Any questions asking about mod compatibility will be deleted. I have already answered this in my previous comment. If I make an active effort to add additional compatibility to certain mods it will be mentioned directly. Also: World gen modifications are currently content based, not code based, on my end. In the case of the Wastes area, it is more just where sand/gravel generally spawns to provide variety. 

I am not at all familiar with that mod. The only two mods I worked to make this especially compatible with (Both before CompatibilityLib was integrated into vanilla and after) was jakecool19 Useful Stuff, and SpearAndFang Primitive Survival. Especially since the explosion of new mods in July 2023, it would be almost impossible to try to make RTD compatible with all mods. I don't want to sound mean or anything, but I am not going to try to do that either, for my own sanity. 

However: I have been working on, and still am working on, Trying to utilize config files. It has been a process to learn how to do because I am NOT a C# developer. The goal is to be able to enable/disable recipes, certain WorldGen elements, and allow different return rates for panning.

RTD was created for the original UHC (Ultra Hardcore server by BotenRedWolf back in 2001 for a Snowball world before trees were plentiful in those regions, as well as my own RuraPenthe Servers.

Before Larch, before Arctic Vessles, food was super scarce. For a normal world I though I totally agree with you the satiation rates are too high.

RTD is going to be the resource mod in the future, and Frozen Wastes (Had just started splitting Yabba RTD into two mods back in 2023, but still in the works) would be the way to return UHC worlds truely back to UHC status. Not the Carebear version.

Update as well: I have most of the names and descriptions fixed, fixed forest floor not breaking correctly, Working on a few recipes as well as some balancing. If things continue at a good click, I should have update posted here by Friday. 

Edit: Tagging is being weird, so I just bolded them.

Also, the pine nuts recipe conflicts with Wildcraft: Fruit and nuts, they share a recipe.  Also the output of 180 satiety for 1 pinecone is too high imo

Ah, Yes, I see how that can cause an issue. I will do some testing today on the recipe. There was a reason why I had originally listed out the vanilla rock variants, but I am not sure if that is still needed. I will try to make sure it works with any sand/gravel, even from another mod if it adds variants. 

Quixjote

Yes I see now, this mod does work with the sluice from the 1.20 branch of (Still) Useful Stuff.  The incompatibility is with 'Geology additions'.  The sands of that mod DO break into handfuls, but DONT turn back into blocks using the expected recipe.

I will double check. we have been using the new version on a regular world.
Basically

• If you dig gravel you get Handfuls of Gravel, and occasionally Handfuls of Sand
• If you dig sand, you get Handfuls of Sand, and occasionally Handfuls of Fine Sand
• You will also get other goodies occasionally digging through Sand, Gravel, and Soils

For Handfuls of Sand, Gravel, and Soils (barren, Low, med, high, preta) it currently takes 9 to make a block, though doing more indepth playthrough myself I have ideas to make it not QUITE so grindy... Grindy is the intent, but not unbearably so.

I was not aware that Useful Stuff still worked. I absoutely love the OG version of it that JakeCool19 made, and I try to make sure mine has worked with with his, at least in terms of the Sluice. You are correct, it has to be a block that goes through the sluice. I would have loved for it to be the Handfuls, and I am working on learning the API enough to have my own Automatic dirt processing... though that is still a few versions out.

I am not familiar with Geology Additions. In the last year and a half there have been  A TON of new mods, and my main concern atm is trying to get RTD at least up to date.

Hello, can't tell if things are messed up or working properly.  I dig up diorite sand and get diorite sand and fine diorite sand.  Diorite sand handfuls cannot be made back into blocks, making it imporssible to get these sand blocks.  Neither of these sand handfuls work in the sluice from Useful stuff, though maybe it needs to be a sand block?  I recognize that there are 3 different mods interacting here; Geology Additions, Useful stuff, and this, but I'm just wondering if I am interacting with this mod correctly.

It's possible a lot of the handbook stuff got messed up trying to switch to .NET 7 code base. I will add that to my list of things to fix

Not sure if it's normal, but a good amount of the names are not properly implemented, such as the Terra Petra mix being called "richerthandirt:item-soilmix-terra". Many of the other items added to this mod currently doesn't have proper implemnted names.

any chance this could get a 1.19 update?

Hey just trying to figure out something. are those stacked bricks in tha last picture from the march preview snow bricks? if so how does one make those.

Hi, been using your mod along side (the now quite old actually) Auto-Shifter and noticed that it fails to find valid panning drops for all the layered soil variants. I think this is due to how the "survival-blocktypes-wood-pan_pannable_soil" patch is setup only defining drop tables for the "base" pannable_soil block type by fertility without wildcarding. Auto-Shifter tries to do a lookup for smth like "pannable_soil-medium-7" and fails. Just a quick test changing each definition to be wildcarded to account for layers: "/attributes/panningDrops/pannable_soil-high" becomes "/attributes/panningDrops/@(pannable_soil-high).*" - Following the vanilla format for sand & gravel and how you patch the base grass types - fixes its use for Auto-Shifter and seems to keeps regular hand panning(at least in basic testing, lets me grab material, start panning, generates a drop, etc... without errors being logged). I know the "bug" is not really with your mod but rather an issue with Auto-Shifters method for checking for panning drops by block, perhaps due to being built for an older version of the game and just simply not being actively developed anymore, but id love for them to work in tandem. Apologies if its a weird request, I do also think just adding in the wildcarding may help just for robustness incase any other future mod ends up with the same block code checking issue with panningDrops. 

Quixjote and ElectroNikkel did the cooperation happen? massive fan of the concept of the former and a follower of the latter :-)

Hello. I am the creator of the mod "Not Enough Sand", that adds pebbles, more crushed rocks and rock dusts. ¿Do u want our mods to be compatible?

Production is back in progress on RTD.
Started working on 1.3.0 back in Feb, but got delayed due to a move. Many new features in the works.

Version 1.2.0 was released for VS 1.15.x, but as of right now it DOES work in VS 1.18.x, but it appears there is a bug when panning anything other than base materials (I noticed it in the "Still Useful Stuff" mod when trying to pan Muddy Gravel as well) in that the block doesn't change to it's layered version. This will be corrected in my next release hopefully.

EDIT: Has been updated to 1.2.1 to correct these bugs.

Surprisingly, it seems to work just fine in 1.17, as I've yet to run into any issues with it.

Would love to play with this. It hasn't been updated in awhile. I'm assuming it's going to have issues with 1.17

was working with 1.16.

any chance for an update for 1.17?

Loktar: Thank you, that will be in the next update

Malakai: Not sure why you would be getting an error with Muddy Gravel, I haven't even incorporated Muddy Gravel into RTD yet. Do you have Wild Farming installed by chance? I know that allows panning of Muddy Gravel. Either way, I will keep it on my radar during my next update :) Thank you for the heads up.

Getting a crash when trying to pan muddy soil :/

"Fine Soil Created from using Sand in Quern" should say Fine Sand correct?