Thap
There's nothing wrong with tree growth last time I tried it, but that was quite a while ago and in single player.  Trees in general are quite a performance hit (confirmed by the game devs) so dynamic tree growth can be problematic, especially on servers.  Which is why I disabled it by default and stopped supporting it.  And yes, that sounds about right about the config.

Nymous

No idea sorry.  This is not my mod, I simply revived it because there were people asking for it and I had a bit of free time.

What's the most space efficient way to farm lots of mushrooms?  It feels like the mushrooms will disappear if I don't pick them, but the radius is pretty generous (is it seven blocks in any direction from the central substrate block)? Is it better to grow them vertically using logs?

A friend wants to get into alchemy so he needs a decent supply of mushrooms.

What's wrong with the dynamic tree growth? Also are the first 14 configs meaningless with the growth disabled?

I know someone else had an issue with the horsetail seeds recipe giving dry grass instead, but I'm having a slightly different issue, where in all spaces possible to craft it it doesnt do anything except fopr one, where the horsetail seeds appear for a second when clicked but I can't grab it- I'm 99% sure I don't have any other mods that do anything with horsetail, figured I'd post the issue just in case (edit: at some point I decided to go into creative and give myself however many seeds I'd normally be able to craft, but I finally got around to planting them and it seems I can't put them in soil either)

LordWungus
Thanks for reporting that, I'll need to revisit this issue yet again.  At some point in the 1.20 development cycle the ability to generate resin using the vanilla mechanism changed, and the quick fix for this mod was to increase the chances dramatically.  It may just be that the vanilla code was fixed and I can now remove that "increased chance".

Seems like the resin growth setting causes every single planted pine tree to generate with resin in my world. I also have dana tweaks downloaded but I have the resin growth setting from that mod disabled. I'm not necessarily complaining but leaving this here for anyone who's noticed the same and is curious why it's happening

After a lot of searching I think I narrowed it down to "Ferns are like Grass"  I had tried disabling the recipe but it seems I did not do it correctly and just disabling the mod altogether did it it works now thank you

Louse
I just tested the recipe and it is working for me. Must be another mod causing that but I do not know which one, sorry.

I am unable to craft the horsetail seeds the recipe for them just turns them into dry grass and looking through my mods I can't find anything that would make the recipe conflict either

Qooqey
I always check the log files for warnings/errors prior to release, and am not getting those warnings in 1.20.6
Looks like a mod conflict, probably related to another mod that changes panning drops.

Nymous joeyjoejoe
If you hover over a mushroom it tells you what type of tree it will grow on.
And yes, mushrooms will grow underground.  But not year round, they use all the same rules as vanilla mushrooms (so temperature matters)
And yes, it can take quite a long time to see results.

So far my mushroom farm is only growing grass. Do I need to till the soil, does it take a long time to see results or is subterranean mushrooms a no go?

@SpearAndFang Getting the below warnings on 1.20.6:

21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-smallberrybush-cranberry-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-smallberrybush-blueberry-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-redcurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-blackcurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-whitecurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-catmint-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-forgetmenot-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-edelweiss-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-horsetail-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-heather-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-wilddaisy-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-orangemallow-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-westerngorse-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-cowparsley-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lilyofthevalley-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-blue-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-orange-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-purple-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-red-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-white-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-brown-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-darkgreen-gold in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-darkgreen-gold-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-green-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-lemongreen in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-lemongreen-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-brown-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-darkgreen-gold in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-darkgreen-gold-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-green-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-lemongreen in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-lemongreen-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-rafflesia-brown in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-rafflesia-red in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-smallberrybush-cranberry-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-smallberrybush-blueberry-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-redcurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-blackcurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-whitecurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-catmint-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-forgetmenot-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-edelweiss-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-horsetail-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-heather-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-wilddaisy-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-orangemallow-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-westerngorse-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-cowparsley-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lilyofthevalley-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-blue-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-orange-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-purple-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-red-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-white-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-brown-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-darkgreen-gold in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-darkgreen-gold-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-green-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-lemongreen in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-lemongreen-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-brown-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-darkgreen-gold in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-darkgreen-gold-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-green-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-lemongreen in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-lemongreen-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-rafflesia-brown in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-rafflesia-red in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-smallberrybush-cranberry-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-smallberrybush-blueberry-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-redcurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-blackcurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-bigberrybush-whitecurrant-empty in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-catmint-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-forgetmenot-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-edelweiss-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-horsetail-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-heather-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-wilddaisy-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-orangemallow-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-westerngorse-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-cowparsley-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lilyofthevalley-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-blue-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-orange-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-purple-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-red-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-lupine-white-free in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-brown-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-crimson-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-darkgreen-gold in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-darkgreen-gold-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-green-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-lemongreen in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-small-lemongreen-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-brown-green in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-crimson-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-darkgreen-gold in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-darkgreen-gold-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-green-orange in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-lemongreen in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-croton-medium-lemongreen-crimson in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-rafflesia-brown in panningdrop
21.3.2025 18:08:32 [Warning] Failed resolving a blocks itemdrop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-rafflesia-red in panningdrop

I hope they grow underground, I just finised digging out a 7x7x4 wide cave for a mushroom farm assuming they'd grow better away from the sun.

Will these grow underground, and 365 days a year?

Which mushrooms prefer which trees?

Rowanas
I searched this mods codebase for any mention of firewood and came up empty.  I think you're barking up the wrong tree here.

I'm encountering an issue where some firewood isn't real firewood, as far as firepits are concerned, and I have to store them in a separate place because they won't stack with other firewood. I've got a few mods that could be the culprit, but thought I'd check here first to see if anyone's had the same.

Im not having any planted trees show their growth state. are there any known imcompatabilties that would prevent that?

SpearAndFang
oh, right I forgot that I can only read half of the text and then rush to do the thing with only 50% of the knowledgeXD
aqua vitae it was aqua vitae, that was missing.
Thank you:) Fogrive me for such a silly question.
 

love_flower
I just tried here and it seems ok
I used oak logs, flax grain, and high fert soil to test.
and drygrass and aqua vitae of course. I tried both 1L and 10L of aqua vitae just to confirm that that liquid portion size would not matter.

It maybe is a mod conflict of some sort

Hi:)
SpearAndFang,
thank you for the mode, it is so cool!
I have one issue though, in multiplayer and single game I'm unable to craft the substrate block, by some reason. (all ingridients are right)
Tried to look for the similar issue on the web, but couldn't find.
Please let know if you (or somebody else) have any ideas how to resove.
Thanks!:)

Just curious about the how different the tree growth values are from the base game, this will help me decide how much i want to tweak these values to my preferences, thanks!

The vine growth function is acting weird. When the vine grows, the new section instantly breaks and falls. If someone doesn't go collecting it, it just despawns.

@SpearAndFang
We don't have dapple groves, but we did have living trees enabled and I believe that was the cuplrit.

Working fine for me, both with Living Trees enabled and without.  
Probably a mod like In Dappled Groves conflicting (if living trees are enabled that is).
Also living trees are not enabled by default and unsupported, so in this scenario this mod does not even change tree trunks.

It seems all trees that a player grows, the bottom most log/trunk is invisable.
If you attemp to place a block it shows the health / growth stage, then it turns back into a normal log.

SpearAndFang helo. I dont have this mod , i have your mod, long-term food, xskills, geology additions mod, 40+ mods, but dont have any mods what adding different food becaus dont need them, only your and long-term food. VS have lot of food inside for me.That why i have only this two mods what have good things and have all what i need(seeds/food what dont rott fast). I just have this error after last update. Stay save.

Psychomor
You don't have Expanded Foods? Because that mod probably changes this.  I mentioned it to the mod author already.
In any case, it is needed here for seaweed farming, and there for seaweed cooking.

It's a harmless error that one of us will eventually suppress.

Helo. Have this after update.

[Error] Patch 2 (target: game:blocktypes/plant/aquatic/seaweed.json) in wildfarmingrevival:patches/seaweed.json failed because supplied path /drops is invalid: The json path /drops was not found. No such element 'drops' at the root path

Seaweed is just vanilla seaweed from what i see in crafting book. Dont have any outer mods what can change this. Stay save.

Has anyone tried this mod with Art of Growing and Realistic Farming? I'm curious to know if there's any issues.

AzuliBluespots
oops.  Fixed in the new release.  Thanks!

SpearAndFang

I checked my config file (named WildFarmingConfig119.json) and the seaweed cuttings option is enabled, but somehow I can't even find the variation or recipe, it's like it doesn't exist. I get the tips and middle sections of the seaweed, but not the clippings, and it just won't grow.

(then again, I'm probably a few versions behind. Yep, 1.3.4)

Is this intended or is it a bug?

Junrall
You can disable a lot of thiings via the mod config.  Not sure about "everything".

Tree/flora propogation is disabled by default and unsupported. Use at your own risk. I'd say it's generally ok in single player and when not heavily used, but can quickly get out of control and cause performance issues in a MP environment.

SpearAndFang

Is there a way to disable everything but the tree/flora propagation? 

I'm sorry, I know that scope of this mod is meant to be much more broader than just tree propgation.

SpearAndFang

It might be that .NET issue you mentioned since he is running on Linux, I'll see about those other possible issues too.

Thanks for the help!

Garage
I'm quite sure the mod works fine in multiplayer - unless you are running one of the unstable releases of the game.  It really hasn't changed much over the years.

It's much more likely to be a cache issue, texture atlas issue, multiple version issue, .NET issue (if your friend is on linux especially), or maybe a mod conflict.  The Mod Troubleshooting section at the top of this website touches on a bit of that, as does the Troubleshooting section over on the Primitive Survival page (here: https://mods.vintagestory.at/primitivesurvival).

The server-main.txt and/or client-main.txt logs may also provide a clue as to what's happening.

SpearAndFang

It seems to be causing an issue with multiplayer, I was hosting a server with the latest version and when my friend would try to join, he'd crash. I removed the mod and it resolved the issue.

Aeliaz
It is not a serious issue at all, but is that the latest version of this mod?
Because that was one of the things I was trying to tidy up with the latest release.

Hi SpearAndFang !

Some error at server launch !

```10.2.2025 11:07:13 [Server Warning] Failed resolving a blocks item drop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-treeheath-free in Block wildfarmingrevival:wildplant-flower-treeheath-free
10.2.2025 11:07:13 [Server Warning] Failed resolving a blocks item drop or smeltedstack with code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-treeheath-free in Block wildfarmingrevival:wildplant-flower-treeheath-snow```

Oulana
Sounds like the vanilla texture atlas bug. Add this mod
https://mods.vintagestory.at/autoatlas
should fix you right up

Laerinok
Thanks!

I've found an issue with this mod and Better Ruins mod. Whenever we have both mods installed on single player or server, we get texture conflicts with the chiseled blocks used in the ruins mod. They'll begin displaying a 2x2 checkered pattern with purple and and black on one or more faces. I not sure which sde is causing the issue but I mentioned it under that mod too since they were dealing with a different kind of lost texture bug that brings up the normal white block with a ? in it. This seemed something different and maybe a conflict of names on textures or something?

Hello,
Not essential, but here it is a slight improvement of my fr.json file to better match the vanilla names.

Is this incompatible with wildcraft fruits and nuts? I have both mods and it seems I can never get acorns as a food source, since there are acorns and also oak seeds as different items.

Putting flax grains in the crafting inventory with a wood pan doesnt seem to do anything for me. Havent tested with other plants yet.

Jsaac4000
you mean this?
"Cattail/Papyrus roots can be grown and split into two roots by putting tops in the crafting grid with a full bucket of water."

I have never done this myself, but I just tried it with cattails and it works.

How does the ReedCloning work ?

Foxtrot88
I don't know either, but so far it seems to just be an error that it can't find a seed for the Tree Heath, but it doesn't seem to cause any issues with either mod

VaelophisNyx
No, but if you disable everything else in the modconfig file about all that will be left is the seed stuff

any chance the seed stuff can be split off into its own mod?

KeiroFyre Ohhh, I see, that might be what's causing it, I haven't found any smokable plants on my playthrough to know if it conflicts in any way other than that message

Foxtrot88 I found out it's a compat issue between Pipeleaf and Wild Farming Revival, basically there is no seed for the Tree Heath

Foxtrot88

Hmmm. I'm not seeing "treeheath" in this mod or in vanilla.  Some other mod must be adding this.

Regardless, those errors are quite harmless.  I can modify this mod to prevent those error messages from popping, and will do so for the next release.

Thanks

Whenever I check the logs on loading a save, I get the following errors:
[Error] Grid Recipe 'wildfarmingrevival:flowerseeds': Output Item code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-treeheath-free cannot be resolved
[Error] Grid Recipe 'wildfarmingrevival:flowerseeds': Output Item code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-treeheath-snow cannot be resolved

Hi, is possible to add time control setting to mushroom substrate spawn or command? I change grow time for berries, but mushrooms are still same

That is unfortunate. That being said, in the near future, I suppose I can try to make a compatibility patch for the two. Would be cool to have recipes for mod added plants and flowers!

RollForWizards
Compatible as in will they work together without causing any issues/crashing?  Likely.
Compatible as in fully integrated?  No.

Is this compatible at all with the Floral series?

Absolutely blessed mod, my resin woes are SO over!

UA_Shaman
sorry, no

Dirty_Shisno
glad to hear it

Staniboy
Have you ever removed termites from a mound with a stick?  I haven't but it's some vanilla mechanic.  I can only assume that TermitesEnabled will repopulate the mound afterwards, after some number of days.

What does "TermitesEnabled" do?

This is exactly what I was looking for and then some, thank you!

SpearAndFang
Hello, tell please if the option in the config file is enabled:
"SeaweedGrowthEnabled": true
does this apply to the new algae species added in 1.20?
It wouldn't be bad if it were like that 🙃

Perturbee
Thanks. Based on that selection box, I think that the snow might have actually been the issue, not the plant.

It has corrected itself when a new spell of snow came and went.

This happened in my world, the plant wasn't fully grown (probably stunted while upgrading from RC5 to 6, I wanted to wait for spring to know for sure). I have others that have the same behaviour.

TheRealFlynn
sorry, I just keep this mod updated, crush the bugs, and add a little polish here and there sometimes (when requested).

I actually know very little about the mod.

Fantastic mod. Tysm!

Curious what number would closely resemble 8x tree growth, and the same for 16x tree growth (in vanilla).

update, it was a mod conflict with smithing plus, they had an update 3 days ago that I didn't know about that fixes this exact issue ^^" thanks for the idea to binary search it. ^^

SpearAndFang Thank you for the tips, I'm realitively new to the game, a friend got me into it so I'm still new to what could be a conflict and what could be a bug ^^ I'll definitely try out that binary search and hope I can figure out exactly what's causing a conflict ^^ thank you.

Marshy_Pup
We are too close to a 1.20 stable release for me to want to go back and troubleshoot this, and it really sounds like a mod conflict.

My recommendation: start a test world with just this mod enabled.  If the problem goes away and you have many mods, use a binary search a.k.a "divide-and-conquer" to narrow down what might be causing this.(see the new "Mod Troubleshooting" tab at the top of the page for details.

This is a simple grid recipe so crashing is highly unusual unless some other mod is involved.  So the crash log could definitely provide a clue.  If I could see server-main.txt and client-main.txt I imagine there is something revealing there...Ideally posted on some other site and then linked to here...or hit me up via PM on the official VS Discord (I have the same name over there)

Hey, unsure if anyone else is having this issue, but me and my friends are doing a server on 1.19.8 and using the v1.2.5 version of the this mod. Whenever we try making any seeds from gain (in this case flax seeds from flax grain) We get kicked from the server saying "You were disconnected from this server. An action you (or your client) did caused an unhandled exception".

Even in single player, when I try to make the seeds, it bugs out, sometimes makes them, sometimes dupes the grain and makes the seeds, sometimes deletes the seeds after I make them and the grain is consumed, or rather appears to be consumed. But if I click the empty space, ALL the grain appears again. And the lack of seeds makes sense.

Unsure as to why this is happening, and wondering if downpatching to an older 1.19.8 would fix this. (tried v1.2.4 but had similar results.) I'm also unsure if the issue is from a mod conflict OR this mod specifically. Any help is appreciated ^^

Edit: didn't include any log text, as I'm unsure which log(s) is/are needed for more info on this.

Laytard
yes. I do not like this at all.  It is my biggest complaint with the mod.
But I only revived this mod because someone asked nicely (and I was bored that day).
I did not want to change it from what Jake had intended.

Having said that, I did add the whole ResinGrowthEnabled mechanism...

I know we are allowed to score the trees, I just wasn't sure if we were meant to score every single log on just one tree.

seems very strong to just harvest like 14 resin on every cycle

Laytard
Oh I'm sure Jake intended that because he added it to his mod.

But he also added the ability to disable it!  Just set LogScoringEnabled to false in the config file (see the configuration section above for more info).

"LogScoringEnabled": Pine and acacia logs can be cut to leak resin

If that's too extreme for you, you could ALSO set ResinGrowthEnabled to true.  It's a bit of a middle ground.

"ResinGrowthEnabled": false by default - set it to true to allow PLANTED trees to also grow resin at the same rate as vanilla trees

Hey not sure if this is intended but you can cut every log on a pine tree, allowing you to collect ridiculous amounts of resin.

Darkx
This mod should fix that issue right up
https://mods.vintagestory.at/autoatlas

It's a weird crash with RC. 5. It would work fine by itself but not when combined with better crates or extra info. It crash was caused when looking at the shields in the inventory. Do ask me how or why. All I know is when I removed it the client side crash stopped. 

DejFidOFF
Thank you for reporting this.  It was working, but only very rarely.  I increased the chances of resin growth a lot in the latest release.
What I could not solve is that resin growth on pine will only happen now 7 blocks or higher from the bottom of the tree. I am not sure what changed in vanilla to cause this - probably performance related - but it does not make any sense to me and I could not figure out why.

But you will have plenty of resin again, just high up in the planted trees.

SpearAndFang

Hey o/ I think

Does anyone know, is this for version 1.20 only?

JK JK! Love the mod as always! Super impressed how fast you got this out! 

I see, so it was probably the temperature

Auro
temperature is the only requirement.  I've grown mushrooms under the conditions you describe.
you could look in assets\wildfarmingrevival\blocktypes\wood\trunk.json for the deets.
if I was to ballpark it, I'd say something like 5C-30C

a few days seems pretty optimistic for mushroom growth, unless you read that somewhere. I would think it's going to take longer. It relies on vanilla mushroom growing mechanic.

Do mushroom farms have any temperature, spacing or area requirements? I dug a room small enough to become a cellar (so I can both farm and store mushrooms in the same room), placed the mushroom substrate at the bottom, put a mushroom that grows on Oak on the substrate, then placed 5 Oak logs on top of the substrate, reaching the ceiling of the small room and waited a few days, but so far no mushroom has spawned on the logs. Other than the substrate and the logs the rest of the room is pure stone, I know ground mushrooms need dirt, but I wanna grow only the ones that grow on logs.

Marshy
Well that's not good.  Thank you so much for the heads up, it is something that I will definitely fix for the next release.

In 1.19, (mod version 1.2.5) when planted flower seeds get snowed on, they become the "-snow" variant. Breaking these gives a unique "-snow" seed item (e.g. wildfarmingrevival:item-wildseeds-flower-orangemallow-snow) that doesn't stack with regular seeds. Is there a way to make them drop the normal seed item instead?

SpearAndFang 

Hey! Out of cursoity, are there any bugs associated with the Mushroom farming on version 1.19.8, I have a private playthrough going currently with a friend, and we tried out the mushroom farming, the day counters are stuck at the values they started at, and refuse to tick down, would you happen to know why that would be the case? 

(update!:  I actually got the solution fixed already, nevermind!)

Kriky
I'm sorry but I do not understand what you are saying. I think you are talking about grid recipes but this mod has really standard (vanilla) grid recipes, so...
If you can give me instructions on how I might recreate an issue I might be able to help.  Or you can look me up on the official VS Discord (I have the same name there), we can more easily share pictures and stuff.

Hi.

Sometimes it happens in the inventory that when I click the mouse to icon turn into seeds of flowers or trees and they multiply in different ways. For example, my big flower pot disappeared and flower seeds were in its place.

Hi friend, I love your mods, I recently finished translating Primitive Survival and I've already finished translating this one, I'll be in touch with you soon on Discord (es-419)

VincenzoDiNeva
No idea sorry. You could try disabling "Harsh Saplings" in the configuration file I suppose.

I added the version for 1.2 by accident on 1.19.8, and I'm just realizing there's an error when checking for sapling growth every tick... Is there any way to undo this without rolling back?

👍

SpearAndFang

For the next update ;)
The french translation for the two new seeds :

"item-wildseeds-fern-tallfern": "Spores de fougère arborescente",
"block-wildplant-fern-tallfern": "Fougère arborescente en croissance",
"item-wildseeds-silvertorchcactus": "Graines de cactus torche d'argent",
"block-wildplant-silvertorchcactus": "Cactus torche d'argent en croissance"

Laerinok
Awesome, I've added it...thanks yet again!

SpearAndFang

Great ! So this is the fr.json

Laerinok
Thank you - I have fixed the code for the next release - so it will simply use the vanilla seed descriptions for the translations instead.

SpearAndFang

Hello,
I am updating the fr.json and it seems that some seed's description keys are missing. I don't find them in the en.json and it's still in english in game. Or maybe it's due to the the new v1.20. of VS (but vanilla seeds description are translated)...

BrownishStorm
No. Trees break normally.

Now if you really WANT to break a log and not have the tree fall, use a saw instead of an axe (which is a vanilla thing btw).

Question: Does this mod make it so that when you break a log at the base of the tree, the entire tree doesnt fall down anymore? It seems like it might based on the discription and so just asking this clarifiying question.

GaylordZap
I'm pretty sure that mushroom farming only works with vanilla logs.

SpearAndFang

Awesome! I'm playing with the Floral Zone mods, do the logs in those mods work for mushroom farming? In particular if any would be recognized as 'tropical' in nature? Related question, do the mushrooms generate on the thinner log blocks that trees like willows and alders will have?

GaylordZap
I have indeed grown shrooms in a cave.

Are there any environmental factors to note when growing mushrooms? Translation: can I grow them shrooms in a cave?

Dracomancer
I will add those to the to-do list

Hello, First of all I want to thank you for keeping this mod alive. It saves lifes for people who likes to decorate and use flowers more broadly on their builds.

With that may I ask you to add seeds for tall ferns and silver torch cactus? They seem to me bissing completely from this mod and I really wish I could farm them.

_Koza
Sorry, the mechanism that would allow that (living trees) is disabled by default and no longer supported by me.
But yeah, with a bit of a rework of the c# code I suspect that it would be possible.

SpearAndFang

Is there a way to make it so the last stage of certain tree growth has a chance to end in the larger variant of the same tree type? Like the large oaks, large kapoks, & old kapoks?

For example, oak trees use "englishoak" until the final growth stage which swithces over to "oldenglishoak"?
Either that or a way to make it a very rare chance for the oak sapling to use the "oldenglishoak" generator from the start? (as well as the other large tree types)

SpearAndFang

Thanks for your help. It works. No need to have "LivingTreesEnabled" true.

DejFidOFF
I don't have much experience with modding mods, but I think you can take a copy of this mods saplings.json patch, put it in a compatibility folder structure (see the link below), and change the temperatures in it. Then the json patch in your mod should completely overwrite the json patch in this mod.

Details at the top of this page
https://wiki.vintagestory.at/index.php/Modding:CompatibilityLib

SpearAndFang

thank you, I will test that. I hope it will works how I intended.

And is there a way how I can change that temperatures to fit my server?

DejFidOFF
That sounds about right to me, but it still must be enabled by setting "HarshSaplingsEnabled" to true.
And it may only apply when "LivingTreesEnabled" is also set to true, idk.

SpearAndFang

hello o/ in sapnigs.json  the setting "path": "/attributes/minTempByType"

"*-birch-*": -7,
"*-oak-*": -5,
"*-maple-*": -7,
"*-pine-*": -18,

this values means the birch sapling will grow from seed to tree even it´s -7°C, oak -5°C etc etc?

DejFidOFF
Sorry I'm not really interested in doing that. This mod already has a way to grow mushrooms and I've got many other things I'm working on these days.

SpearAndFang

please add mushroom seeds to grow single mushroom ( same mechanics as with flowers but from 1 mushroom 1-2 seeds )

Why? Because in those dayes you cant sell mushroom for growing, just because of spoilage

DejFidOFF

Can't you just change VineGrowthEnabled to true (in the configuration)?

I tested it when I was working on vines the other day and it seems to work ok.  You must make vine tips in the crafting grid and then place those iirc, if you want to grow your own.

I want to leave it disabled by default because it may effect performance, especially on servers.

Any chance to bring vine regrow to live?

SpearAndFang Awesome, that you updated it so quickly. I really appreciate it. 

Edit: everything works flawlessly without any hiccups on a modded server. Just tested it. Thanks again. :)

oops
if you are seeing any weirdness on startup then download the latest version
my bad

dashr

New version up.  Turns out that those duplicate vine entries are vanilla - nothing to do with this mod.
Regardless, I did my best to clean that up to make it less confusing. It's not perfect but my goal was to only lightly touch the hot mess that is vanilla vines...so it doesn't cause any problems for anyone in the future.

I also changed the vine tip crafting recipe as per your suggestion. Thanks!

SpearAndFang thank you. Looking forward to it. I missed the message, since the @ didn't work :D

By the way, I edited the vinetrimming.json in assets\wildfarmingrevival\recipes\grid of your mod.
Maybe that's a change you want to implement too. If not, that's perfectly fine. I just felt like it would be a bit more immersive if the vine tip crafting used a bit of water. Yours is using the “requiresQuantity”: 10 - (mine is using "requiresLitres:1" (number can be changed anytime to a lower one) - and so you can use a bucket an infinite number of times.

imgur.com/a/3aPM5US

@dashr
thanks, and for the thorough report
I will add it to the to-do list

Great mod SpearAndFang

Just a quick headsup. It would be awesome if you could replace the normal vine tip handbook entry. With this mod installed it shows two - presumably because of the recipe.

Edit Screenshots: imgur.com/a/IxfqtH7

Your vine tip: https://imgur.com/a/WSXLs5I

Vanilla: imgur.com/a/M65NxTK

SpearAndFang

You are a star! Thank you so much 😁

JamminBT
I planted several redwood seeds in creative mode and then advanced time rapidly - when they grew every single one of them skewed in a South-East direction, So anecdotaly I believe that this is the correct answer. 
Tree growth relies heavily on vanilla code (even for living trees), so I imagine that even without this mod or without living trees enabled, the same thing will happen.

I also tried to influence the skew by placing blocks in the way, but they simply stomped over the placed blocks and still skewed South-East.

Hi Spear. I have a quick question about tree growth. It may be a bit difficult to explain what I mean so I'll do my best. When Living Trees is enabled, do 2x2 base trees (like large Oak trees) have a specific orientation in which they grow? For instance, if I plant an Oak seed with the intention of having a 2x2 as decoration, will the tree grow in any of the 4 diagonal directions (North-East, South-East, South-West or North-West) randomly to make a 2x2 or, for example, always skew towards "South-East"?

Cheers in advance 👍

Chrizzlybear
Thank you!

Hi, i updated the german translation.

wildfarmingrevival/lang/de.json

game/lang/de.json

Marlim
Who's writing that code, me or you?
Because it sounds rather difficult...

Regarding your comment about disabling the dynamic/self propagating trees option, I was thinking about the possibility of optimizing this functionality. Considering this, I propose that this mechanic only works when a player is rendering the chunk where the tree is located.
What do you think about this? SpearAndFang

Kaidra808

Unfortunately I was never able to get modded trees to work for Wild Farming for the temperature growth restrictions. 

For the growth stages I would imagine no modded trees would be able to be supported, since seperate growth stages (and tree states) would have to be built for each tree.

MadGnome

I've turned that on, and it's working as it should for the vanilla trees! But I'd love it if I could get the bearnut and poplar trees to spread on their own as well. I tried adding them to the trunk.json file mimicking the format of the other trees, but then the mod wouldn't load in game at all.

Kaidra808

I was trying to get the temperature requirements to apply to modded trees, so I could get trees to only grow in certain areas, but wasn't able to get it to work. 
If you want the dynamic tree growth/spreading you should be able to do it in the config by changing the following entry to true.

"LivingTreesEnabled": false,

MadGnome Did you have any luck getting the wildcraft trees to be dynamic? I really want to get some of those trees to self propagate, but I'm not sure how to go about setting that up...

Is there any possibility at all that you could add compatibility with the Floral Zones series of mods? No rush of course! I just adore the plants from those mods and would love to decorate my base with them, even the ones that you can't normally pick up. Edit: Also, forgot to mention: I'm Flamy, a Dragon (my nickname on the VS server is now genderneutralnoun, my Discord username, so you can check) and I'd honestly prefer if you credited me by "genderneutralnoun" than "Flamy, a Dragon".

Ahh, that's odd then. 
I did see the note above for the disabled by default portion, and had not enabled that but I wasn't aware the temperature growth requirements for tree farming was included in that since the temperature values seemed to be working for the Vanilla Trees.

MadGnome

hmmm. I'm pretty sure that trunk.json is only used when Dynamic/self propogating trees is enabled in the modconfig file. Unfortunately this feature of the mod was causing quite a bit of grief for multiplayer servers (performance issues mostly iirc, and the occasional crash) so I finally decided to disable it by default (see the IMPORTANT: note above).

I'm trying to add trees from Wildcraft and the Floral Zones to the Min/Max Tempby Type tables in the wildfarmingrevival/blocktypes/wood/trunk.json file with no success. I see the Vanilla trees names are taken from the treegenproperties.json from the 'Generator' field, but when I add similar ones from Wildcraft and the Floral zones to the list the Min/MaxTempByType requirements never work.

Example, from wildcraft.

In the trunk.json I place it after the acacia in the same formatting to no avail.

Is there different/additional requirements for wildfarming revival to recognize/add modded trees to the minTempByType/maxTempByType tables, or am I just doing something wrong perhaps?

Hi there!  I believe the mod is crashing Vintage Story.  It's weird, because the mod is not mentioned anywhere in the crash report, but the game consistently crashes when I install the mod, and stops crashing when I remove the mod.

One curious thing I noticed is that the mod makes reference to D:\Projects\VintageStory\configlib\configlib\source\ConfigLibModSystem.cs, which is not on my system.   Is this a filepath on your system?  But even curiouser, the actual thing that caused the crash is: System.UnauthorizedAccessException: Access to the path 'C:\Users\p\AppData\Roaming\VintagestoryData\ModConfig', which does exist on my system and is accessible, so the unauthorized access exception is mysterious.

Crash report is here.

Edit: I have something definitive that is almost certain to help figure out what's happening.  I uninstalled the mod (version 1.1.9) and installed the previous version (version 1.1.8) which seemed to work just fine.  So whatever is going on with my game, it was introduced in version 1.1.9.

conninator2000
ha no, no worries.  If you mod some stuff up I will gladly add it to this one.

SpearAndFang

Thanks for the reply! Hope I didn't come off as pushy - definitely don't expect you to be bending over backwards for new suggestions - especially considering that most of your effort with this is taken up by keeping it up to date. Thanks for the suggestion though. There is an option to turn off grass trample, but its a cool feature to see where rabbits/animals went through the trampled grass when the visibility is low. I was worried it might be a bigger issue than it is, but grass grows back somewhat fast - just no way to keep a consistant amount around the base as I am use to :)

If I have the energy to, I might make a mod for that (and maybe creating tule roots too) since I couldn't find anything like that in the mods either (which is why i ended up here!)

If I do end up modding those 2 recipes, would you want to add it to this mod or rather I keep it in a separate mod on the db

@SpearAndFang
If you need, I have prepared a modlist:
[Notification] Mods, sorted by dependency: aculinaryartillery, emotemenureload, fantasycreatures, pipeleaf, primitivesurvival, game, alchemy, alloycalculator, animationmanagerlib, expandedfoods, fromgoldencombs, hudclock, sailboat, medievalexpansion, moreanimals, pelaguswinds, petai, prospecttogether, storageoptions, creative, survival, vsvillage, wildfarmingrevival, workbenchexpansion, bullseye-continued, cats, foxtaming, wolftaming

And yes, maybe it’s Wildcraft. Thank you

Mayadzuko
thanks!  Not critical for sure, and I'm assuming this is a bit of a mod conflict - Wildcraft Fruits and Nuts perhaps. 

conninator2000
appreciated! I like the idea but have little motivation to work on something like that.  I went looking for another mod that did such a thing but could not find one.  Perhaps the Natural Trail Mod modder would consider this request, since they're the one that's killing all the grass?  ;)

Hello there. Thanks for the mod, I really like it. But my console complains about this:

[Error] Grid Recipe 'wildfarmingrevival:flowerseeds': Output Item code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-treeheath-free cannot be resolved
[Error] Grid Recipe 'wildfarmingrevival:flowerseeds': Output Item code wildfarmingrevival:wildseeds-flower-treeheath-snow cannot be resolved

I understand that this is most likely not critical, but I consider it necessary to inform you that some recipes have broken.

Hey, absolutely love this mod. Its been a staple of every playthrough since I found it - glad to see how you have kept it up to date and bug free. Would it be possible to add some kind of recipe for making grass seeds? I know they can grow randomly on grass tiles if they have sunlight/space etc - but with the trails mod that creates trails as you walk routes, it can be pretty easy to trample a lot of the grass before you end up needing to cut it - and having some kind of way to farm it would be really neat!

I can change it by altering the trails mod settings but it would be a really interesting feature to help organize some kind of grass farming!

@GreenPig
In Windows browse to:  %appdata%\VintagestoryData\ModConfig
Use a text editor i.e. notepad to edit the file: WildFarmingConfig119.json

The setting you are looking for is "LivingTreesEnabled":

Also, see the Configuration section above.

@SpearAndFang

Don't know how I missed it, sorry and thank you very much.
 One more question, where can I find the modconfig file or how exactly is named and in what program should I open it?

Abduwitdapoo
Huh.  It's working for me, and nobody else has reported a problem.

wont work for me i tried 1.17 and 1.18

@GreenPig
Copy paste from above
IMPORTANT: Dynamic/self propogating trees and vine growth are now disabled by default, considered experimental only, and unsupported - use at your own risk.

You can enable this via the modconfig file

Guys, can you please help me with one thing?

My trees have no growth stages displayed and I did a test on creative to speed up the time and see if they change or something and nothing happended.
I tried to look for something similar in the rest of the comments but no luck.

Does it work for the rest of you or is just me?

SpearAndFang

ooh thank you, never went to far.

Aqua Vitae (twice distilled alcohol)

How I can get aquua vitae?

Yeah.. it's a damn shame this mod isn't compatible with Ancient tools

Were there any plans to add the new Tule to be able to create seeds with its roots? The roots just came with the 1.19.4 update and it would be amazing to be able to create more like you can with cat tails! Love the mod, keep up the great work

@Wizard76,
It's working fine for me. The only time I've seen something like this is when dynamic/self propogating trees are enabled.  When the trees go through a growth stage the scored trees disappear.  But I've disabled those living trees in the mod config and do not recommend anyone enable it again.  ever.

I noticed when scoring a pine tree that it does work, but when I relog back into the game, the scoring has disappeared. Has anyone else noticed that?

Kiladin

The mod that has tree scoring enabled is Ancient Tools, by Taska.

So yeah, its a me issue cause apparantly readin is hard.  I did not realize somehow that i couldnt turn on living trees and vines.  but its working now.  Thanks

bringitonwimps
I don't know what to tell you.  That crash should only happen if you enabled living trees (which is unsupported - see IMPORTANT section above), or I guess if the world had parts of it generated with a previous version of this mod (which I guess could be fixed by regenerating the offending chunks - the /wgen command - use with caution).

The thing that crashed (BlockEntityTrunk) simply shouldn't exist anymore.

Fwiw, Primitive Survival does not have tree scraping, and shouldn't conflict with this mod at all.

i rermoverd the mod and our crashing stopped.. really like this mod so ill be keeping my eyes open for any ideas... thanks

i do have primitive survival mod which has tree scraping, and it is on there and i turned it off on survival and i do know there are scraped trees in area.  idk if this could be a conflict

It appears that wild farming is causing this crash when we are in a specific area of thew map.  one my players crashed and i got close to the area he instant crashes in and now i cant get loaded back in game without instant crashing.

Running on 64 bit Windows 10.0.22621.0 with 32689 MB RAM
Game Version: v1.19.3 (Stable)
2/6/2024 7:01:18 PM: Critical error occurred in the following mod: wildfarmingrevival@1.1.7
Loaded Mods: aculinaryartillery@1.0.16, carpet@1.0.2, cellardoor@1.4.0, chiseltools@1.10.2, craftingtable@0.5.0, creaturescan@1.0.6, decor@1.0.13, effectshud@0.2.10, flourbags@1.0.2, caninae@1.0.10, machairodontinae@1.0.1, pantherinae@1.0.9, HangingOilLamps@1.0.1, millwright@1.1.4, leadroof@1.3.4, newworldgianttortoises@1.1.1, pieontheshelf@1.0.0, potontheshelf@1.0.0, primitivesurvival@3.4.5, somethinginthewater@1.19.3, ssppvv@1.0.5, thecritterpack@0.8.5, translocatorengineeringredux@1.4.9, game@1.19.3, wallpaper@1.0.0, abcsreborn@0.1.7, alchemy@1.6.23, ancienttools@1.5.12, animalcages@3.0.2, egocaribautomapmarkers@3.1.0, betterruins@0.3.2, blacksmithenhancements@1.0.4, butchering@1.4.4, carryon@1.7.4, commonlib@2.3.2, decoclock@0.9.3, expandedfoods@1.6.8, fieldsofsalt@1.2.0, fromgoldencombs@1.4.25, hudclock@3.4.0, sailboat@1.2.7, lc@1.0.0, lavoisier@1.3.0, medievalexpansion@3.13.1, meteoricexpansion@1.2.5, moreanimals@1.3.3, moreplaster@1.0.2, petai@2.2.3, playerlist@1.7.4, scarecrow@1.4.2, simplestep@1.1.5, stonebakeoven@1.1.3, stonerailings@1.1.0, storageoptions@1.0.2, creative@1.19.3, vsinstruments@1.2.6, survival@1.19.3, wildfarmingrevival@1.1.7, woodbarrels@1.0.4, woodchests@1.1.0, xlib119@0.7.4-dev.119, awearablelight@1.1.1, cats@2.0.1, chemistrylib@1.1.5, em@2.5.0, feverstonehorses@1.6.0, gespileslib@1.2.0, morefloors@1.4.0, playercorpse@1.9.0, simplewinddirection@1.0.2, slanted_display_cases@1.1.0, stainedbeams@1.0.0, xskills119@0.7.5-dev.1191, yeet@4.0.1, bricklayers@2.5.0, gespilesgran@1.0.1, kosphotography@1.3.4
System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object.
at WildFarmingRevival.ModSystem.BlockEntityTrunk.Regenerate(Single dt) in C:\net7repos\wildfarmingrevival\wildfarmingrevival\ModSystem\BlockEntity\BlockEntityTrunk.cs:line 213
at Vintagestory.Common.EventManager.TriggerGameTick(Int64 ellapsedMilliseconds, IWorldAccessor world) in VintagestoryLib\Common\EventManager.cs:line 57
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.MainRenderLoop(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 831
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.MainGameLoop(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 723
at Vintagestory.Client.GuiScreenRunningGame.RenderToPrimary(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\MainMenu\Screens\GuiScreenRunningGame.cs:line 163
at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.Render(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 675
at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.OnNewFrame(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 650
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientPlatformWindows.window_RenderFrame(FrameEventArgs e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\GameWindow.cs:line 88
at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.GameWindow.Run()
at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.Start(ClientProgramArgs args, String[] rawArgs) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 318
at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.<>c__DisplayClass9_0.<.ctor>b__1() in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 128
at Vintagestory.ClientNative.CrashReporter.Start(ThreadStart start) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\ClientNative\CrashReporter.cs:line 93

Event Log entries for Vintagestory.exe, the latest 3
==================================
{ TimeGenerated = 2/6/2024 7:00:39 PM, Site = , Source = Application Error, Message = Faulting application name: Vintagestory.exe, version: 1.19.3.0, time stamp: 0x65310000
Faulting module name: openal32.dll, version: 1.23.0.0, time stamp: 0x63dd31ad
Exception code: 0x40000015
Fault offset: 0x00000000000df046
Faulting process id: 0x0x5eac
Faulting application start time: 0x0x1da5960d2617fcf
Faulting application path: C:\Users\Cheddar\AppData\Roaming\Vintagestory\Vintagestory.exe
Faulting module path: C:\Users\Cheddar\AppData\Roaming\Vintagestory\Lib\openal32.dll
Report Id: d8833c86-5911-401c-ab11-492c4d03bae7
Faulting package full name:
Faulting package-relative application ID: }
--------------
{ TimeGenerated = 2/6/2024 7:00:37 PM, Site = , Source = Application Error, Message = Faulting application name: Vintagestory.exe, version: 1.19.3.0, time stamp: 0x65310000
Faulting module name: openal32.dll, version: 1.23.0.0, time stamp: 0x63dd31ad
Exception code: 0x40000015
Fault offset: 0x00000000000df046
Faulting process id: 0x0x9270
Faulting application start time: 0x0x1da5960fa23f8cb
Faulting application path: C:\Users\Cheddar\AppData\Roaming\Vintagestory\Vintagestory.exe
Faulting module path: C:\Users\Cheddar\AppData\Roaming\Vintagestory\Lib\openal32.dll
Report Id: 22a4af67-d072-4428-9c6a-bf2c043eba10
Faulting package full name:
Faulting package-relative application ID: }
--------------
{ TimeGenerated = 2/6/2024 6:58:53 PM, Site = , Source = Application Error, Message = Faulting application name: Vintagestory.exe, version: 1.19.3.0, time stamp: 0x65310000
Faulting module name: openal32.dll, version: 1.23.0.0, time stamp: 0x63dd31ad
Exception code: 0x40000015
Fault offset: 0x00000000000df046
Faulting process id: 0x0x823c
Faulting application start time: 0x0x1da5960af880198
Faulting application path: C:\Users\Cheddar\AppData\Roaming\Vintagestory\Vintagestory.exe
Faulting module path: C:\Users\Cheddar\AppData\Roaming\Vintagestory\Lib\openal32.dll
Report Id: 782058ce-52d7-4fc3-aa5d-bcce4233c620
Faulting package full name:
Faulting package-relative application ID: }

@Xaro
There's nothing to spawn.  I added it to my own world after 200 hours.
Of course it never hurts to make a backup before adding new mods.

Quick question - If I add this mod to an existing server, will things spawn in already loaded chunks or not? Should I re-roll my server?

Yanazake

"Tree scoring is already available elsewhere".  Would you please share which mod it is that has tree scoring?  That was the one feature I was pining for when this mod was not yet updated.

Cpt_C0nfus3d
Aww hell, so do I.  I checked my logs twice before releasing so I'm not sure how I missed that.  Thanks

XurxoMF
Correct. At least for the foreseeable future. 

Just to know. The unsupported features will not be updated/fixed if they are not working right?

I have this error in the log...

4.2.2024 12:17:20 [Error] Patch 21 (target: wildfarmingrevival:recipes/grid/vinetrimming.json) in wildfarmingrevival:patches/enabledpatches.json failed because supplied path /0/enabled is invalid: The json path /0/enabled was not found. No such element '0' at the root path

I seriously would if I knew how to code or make mods for VS in Linux at all. There's too much of a learning curve here and I'm already too invested in the translation department. :/

new "lighter" version up, 1.19 only.

Id offer to take on the 1.19 developement and testing - and some bug fixing attached, but for the same reason as you, id not want to be the dedicated owner/maintainer of it going forward

I agree with Yanazake, I think ideally merging the seed extraction, cattail roots, and perhaps mushroom, into smth like Primitive Survival, and leaving the broader systems changes with tree framing and other vine/vine related growing in its own mod. I also think there are probably a larger group of people who desire those features, but might not want the changes/addition of tree growth requirements (and yes its configurable to turn off, but it feels like its the big feature of the mod and the rest are QOL or sprinkles on top). 

There's stuff in this that's absolutely necessary, but those are the things that weren't already implemented elsewhere.

They are mainly seed extraction (SPECIALLY from flowers), root splitting, plant reproduction, seaweed growing and mushroom farming. Aside from the seaweed one, the rest should be just extra items and recipes. Tree scoring is already available elsewhere, and the growth of trees is cool and organic, but ultimately very intensive on the world.

I'd say add these to primitive survival with making sure that you can't just forever split cattail roots - split once and plant them, no re-splitting - since it's also very popular, and we're done with this. Heck, even without the mushroom and seaweed parts, we just want a way to get seeds from crops and flowers and fruits.

Now were getting somewhere.  Volunteers?
The thing is, I support 7 mods and not to brag but they've all reached a certain degree of popularity. And it's burning me out.  My options are

(a) merge it (or at least parts of it) with another one of my mods so it is more manageable
(b) drop it completely
(c) have someone take ownership of it.

Reviving this mod was really me doing Flamy a favor (because they asked nicely and I was feeling generous that day). And a nod to JakeCool for all his hard work around here.  I didn't realize how much tlc this mod needed, and it's not a part of my regular loadout when I play VS.

Hell, there's already a pull request available to make it 1.19 compatible. 
https://github.com/SpearAndFang/wildfarmingrevival/pull/4
Just need someone to build and upload it to the modDB, and provide support. Then maybe iron out some of the outstanding issues.

If you all know he/she doesn't want to update it then its time for a 3rd person to take over it.

I know you said you don't want to update the mod but... please!!!! This is mod is one of the best mods on the moddb and we need it updated to the 1.19 ;-;

The mod is great, love it and it just doesn't feel the same without it.

As the game has moved to v1.19, I do hope that this mod follows. :)

Confirming there's stuff broken in the mod. At the very least, seed extraction from flowers isn't working, probably because the model is different now and the old one doesn't exist.
Sadly seems like Spear and Fang won't work on this anymore.

At least the rest of their content is pretty great, so we'll have to do without a few things.

1.19 pleaseeee 🙏

Phraxas
Yeah I completely agree. The seed extraction and pine tree scoring should already be in the base game, but having them in a mod like this makes the mod essential to playthroughs. 

Will this mod be updated to 1.19?

Perhaps a Wild Farming Lite would be more manageable?  I feel like the seed extraction, seaweed growing, mushroom farming, and pine/acacia tree scoring is absolutely necessary for a good VS experience.  It seems to me like the tree farming is getting a bit out of scope due to its management requirements.

I really don't understand why these aren't Vanilla features.

Hey I read in the comments that you're considering abandoning this mod. I'm aware my word won't mean much, but please don't. Your work is incredible and has legitimately made the game better. 

I've had to remove and replace about 100 forest floor from a 20 tree orchard in under a year

this is just far, far too much

One can only hope D;

I'm inclined to agree - this mod is one of the necessary mods I use every time I play this game - I really hope it doesn't become abandoned!

I really hope this gets an update for 1.19. This is one of those mods that's almost essential with how much gameplay it adds in. 

@SpearAndFang
"Agreed. I'm actually thinking about abandoning this mod, hence no 1.19 version."

Man id love to have this in 1.19. Seems like it shouldnt be abandoned D:

Ok then I know. Yes, I actually use the mod.

Cpt_C0nfus3d
You maybe have the mod "In Dappled Groves?"
regardless, that error is just failing to add a gizmo called the "Administrator Axe", a creative only axe that I use for playtesting, and will not efffect gameplay - so you can just ignore it.

I have found this error in my log.

3.1.2024 07:08:44 [Error] Patch 6 (target: game:itemtypes/tool/axe-metal.json) in wildfarmingrevival:patches/wfr-survival-itemtypes-tool-axe-metal.json failed, following Exception was thrown: Index must be within the bounds of the List. (Parameter 'index')

Coleroni
Agreed. I'm actually thinking about abandoning this mod, hence no 1.19 version.

this mod has cool features, it needs WORK. optimize your mod please.

MexiBlob
Yes thank you.
Elfini13
Wild farming is the old version of the mod.  Do not use that, it will not work.  Wild farming revival is the replacement.

@Elfini13 from my understanding, Wild Farming Revival is the updated version of wild farming. you don't need wild farming installed in order for Wild Farming Revival to work. it worked perfectly for me on v1.18.15 (Stable)

Will Wild Farming Revival work without Wild Farming ?

Hello,
I've no clue why wildfarmingrevival has suddenly decided to crash my game, but it has and I am too clueless to understand why. Can someone point out what the problem could be?

My Crash-Log:

Game Version: v1.18.15 (Stable)
16/12/2023 11:14:58: Critical error occurred in the following mod: wildfarmingrevival@1.1.6
Loaded Mods: aculinaryartillery@1.0.15, betterbricks@1.1.1, bettercrates@1.6.0, betterruins@0.2.4, bettersticks@1.0.0, cellardoor@1.4.0, claycasting@1.1.1, driedpeat@1.0.3, extrachests@1.7.0, HangingOilLamps@1.0.1, primitivesurvival@3.3.0, quicklimepk@1.0.0, game@1.18.15, abcsreborn@0.1.3, alchemy@1.6.20, ancienttools@1.5.11, egocaribautomapmarkers@2.6.0, beehivekiln@1.5.1, betterfirepit@1.1.2, betterjonasdevices@1.0.2, betterstonepath@1.0.2, blacksmithenhancements@1.0.3, blocksoverlay@2.5.0, butchering@1.1.5, carryon@1.6.1, clearerquartz@1.0.0, commonlib@2.2.0, expandedfoods@1.6.8, farmlanddropssoil@1.4.0, fromgoldencombs@1.4.25, hudclock@3.4.0, sailboat@1.2.4, knapster@2.6.3, metaltongs@1.1.3, postsandbeams@1.2.0, prospecttogether@1.2.4, rivers@1.1.1, sharablewaypoints@1.3.2, simplecloth@1.0.1, sprucedup@1.0.3, stonebakeoven@1.1.1, storageoptions@1.0.1, vtpp@1.1.0, creative@1.18.15, survival@1.18.15, wildfarmingrevival@1.1.6, woodenfortifications@0.0.4, metalrecovery@0.1.19-pre.1, simplewinddirection@1.0.2, stonequarry@3.1.7
System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object.
at WildFarmingRevival.ModSystem.BlockEntityTrunk.Regenerate(Single dt)
at Vintagestory.Common.EventManager.TriggerGameTick(Int64 ellapsedMilliseconds, IWorldAccessor world) in VintagestoryLib\Common\EventManager.cs:line 84
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.MainRenderLoop(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 809
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.MainGameLoop(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 711
at Vintagestory.Client.GuiScreenRunningGame.RenderToPrimary(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\MainMenu\Screens\GuiScreenRunningGame.cs:line 163
at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.Render(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 668
at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.OnNewFrame(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 643
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientPlatformWindows.window_RenderFrame(FrameEventArgs e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\GameWindow.cs:line 77
at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.GameWindow.Run()
at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.Start(ClientProgramArgs args, String[] rawArgs) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 313
at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.<>c__DisplayClass9_0.<.ctor>b__1() in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 129
at Vintagestory.ClientNative.CrashReporter.Start(ThreadStart start) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\ClientNative\CrashReporter.cs:line 93

EDIT: I finally found that this has to do with Living Trees. It seems a sappling I planted for regrowth in the middle of nowhere has grown and wanted to check for conditions to grow further? Probably? In any case changing the config and yeeting harsh-sapplings and livingtrees to false fixed it for me. I would've liked to play with it, but I guess I'll either wait for a fix or just live with the vanilla version of trees.

We have some trees that appear to have skipped a growth stage.
I have 2 theories as to what may have caused this, either the chunk needs to be loaded for growth to occur properly, and somehow the tree missed a stage but then as the chunk was loaded later on it finished the next growth stage, or, the more likely explaination is tree growth could be checked when chunks are loaded, but then can only physically occur if the chunk is in entity tracking range, which is by default significanty lower than view distance.
i can test this second theory by raising or lowering entity tracking range in test worlds, and will do so, but if raising entity tracking range to meet view distance fixes the issue its not ideal as that will have a very significant performance impact on large multplayer servers.
I also have a minor issue, manually planted trees have the "Wild farming revival- health 100%" tooltip at the trunk, while worldgen trees dont, this is an issue on pvp/anarchy servers as it gives away which trees are natural and which ones were likely planted by players. I cant find an easy way to remove this label but I think ideally worldgen trees need the base log to have the same label anyway, But I guess worldgen trees arent technically alive. llmao.

@Newfie,
I think I would have disabled wild vine growth via the mod config file instead.  Removing a mod like this (or any mod that adds/alters content) can be a real hassle.  Anyways, I replied to the BEVines issue in Discord.

This mod is EXTEMELY performance heavy and causes lag spikes every few seconds on large worlds that incorporate alot of wildfarming, it was making 11000 plus calls a tick for growing vines on my world making it unplayable for 80% of the players. SO I removed the mod which drastically made it better. Now after removing the mod it still has edited a file somewhere and is spamming my console full of;
23.11.2023 19:50:09.336 [VerboseDebug] Failed loading a blockentity in a chunk. Will discard it. Sorry. Exception: System.Exception: Don't know how to instantiate entity of type BEVines did you forget to register a mapping?
at Vintagestory.Common.ClassRegistry.CreateBlockEntity(String className) in C:\Users\Tyron\Documents\vintagestory\game\VintagestoryLib\Common\ClassRegistry.cs:line 498
at Vintagestory.Server.ServerChunk.AfterDeserialization(IWorldAccessor worldAccessorForResolve) in C:\Users\Tyron\Documents\vintagestory\game\VintagestoryLib\Server\Models\ServerChunk.cs:line 441
23.11.2023 19:50:10.900 [VerboseDebug] Failed loading a blockentity in a chunk. Will discard it. Sorry. Exception: System.Exception: Don't know how to instantiate entity of type BEVines did you forget to register a mapping?

How can i remove this without making a ton of errors in my 500+ hour world....

Whiteshadoh
Wildcraft trees themselves are not supported by this mod, but I've made a number of changes to at least make the two mods load up cleanly together. So there shouldn't be any weirdness. 🤷‍♂️

What is the easiest way to make this work with Wildcraft Trees? SpearAndFang

"Cattail/Papyrus roots can be grown and split into two roots by putting tops in the crafting grid with a full bucket of water."
I think this is overpowered, as the water is not removed while crafting. Starting with one bucket and 1 cattail roots, you can fill your whole inventory in like 30 seconds. Since these can be cooked for food, it is an infinite food glitch.
It would make more sense to seal up to 20 roots in a barrel with water for 10 days and get double the amount back

In general, I would like to express feedback. I think the vegetation generation is too aggressive. Almost 90% of the land in the pine forest is covered with bushes (eagle fern), with vines hanging from each tree. I would like to make the forest visually cleaner, or at least make a config where you can configure such things.

SpearAndFang As I noticed, double air blocks are still appearing in the trunk. There are also sometimes tree branches hanging.

btw could a config be added to disable forest floor generation specifically from this mod? Makes operating an orchard or even just decorative trees an excersize in frustration

Ive disabled tree growth in the configs, if that helps.

Hmm...thank you for that MrTango, I'll revisit that code and see if I can determine what's going on there.  I do know that if you score a tree that is not fully grown, that the scored logs are removed entirely when the tree goes through a growth stage. But that does not sound like what you are describing at all.

I scored a bunch of new logs after checking i'd updated. Some have resin visually, some dont, seems 50/50 split.

SpearAndFang

No worries, I was just searching to see if it was mentioned and in case anyone else was looking for the same.   Based on the new wildcraft rollout that just started (in particular wildcraftfruit for the berry changes, let alone any other tree compatibility when that rolls out), it might be better to wait anyway.

jhadred
My apologies for forgetting to revisit this, and thanks for the detailed explanation.  I'll see what I can do for the next release.

VaelophisNyx
Noted. I'll see what I can do about that. Thanks!

Not sure how big of an ask this is, but Wildcraft overwrites the fruit bushes and berries to a different type which breaks the default Wild Farming fruit seed making process for the vanilla berries.  Is adding this to the recipes and having it toggleable on the future list or a possible ask?  I know you mentioned that you were  going to be looking into it back in May.

I don't know enough about the modding yet, but it looks like a content mod could be added with just the recpies taken from WildFarmingRevival1.1.6\assets\wildfarmingrevival\recipes\grid\fruitseeds.json where I directly copied the json into a private, nonpublished zip and changed all the "game:fruit-*" to "wildcraft:fruit-*" keeping it to just the base fruits that were changed and leaving the other wildcraft berries (whatever they are) out of it.

Ideally, I think it'd be nice to have this in one of the two mods with an option to disable if someone wants just the wildcrafting berries process vs the wildfarmingrevival berries process.  But if not, a standalone mod of just that would be more than enough but I'm not sure that I should be the one to do it as all I did was directly copy and modify the json from wildfarmingrevival and I haven't done any significant testing on it in my personal game.  Heck, I even copied the modinfo and tweaked a few things, keeping the original authors despite not having it public.  Also, I haven't played in 2 years and may have a gap where I wouldn't maintain anything.  I'm still going through the wiki on mod making and tweaking my personal one though.

Admittedly the only reason I put in wildcraft was due to some pipe smoking mod so...

I've noticed tree mushrooms seem to pop off of redwood trees sometimes when they grow

GioVaporwave
oof thanks for reporting that. It seems when I greatly restricted undergrowth (ferns, claims, water) that I accidently prevented ground mushrooms and other plants from growing.  I am investigating.

Qustion: I've planted a lot of trees, they regenerate leaves and grow in 5 stages, but in the video, some mushroms and plants grows between trees, and thats not working in my world(only ferns are "planted", and some vines, mooshroms are not). Is there some requirement for that?

Vityuri
I've added it to the to-do list and will see what I can do.

Could there be a configuration to exclude Terra Preta from turning into forest floors? On the same train of thought, do clay and peat also get turned into forest floors?

Jimzawy
I too am not fond of how easy this mod makes resin collection, but this mod isn't really focused on balance.  My best suggestion if someone has concerns about that is to disable that option via the modconfig: "LogScoringEnabled"...or do what I do - change vanilla game settings to make the game much more difficult in order to offset the impact of my mod loadout.

My intention when reviving this mod was simply to pay respect to JakeCool and his massive contributions to the modding community!

Great mod,I have a weird question regarding resin,  I do like the idea of creating resin farms instead of having to roam around to collect it from random spawns, however I'm afraid that with every QOL change like this the game may become less challenging, how is the mod balancing the ease of resin collection ?

Alatyr
Thanks for the exhaustive test.  282/290 is >97% and is much better than I expected! I had concerns that my fix would be a performance hit so I didn't get overly aggressive with the solution. I may revisit that code and try and shore it up a bit more.

Please ask the XSkills modder if they can address this on their end first. Since that mod is closed source it is a bit of a hassle to come up with a solution on my end.  If they simply can't add that compatibility then I will be willing to look at it.

Of the 290 pine trees I grew, only 8 had problems with floating tops. A big improvement, but still some work to do.
Is it possible to make it compatible with XSkills? Skills to speed up tree growth don't seem to work.

Moon_Dew
I just tried it out (latest game version, latest mod versions), and all the vanilla knives seem to work fine for tree scraping, as well as many of Ruddi's knives.  Some of his knives don't work though - not sure what makes them so special, but I would guess that they also don't work for other "knife like" purposes as well.

EDIT: I've continued the investigation on my end, and it seems that some of that mod's knives are not classified as knives. Perhaps there is a reason for this, idk. It would be strange for me to patch that from this mod - it really should be fixed from that mod.

I don't know if it's on your side or theirs, but there's an incompatibility between your mod and Medieval Fashion Vanilla Textures that prevents tree scraping.

Inabikari
No worries.  Glad you got it figured out!

SpearAndFang It was a false alarm. Just me being stupid. Xskills adds a skill called 'vampire' that reduces your healing effectiveness in a weird way, and I had that skill. Sorry about that.

@MrTango. You didn't score those logs with v1.1.5 of the mod by chance?  Or are running 1.1.5?  I quickly released a hot-fix, but may have permanently messed up the scrored log resin visually in either case.

1. Make sure you're upgraded to 1.1.6
2. Score some new logs.  I'm pretty sure the resin will show up on them. 

The previously scored logs (anything using 1.1.5) might be perma-bunged. Chop that tree down!

I have scored logs, and they've generated resin which I harvested, but I cant/couldnt see that its ready to harvest visually...

meuhey
Yeah that all sounds pretty awesome.  
But that's all beyond the scope of what I'm trying to do here, which is to revive this mod as a nod to JakeCool and all the awesomeness he brought to the community.

@Inabikari
That update was completely unrelated.

Those logs have a lot of other mods/issues to digest. But I didn't see anything related specifically to your issue below.  Personally, I would do this - most importantly step #2.

1. Backup your saved game. Exit the game.
2. Open your mods folder and completely remove any older versions of mods that are sitting at that location.  Having the same mod in that folder (even if they are different versions) can be problematic, and disabling mods via the mod manager isn't always enough.
3. Navigate to your Cache folder (it's in the same folder as your Logs folder).  Delete everything in there.
4. Go back to the mod manager and click "reload mods" to ensure that it's all looking clean.
5. Update to the latest game version if possible.

SpearAndFang

I see you've pushed another update since then. I'll give that a try real quick.

Edit: Same issue still persists. Here's the entirety of my logs: mega.nz

Inabikari
I tried to recreate that and couldn't (latest version of game and mods).  It also seems pretty unlikely that that would happen. idk what else to say - maybe there's something in your log files that might provide a clue.

The newest update has a bug with Alchemy where the healing oil flask damages you roughly equal to the amount healed, resulting in a health total close to before drinking it in the first place. I have no idea how this interaction even exists.

I really wish there was a mod to make trees growth dynamic & look like hytale trees , tall, with visible smaller diameter branches, old growth & snag trees.

@Ryuu
When Jake wrote that bit of code he probably just called the vanilla method for establishing a resin block which would have a randomizer for orientation. It wasn't a deal breaker for me when I first witnessed it, because you can harvest resin from any side of the block as well in vanilla.

Should be an easy enough fix though - I'll add it to the to-do list.

What would be causing trees that are being scored with a knife to have the resin part placed not in front of the player where they scored but on the opposite side of the block ?

@Alatyr @Sindin
The new release has somewhat addressed your concerns. See the changelog for more info.

Thanks  got my genders all wrong ;-) 

The fact that the tops of trees sometimes remain hanging is really a big pain in the ass. So I hope this problem will be fixed soon.

@Sindin
That does not appear to be configurable - I've put it on the to-do list and will see if it's something I can implement.

@NukoSan
Yarrow is not from this mod, so I don't think this comment has anything whatsoever to do with me.  But please do annoy *him*, because she makes it a habit of annoying me at every opportunity.

Yarrow, planted it and destroyed the block underneath it, so with the soil I have picked up something that crashed my game, young Yarrow? Looks like water but brown, whenever I put my cursor above that, the game goes bye-bye ;-) Don't worry about it though, it's not your mod, after a wee bit I've noticed it's the Extended info that's crashing the game, will annoy him ;-)

Was wondering if there is a way to reduce the time it wake for seedlings to grow for bushs and other crops. For some reason its taking 34 days to grow the bush and thats about 1.5 years at default time settings. (almost two seasons with my time settings)

@RobertS42
It will take much more than just editing some json files, and I'm not willing to tackle that just yet, sorry. I'm assuming that you're talking about Wildcraft Trees...

Would it be possible to manually add modded trees to this mod? As in editing some manually.

RogueRaiden Vityuri
Acacia tree scoring has been added to the latest release.

Alatyr
I've removed king crimson maple from the mod so there won't be any more weirdness with that. 
And I'll add your other reported issue to my to-do list, although I'm not overly optimistic that I can fix that one.

Unfortunately, sometimes the tops of trees remain after felling. When tree growing, in some places the trunk does not continue and a block of foliage remains inside.

Thank you.

I agree with excluding the Crimson King Maple for now at least. Otherwise its basically disabled.

@Vityuri @RogueRaiden
Fair enough. I've put resin from scraping acacia trees on the to-do list

@Alatyr
This is due to limitations in vanilla. I'll look at it yet again - perhaps I can exclude king crimson maple from the mod completely.

Could we get another option, resin from scraping acacia trees for the drier and hotter climate in the tropics? If balance is an issue, an option to limit only one scrape per tree?

SpearAndFang
the Acacia resin scraping is for the players of the south. seems to be a desired feature. it could have an optional config for those who dislike it.

Krimson king maple, when moving from stage 1 to stage 2, it changes foliage to regular maple. Pretty critical issue.

RogueRaiden
I could make acacia trees scrapeable, but I'm not terribly fond of that mechanic as it is.  Find one tall pine tree and all of your resin needs are met.

Primitive Survival tree hollows only exist in world gen trees, not player planted trees.

could acacia trees be resin scrapeable?

also do Primitive Survival tree hollows appear in grown/growing trees at all?

Could anyone do a tutorial for the mushroom farm pls?

Janeator
Unfortunately, yes. The two types of maples are too similar to each other in vanilla (in the backend code that is) for me to distinguish between them for modding purposes...without a lot of work.  

I had a Crimson King Maple grow into a normal maple by stage 2. Is this normal?

BlueFuryDragon
You can add it at any time - new or existing world. Just make a backup first because it's always a good idea to make a backup prior to adding/removing mods.

Can you use this mod on a already created world or is it required you start a new world?

@Retsof
Well I did not have an answer for that so I tried it out.  I made a single change - setting the tree growth stages to 40.
If you want to try it yourself:

1. Start a new world
2. Immediately switch to creative mode /gm 2 so you won't die and have access to the entire inventory
3. Press e, Grab a tree seed and plant it
4. Use /time add 240 over and over again to accelerate tree growth. Note: Once you run that command once you can do like / followed by up arrow to access that command again easily (then press enter).

Before long you will end up with the tallest (and probably gangliest looking) tree ever.

I doubt that you will ever get a 4 block wide trunk ever though.  Maybe with a redwood, because I *think* that that's pretty exclusive to redwoods.

I have a question.  If you increase the tree growth stages will the trees get huge?  And also will they get 4 block wide trunks eventually?

@Galena
I do not think that your issue is related to this mod.  I could not recreate the issue and I did not get the impression that the two mods would conflict like this. I have reached out to the In Dappled Groves modder (Vinter), shared my findings, and asked him to look at the issue.

RobertS42
The second one.  Wildcraft trees aren't included in the growth system.  But the two mods do indeed play nice together - no crashing or other weirdness.

@Galena
II will try my best.

"While not integrated with any other mods, Wild Farming - Revival loads up cleanly and functions properly when used in conjunction with mods that you might suspect it would conflict with, like Wildcraft and/or Wildcraft Trees."
When me and my friend tried it with wildcraft trees, the growth system didn't work with the new trees. Or do you mean that the mod doesn't break?

SpearAndFang

Can you leave propagation untouched but just fix this problem?

...and...new release up.  Highlights:

FIX: plants and saplings will no longer propogate into water
FIX: plants and saplings will no longer propogate into land claims (including traders)
FIX: only 20% of "proposed" ferns will actually be planted

The changes above will all take effect by simply installing this new version.

See the update log for more info about changing these new default settings.

Galena
Oof.  Yeah I'll see what I can do. The best might be that I disable tree farming/propogation completely in this mod if In Dappled Groves is detected, because both mods seemingly need to control the trunk of the tree for very different purposes.

In the interim, you could definitely do this yourself by setting "LivingTreesEnabled" to false in the mod config file.

@Castor
You can only change a config file setting to something similar i.e. true->false, 1->2, 1.0->2.0, that sort of thing.  I've got a release almost ready to go that will address the fern issue. Should be out soon (tonight I think). And thanks!

@Screwy
I've successfully grown mushrooms above and underground.  I've mostly just ensured that there's lots of low or medium fert soil around the mushroom substrate. Some mushrooms are intended to grow on logs only (hover over the mushroom for a hint, and see Mushroom farming for more info on that).  Temperature definitely matters though - just like vanilla mushrooms - you only ever see them at certain times of the year. Now I haven't tested every vanilla mushroom but I've tested several ground and tree type mushrooms and they would all grow.

We had broken chunks for some time and saw this after the server restart. It seems like a minor conflict between Wild Farming and In Dappled Groves. Please, solve it.

I have a question. My mushrooms don't grow and I wonder why. What blocks are considered dirt exactly? Do they need darkness or cellar effect or something like that to grow?

Eyyy, so is there a way to simply slow down the rate at which grass and ferns spread? it would literally take me all of my time, food amd resources to try and clear the field in which i have made my home, but i still really like the feature, it has taken the grassy plains they once were and turned them into a veritable garden of eden, but my only issue is i dont like the shear amount of ferns that have "taken root", so to speak.

In the Config File it says "Harsh Wild Plants: True." Can i put a value there to slow down or increase the speed at which ferns grow with that? does this also effect regular grass? What would a good Value be to say halve the speed?

Otherwise this mod is TOP notch. Really adds to the immersion and make it feel like the land is actually alive and growing. Mad F***in Kudos.

@Galena
I think you mean that the stumps without roots are easier to chop down.

This mod creates stumps without roots (when you plant a tree), that have growth stages and propogation.  But are a lot like vanilla trees.  In Dappled Groves creates a different type of stumps entirely (with roots). The two mods might not be a good fit together.

I meant that the two mods together were not causing me any big issues (like crashing).

SpearAndFang

Is that ok that stumps without roots are being destroy faster than stumps with roots? Like few times.

Galena
I did some light testing of this mod and In Dappled Groves the other day and they *seemed* to work ok together.

Thanks! I thought the mushroom substrate was normal dirt, forest floor or logs.  Thanks again!

Does this mod work correcly with "In Daappled Groves" from Vinter_Nacht?

ribacebola
You need to right click the mushroom on mushroom substrate. The recipe is in the crafting grid but it's not easy to make since it requires aqua vitae.

How can i plant a ground mushroom? When i right click the mushroom over the dirt, my character starts to eat it.

Guimoute
This mod is highly configurable - edit the modconfig file - change all of the "true" to "false" except for "FlowersEnabled" and maybe "SeedPanningEnabled".

It's a shame there isn't a standalone version only for flower reproduction. I feel like this mod changes too many things at once.

Thanks for the additional info SecretFoxfire
I'll also look at preventing regrowth in trader claims.  And if you have some setting changes to share I will gladly make them the new default settings.

I agree that the foliage regrowth is a little extreme. Everything is completely overgrown with giant ferns and we've even got a tree growing inside a trader claim that can't removed in survival mode. I've tweaked the config values on my server and will see how it goes, but my players are all a little annoyed that the areas they used to use for growing grass are completely dominated by ferns and they're constantly having to fight against having their land taken over by new growth. I don't dislike the idea of the forest recovering and slowly spreading with time, but it's happening way too fast and growing way too much. (Thank you for all the work I'm sure has gone into making/fixing/reviving this mod! I love that I can grow mushrooms. \o/ )

From what I've seen of the code, I'm an agreeance with FinkThinker.  This mod simply leverages vanilla worldgen code to regenerate foliage, just like vanilla would do. Although now that I've got that working again, I do need to revisit that code yet again to prevent it from regenerating that foliage (and trees) in water. It is highly configurable via the mod config options though - maybe the defaults are a bit extreme...

I don't believe this mod changes how much of foliage spawns, the author can correct me if I'm wrong.

Please fix the number of eagle ferns that spawn, the forests are filled with vegetation, it's lagging, it's absurd!

Great mod! 💜

Moon_Dew
I'm not sure, but if it did it would surely have to do with living trees.
you could set "LivingTreesEnabled" to false in the WildFarmingConfig.json

Is this compatible with In Dappled Groves?  I'm trying to figure out which mod's preventing me from splitting logs into slabs.

Kinda needs to have the growth speed reduced and some maximum growth area boundary; had to disable the growth function as my clear plains is infested with tall hedges now, dont want to feel Im at war with the forest, or solely responsible for trimming it.

SpearAndFang thank you for the reply i wasnt sure just figured the rest of the mod was very useful but was a bit turned off by the tree functions seeing as again world travel is crazy and teleporting seems a bit... not realistic and not super easy to get translocators as is in base game. 

l33tmaan i noticed lol. most of them are really neat and nice features so im glad someone is taking care of the mods.

Ultimaheart4

Spang's shoulders are big and broad from carrying some of the most important VS mods into the present day.

Ultimaheart4
Yes, changing those two settings to false will make trees vanilla again.

jeeze i feel like im perstering you. i didnt know you maintained so many mods! i was wonderinf if the config options for turning off harsh saplings and living tree's would make just the trees standard vanilla mechanics? its a neat idea but i dont really want to travel 10k blocks north/south to farm certain tree's if i read the infor correctly that is posted above it seems that it would work that way wasnt sure if you could confirm that. SpearAndFang

Cusco
A LOT of things can be disabled.  See the configuration section above.  Not sure if you can get it down to simply mushroom growing, but it looks like you can get it close.

You just have to edit your %appdata%\VintagestoryData\ModConfig\WildFarmingConfig.json file with a text editor and change a lot of true to false. 

Is it possible to only have the growing mushrooms part, like edit the mod file or something like that?

SpearAndFang Thank you for your time. its prob a mod confict on my server. its heavly modded and wanted to reach out to confirm. 

Aljistar
I don't think this mod is related to your issue.  The vines that are mentioned in the documentation above are references to vines that grow on trees, not pumpkin vines.  I don't believe that this mod touches pumpkins in any way.

For further confirmation, I set up a pumpkin patch with this mod enabled.accelerated time in one month intervals, and had plenty of pumpkins grow.

im having issues with growing pumkins.  This may not be a mod problem but id like to state it.  they reach 8/8 growth and change to Withered pumkin without vining out. i have 12x12 area, offset water block, free of grass and any blockages, and proper moisture and temp ranges.

Good info. Appreciate that. 🧡

SpearAndFang

Tested ! And it's work again !!!!

Thank you for your work ! I will play it on my server with some friend, if I find others bugs, things, you can count on me to do another report ^^

I also tested this mod with a "bunch" of other mods. And so far it seems that it's working without issue.

And since this mod affect only new tree planted by the player, it's compatible with any other mods that add or modify tree handling so far (like Wildcraft Trees, In Dappled Groves, Wildcraft (it does not add new tree but some flora and this mod has no problem with it because it's using only the vanilla plant)).

Caution for others player it's compatible in a way that it's does not prevents them from working together. And I didn't tested all the features that theses mods add to the game together, so take my report with a grain of salt.

Thank you again for your work !

Another release up! Tree spawning issue solved.
Thanks yet again Zetoya

Wow, I haven't looked in here in a while, it seems from the comments that tree spread is not working. Sad as that is for some it was the only thing about this mod that had me worried, so I think ill give it a shot right quick before it gets fixed. 

@Zetoya
Thanks for the thorough test - I thought I was just unlucky to not have any trees spawn during my limited testing.  I'll dive back in to the code and see what's going on with trees.

SpearAndFang

So it works better, but not entirely.
Automatic propagation seems to work on a survival world, but not entirely. I have the impression that this one doesn't generate new trees.

I tested it in a vanilla survival world (vanilla config too), where I modified the terrain to have a large flat area with medium fertility soil (grass). I put different seeds/trees at a good distance from each other. And I passed the time with the command "time add 120 or 480".

So it seems that the automatic generation make new plants/mushrooms/forest blocks/flowers but no tree saplings. Tested on the span of 3 in game years.

I made a few screenshots:https://imgur.com/a/ZZd6DgT

Thanks for the update, we're close!

New release! 
FIXED: Tree propogation was only working in creative. Now it always works - thanks again Zetoya
NEW: French translation courtesy of Laerinok

Wow thanks Laerinok!
It will be a part of the next release!

SpearAndFang

Hello,

Here are the fr.json :

• \game\lang : https://pastebin.com/pGKtZGzc
• \wildfarmingrevival\lang : https://pastebin.com/6Vy9CZji

Thanks for having made this revival ! :)

Zetoya
Thank you for the detailed report - I had only tested auto propogation in creative - I'll revisit this and try and get it sorted for the next release

@BigShasta Thank you, I will know who to contact. I'm sorry, I rarely go to the mods section, which is why I answer for a long time.

Hello !

I have a problem, it seems like the auto propagation system is working only on a creative map.
I was using several mods and I have constated after some testing (compatibility check) that the auto propagation wasn't working. So I tested it on a creative world and it was working well (not for the new sapling from wildcraft tree but as you said, it only work with vanilla trees).

So I decided to test with this mods only, on a brand new normal world (absolutely no change in map config or in the config file of the mods) and it's not working either. It seems that the other features are working because vine, mushroom are present after some time. The base of the tree in the HUD said that is from Wild Farming Revival, and the living process is working too.
In a creative world with this mods only, it worked like the previous test with some mods.

I have tried to clean the area around the tree (remove grass, rock, flower, etc), tried to use richer dirt (high fertility), tried with saplings/seeds of different tree types, tried to change parameters in the config file to ramp up some value. Tried to uninstall completely the mods (deleted zip file, conf file, cache directory). And all of that with a new map for each try. And it did nothing too.

I was using the command /time add number to accelerate time for my testing (like in the demonstration video). I don't know what to do, I think I have tested all the things that I could think of ^^ So please tell me that it's a bug and I'm not crazy xD

Game version : 1.18.6 (Stable)
Mod version : 1.0.7

I can't say for certain, but that sounds about right.

Just wanted to confirm that if I change the following

LivingTreesDisabled
HarshSaplingsDisabled

That the trees will be like vanila but still allow for Resin harvest and the likes yes?

I mean...in theory that sounds about right.  In reality, I think that the uniqueness of the vanilla maple trees that may present some real challenges - especially for someone like me that hasn't spent any time looking at tree gen code.  Why they don't have their own trunk block like every other tree is a bit of a mystery.

Most every time I dive into some new vanilla system and try and repurpose it/modify it, I discover some things that are difficult to sort out.

SpearAndFang

The only other thing I could think of doing would be to copy the entire code block for maples, make a new "crimson king maple tree" block and replace all references to like, leaves, seeds, etc with the crimson ones instead for the new block. Though that's mostly just theorycrafting since I don't have access to said code

@WhiskeySunshine
I see reports of this on the forum and the discord from a couple of years ago - long before I revived this mod.  I also see that vanilla crimson king maples simply have "maple" trunks (and crimson king maple leaves)  - which is surely why JakeCool never addressed this issue - there's no easy way to do so.

If he couldn't come up with a solution I doubt that I could.  I would consider something like excluding them from the mod though, or locking them in at growth stage 1, so that players can at least permanently have some crimson king maples around their homestead...

So, a bit of a weird bug has been popping up for me, I wanted to start planting crimson king maple trees around my village, but after the first growth stage (from stage 1/5 moving to 2/5) the leaves instead turn into a normal maple leaves, making it impossible to cultivate the crimson king maples. Happens on both 1.0.6 and 1.0.7, on vintage story versions 1.18.4, 1.18.5, and 1.18.6-rc.2 thus far, on both server and single player. None of the logs say anything regarding the mod that I could find.

I did plant a bunch of trees in a flat world and advanced time quickly using commands.  There was a LOT of tree spread just like in the video above, but it was hard to guage how quickly that would happen in real time.  I wonder if they only spread in perfectly flat areas?

@Mendall I've been planting trees in various places for a year in my game and I haven't noticed trees spreading yet. If they do at all it's very slow.

@Mendall
hopefully someone else can answer that question about trees spreading.  I haven't used this mod long enough to know.  sorry!

Also, I searched this mod for any changes to bony soil and there was nothing to be found.  Then I panned bony soil for a while and it seemed aok. 🤷‍♂️

I have thought about trying this mod again (I tried it in the past, and it crashed my game every time I panned bony soil)  but the tree spread mechanic worries me a bit. Are there any limits as to where and under what circumstances trees will spread. I don't want trees to spread out across the desserts or over my animal pastures etc…

@Rekeme thank you for reporting this. I will add it to my list and try and fix it.

Hey there! Thank you for reviving this mod. I'm here to report Muddy gravel panning behaves oddly. With no other mods active, panning muddy gravel doesn't reduce the block size so you can pan the same block infinitely.

Another potential problem is that the activity yields nothing most of the time. Coupled with the gravel not decreasing in size it initially seemed like the feature was broken. Is it supposed to give nothing of the time?

@PeterSanderson nothing reported.  I'm hesitant to test those two mods together, because Vinter's mods tend to go in the opposite direction of what this mod has to offer. 

Any conflicts with In Dappled Groves?

the trees are coming

Hey NikolayBrony Спасибо! I have been studying Russian for many years at this point, as a native English speaker, so if you'd ever like a second opinion or a proof reader, message me in лс! I would love to help bring more Russian speakers into this gritty survival game! Cheers!

@SpearAndFang I was glad to help.

NikolayBrony yes thank you for this!  I have downloaded your language files and will include them in the next release.

I wrote the Russian language for your mod, since it is used in my build, please answer if you are interested. I also want to say that I am not a professional translator and the translation was done partly with the help of a machine, but with my edits.. https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1an612d2hwNb2CrG1R-2XPil2VJREpaJY?usp=sharing

Crossthebase I can only assume it's a mod conflict as I can not easily recreate that when running the latest versions of the game and this mod. I also have wildcraft and wildcraft trees.

Not that it's serious, it just means that there will be no seed drops from saguarocactus.

I'm not sure what other mod would be changing saguarocactus drops.

hey i have this error

20.5.2023 08:23:46 [Error] Patch 2 (target: game:blocktypes/plant/saguarocactus.json) in wildfarmingrevival:patches/saguarocactus.json failed because supplied path /dropsByType/*/0 is invalid: The json path /dropsByType/*/0 was not found. Could traverse until /dropsByType, but then '*' does not exist. Full json at this path: {
"*-topripe": [
{
"type": "item",
"code": "fruit-saguaro",
"quantity": {
"avg": 2.5,
"var": 1.5
}
},
{
"type": "block",
"code": "saguarocactus-topempty",
"quantity": {
"avg": 1,
"var": 0
}
}
],
"*-branchysegment": [
{
"type": "block",
"code": "saguarocactus-branchysegment",
"quantity": {
"avg": 1,
"var": 0
}
}
],
"*-segment": [
{
"type": "block",
"code": "saguarocactus-segment",
"quantity": {
"avg": 1,
"var": 0
}
}
]
}

SpearAndFang

I got issues similar to what Zerovoid was experiencing. I started a world with the tree growth turned off and wanted to try and turn it on. For whatever reason, both me and a friend but not the other two players in the server crashed. We turned the tree growth off and it went back to normal. And yes, the server is heavily modded. I can send you a crash log for it if it helps.

I'm so confused right now.  

bringitonwimps cattail roots can be split into two with a bucket of water, not a knife, correct?  But this doesn't seem to be necessary.

@denoven I have no problem making rush matting with this mod installed.  The shapeless recipes in this mod are far removed from that recipe, and shouldn't impact that in any way.  I also have no problem planting cattail roots without splitting them.

I don't know much about this mod but I'm not understanding these recent comments at all.

DeNoven, the catail roots have to be cut with a knife into 2 pieces then planted

I'm seeing a conflict with the Vintage Story Sacks mod; to make rush mattings the craft grid has a square of reeds and a knife in the upper right corner, a orientation required recipe. However, the shapeless seed making recipe takes precedence instead, so I can't make mattings. 
Is there any way to change that as/is or could that be fixed?

On the other hand I am also seeing a small, maybe deliberate issue with reeds as well - whole roots can't be replanted (no action on shift click, no hud indicator saying to shift click) but CAN be planted if halved. 

Zerovoid Oh my that's quite the mod line-up.  Surprised to see Farm Life in there.  If it was me, I'd try a couple of things:

1.  Start a new world with that same set of mods to see if the problem persists.  If it does, it's surely a mod conflict (or a problem with Wild Farming on multi-player servers if you are playing MP, although no one else has reported such an issue yet).

2. Make a backup of your existing world, then in the modconfig file for Wild Farming, set LivingTreesEnabled to false.  This will of course disable all of your living trees, but it *should* clear up that error message completely.  Then zip around to all of the chunks you've visited to ensure that they all get re-loaded.  Finally, if you tried #1 above and it worked without issue, and you're feeling brave, I would go ahead and enable LivingTreesEnabled again.

I mean, it's even possible that these trees were broken because of a previous version of Wild Farming itself.  idk.

SpearAndFang

Here are the `server-main.txt` logs: https://pastebin.com/G09yXfvA

Do you see what you need in there?

Again, I am only accepting feature requests on the official VS Discord.  Click here:
https://discord.com/channels/302152934249070593/1101361739221704744

I am only accepting feature requests on the official VS Discord.  Click here:
https://discord.com/channels/302152934249070593/1101361739221704744

Why not acacia trees? They leak resin too

"Pine trees can be scored with a knife to leak resin"

Can acacia trees be scored with a knife to leak resin?

Zerovoid Sorry I could not replicate that issue here with those versions and the 10 or so mods I normally use. If you post the list of mods and it's not too many I can try and recreate the issue.  Otherwise I will wait for another similar report from someone else before looking.  Both the server-main.txt and client-main.txt have such a list of mods loaded, near the top.

SpearAndFang

VS 1.18.1 stable; Wild Farming Revival 1.0.5; other mods -- yes, lots

Zerovoid game version 1.18.0 or 1.18.1?  latest mod version?  Other mods installed?

Hi I'm getting tos of this error in logs and the world just stops:
7.5.2023 19:52:09 [Fatal] System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object.
at WildFarmingRevival.ModSystem.BlockEntityRegenSapling.CheckGrow(Single dt)
at Vintagestory.Common.EventManager.TriggerGameTick(Int64 ellapsedMilliseconds, IWorldAccessor world) in C:\Users\Tyron\Documents\vintagestory\game\VintagestoryLib\Common\EventManager.cs:line 84
at Vintagestory.Server.CoreServerEventManager.TriggerGameTick(Int64 ellapsedMilliseconds, IWorldAccessor world) in C:\Users\Tyron\Documents\vintagestory\game\VintagestoryLib\Server\ServerEventManager.cs:line 122
at Vintagestory.Server.ServerMain.Process() in C:\Users\Tyron\Documents\vintagestory\game\VintagestoryLib\Server\ServerMain.cs:line 769

Burgersim I believe that that's what the modconfig setting "LivingTreesEnabled" is for.  Set it to false.  Or maybe adjust "MaxTreeGrowthStages".  I have not played around with the configuration file much.

Wildcraft + Wildcraft Trees integration is next on the to-do list, but I need to take a break from this mod for a while.

Hi, I wanted to ask if there is a possibility to disable the tree growth changes but use everything else? Is Wildcraft Trees integrated to the Tree growth yet? And I get that this takes time, so no pressure ^^

Willow22 I still don't know sorry.  I have been testing it a bit with Wildcraft, Wildcraft Trees, and the mods that I maintain , but am mostly trying to sort out any remaining issues with the mod itself. Have not tested with other mods.

We're so back

Is this compatible with Dappled Groves and Fields of Gold?

Oh dang, we're still so early in our multiplayer session D: I TOTALLY want to grow shrooms, but the need for aquavitae makes it pretty much mid to endgame stuff.

New version up.  I really need someone to test the mushroom substrate/farming in multiplayer.  I think it is fixed now.  If not, I've got one more trick up my sleeve.

Shion I will try my best.  EDIT: I have done it for the next release.

Can you make it so pan stays in the crafting grid when extracting seeds?

Dammit.  Time for plan B.  Thanks for the heads up Khaligufzel

Unfortunately, using mushrooms on mushroom substrate still crashes the client on version 1.0.3 :<

@Gnomp I just now released a new version that makes this mod Wildcraft Trees "friendly".  Not integrated, but there shouldn't be any more crashes when the two are used together.

SpearAndFang

Is the WildCraft Trees incompatability Fatal? In other words: is it possible to use the mods in conjunction without crashes like my prior error log?

Friskain not for me. The video link is this one that Jake made

Something weird: Either 1.18 or one of the mods I have makes it so that when I cut a wild vine tip, I just get a regular wild vine segment instead. If it's a mod, I guess I should probably figure out which one... but if it's vanilla, then there's no way to grow more vines afaik.

Edit: I am dumb - there's a recipe for making tips out of regular segments in this mod. Disregard this.

Im sorry but the youtube video shows its for the game Minecraft????

@Gnomp sorry this mod is not compatible with Wildcraft Trees (yet). I was mistaken below.

29.4.2023 17:53:32 [Fatal] System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object
at WildFarmingRevival.ModSystem.BlockEntityRegenSapling.CheckGrow (System.Single dt) [0x004f2] in <77a3e55e40bf4f25ac3d8e16a816ab74>:0
at Vintagestory.Common.EventManager.TriggerGameTick (System.Int64 ellapsedMilliseconds, Vintagestory.API.Common.IWorldAccessor world) [0x000d3] in <53a52d6c9cac448aa583eeff54e6c897>:0
at Vintagestory.Server.CoreServerEventManager.TriggerGameTick (System.Int64 ellapsedMilliseconds, Vintagestory.API.Common.IWorldAccessor world) [0x00000] in <53a52d6c9cac448aa583eeff54e6c897>:0
at Vintagestory.Server.ServerMain.Process () [0x0020d] in <53a52d6c9cac448aa583eeff54e6c897>:0


I hope this is of help!
World is frozen and does not recieve any player inputs.
Wildcraft trees was used.

Heads up/Correction: Wildcraft Trees and this mod are not playing nice together, so do not use them both at the same time. Sorting this out is high on my priority list.

Brace yourselves, SaF said it, mod support is coming (eventually)

Let the fellow vintarian cook :)

bringitonwimps I've intentionally disconnected it from wildcraft trees when I debugged it.  I did so to help get all the bugs out as a standalone mod (regardless of whether wildcraft trees was installed or not).  Once I'm fairly confident that it is 100% stable, I will try and have it integrate with that mod.

Also, a couple of fairly serious bugs have been identified with this initial release, so you might want to wait for the next one.

i have always been wanting to utilize tyhis mod.  i am also wondering if it works with in dappled groves, but even more so cause it would seam since dapplked grove doesnt effect tree growth just the logs after it would likely.   but the mod im wondering if anyone knows is does it work with wildcraft trees?.. will it recognized a tree as a tree and effect them.  i amn going to attempt to test it but if anyoine has any knowledge on this be great, or if anyone is genuis enough to make it work that would be amazing!

Anyone know if this works with Vinter's In Dappled Groves?

Yanazake The config file was unchanged, so it should be the same.  I only crushed the bugs.

NO. FRIGGIN. WAY.

Is the config file the same?

You love to see it, great revival!

❤️

YOOOOOOOO GLAD TO SEE THIS MOD COME BACK

Woohoo!