Dang I really really want pemmican in the base game now, would be a great use for bushmeat, which after the early game just starts to feel a bit of an annoyance. Having a stockpile of food storage would be cool.

Rivernoodl right now the mod is running on one of the servers where Primitive Suvival and Expanded Food mods are installed. Initially, the mod was created in this way so as not to depend on other mods. So it works great)

Doggo_ thank you for correcting me) English is not my native language so I can make mistakes, sorry)

Theres a spelling mistake in the 2nd picture. Its written "cooked" pemmican. Funnily enough in the description you wrote it right. Unless there are male chickens involved, then im wrong.

Also bushmeat not buchmeat.

I dont mean to be rude, but felt like i should point it out.

I3eauLeBoi No hard feelings. Have a great day! :)

dashr

Of course!
I do also forget my straight forwardness may come across as 'bold' or 'incencere'.
So i do apologize for that matter, if that were the case!

MrFlame I'm totally fine with it. I just hope you continue that mod in a fair and balanced way. I think it gives the game a nice touch. Especially if traveling far into one direction, without any teleportation mods installed. 

Thank you for working so hard. Like I said I hope you continue the mod in the near future. :)

I3eauLeBoi I'm not here to pick a fight and your opinion is totally vaild and fair. If the mod decides to go that route, I'm open to it, while trying - as you also do - to give contructive feedback. :)

@dashr

But you can disagree or agree with what i've opinionated. Thats the best part.
Its nowhere to offend, its just what i 'personallly' think. There's nothing wrong with that.
Neither is it personal. Although its a bit odd to think i've got something personal against you lmao, its not that deep.

Eitherway.

@MrFlame

Yeah the game really lacks in the 'hand consumable' department. And i do actually agree with the annoying "Move your entire kitchen with you." While you explore.
If you are planning on adding many more hand held items that you can eat on the fly, i'd be there entirely for it! Can't wait what you can 'cook up'  ;D  ;D  ;D

I3eauLeBoi thank you for your feedback too) 
I completely agree that a little treatment is a great addition to the long process of creating this food
Also pemmican is ineffective in terms of saturation: eating the ingredients immediately with minimal preparation is much more profitable. This is the price for a "long shelf" life of this food, so I thought that it would be nice to fill such a saturation loss with something else, different.
Another good feature I think is pemmican-rusks stew. Yes, I don't like eating from bowls, in the game for me it's unnecessary actions - you need a slot for a cauldron on the road, a slot for a bowl, put it on the ground, eat, then pick it up. It's easier to cook something... convenient. However, a stew with pemmican, crackers, vegetables and fruits is a great food to replenish all the elements of the diet at once and get maximum health buffs from food.

I3eauLeBoi I don't understand why you say my feedback is not good feedback? Every feedback is worth considering. It's like me saying your feedback wouldn't be good, which would be utterly nonsense if I would say that. The mod author has all freedom to decide, what he wants to do with the mod. I even gave a detailed breakdown, why I believe healing in items shouldn't be in this mod. It looks like you want to interpret something from my comment that I never wrote and use it against me. Be better.

@dashr

Although feedback is good, doesn't mean all is. Personally to me? I like these recipes and the ability to craft them, its properly balanced by how long it should take and the resouces you need to put into them. That healing bonus is then a fun little addition.

Not everyone is going to spam create these items. And would probably still use meds. Since these foods, as per mentioned before. Take time and resources. While the other medical items are easier to make. So personally. Those things could stay for me. Just to give a little back and forth.

Eitherway, great mod! I am glad we can finally make some preservative foods. Canned goods was something i wanted for a long time as well. Or some sort of packaged food. (I know. That'd be pemmican, haha.)

MrFlame Your're welcome! It has the framework of being great. I really like the vision for this mod and hope you'll continue updating it.  

Quick feedback: I would prefer it if Pemmican did not give an “ HP” bonus. I've already removed that from the mod for me. It would reduce the importance of healing items while traveling.

Furthermore, I strongly believe vintage beef SHOULD be extremely rare since it heals you up to 2 HP. Making it craftable renders healing items "almost" useless. (I know bandages and honey pultice heal way more but I believe having food items that heal you is too much of a buff)
I don't know if it's possible to patch out this ability from the vanilla game but if so, I would do so. Anything that leads to healing items being used less makes the game unbalanced.

Maybe you can come up with a different item, like you did with the pemmican and leave vintage beef out of this mod.


Edit: I started (for myself) to integrate the handbook entry. You can take a look if you want. It is not finished but if you like what you see, I would be willing to do the complete handbook entry for you, so you can concentrate on making the mod. 
All the items will be linked in the handbook. 

Link: imgur.com/8CZN1TX

dashr Thank you for your feedback! Thats means huge for me:3

So, I've got a few hours in testing everything. Seems to work without any issues on a modded server. 

I think you got some great potential with this mods future plans in your hands, since this feels like it would be a part of the vanilla game, without overwhelming new players. Keep it up!

dashr Fixed

MrFlame

DanaCraluminum

For some weird reason, if "Tools require rope" is installed the recipe for the sliced bread version requires a rope. So one of you might need to look into this. 

Screenshots:

Bread:
https://imgur.com/a/23vFxPJ

ToolsrequireRope Config:
https://imgur.com/a/MgYtvxk

The salted pemmican is even stranger because it now has two options to craft the item.

How it should look:
https://imgur.com/a/UsvZfGV


Salt + Rope?
https://imgur.com/a/HRQa9Q4


Since the config of "Tools require rope" reads the files in game and tries to be automatically compatible, this issue needs to be addressed.

Hope this helps a bit to iron out these bugs. 

P.S. I don't want to come across as rude, so I wanted to also say that this looks like an awesome mod that could add so much depth with the planned features. Hopefully the issues I have listed can be resolved soon-ish.

Edit: It's "ToolsrequireRope" I've tested it and can definitely say it needs to be fixed, since these issues are even in other recipes.