This still seems to work on 1.22

when will it be updated to 1.22?

Thanks for the mod! So far it's working on 1.22 rc.4, did small tests with low & high fert. soil.

@jayu, I recently found a bug that I assume involves your mod. I am playing with the Primitive Survival mod and decided to make some worm castings for my farm. Long story short, it appears that when the farmland turns into worm castings, it drops itself with the highest levels of fertilizer. This means you can place it back down and immediately turn it into more worm castings. In five minutes you can have enough to completely fertilizer a small-medium field. I don't know what is causing the bug, or if you have a way to fix it, but I figured Id let you know.

it would be cool if you could also revert farmland back into soil with the crafting grid, so if you use high fertility soil in your farm and you want to turn it into terra preta you can jjust use that same soil, or if youre removing a farm you can tur nthe farmland into soil and use it to refill that same spot

MooseCampbell the only one I found that does that is for 1.16.4 does it work for 1.21.6?

CycloniumGame Yeah I just use a mod that makes the farmland drop the soil

MooseCampbell I wish that you were able to use the farmland itself in the recipe

CycloniumGame Was thinking of the Better Ruins recipe for converting HF to Terra

MooseCampbell youindeed cannot craft the HF farmland into tera you maybe are thinking of the  recipe for the soil? I too can also be wrong

OMG THANK YOU

Is there any way you could add a recipe to craft high fertile farm land into terra preta?

Oof looks like the gif vanished

so far this is working on 1.21.5 if anyone is wondering

Mynxae which part is ambiguous so I can make it clearer? What you're asking for is kind of the entire point of the mod.

Just confirming as the wording is slightly ambiguous - if the farmland currently has fertilizer on it, will that stay attached to it if I dig it up to place it elsewhere? About to be moving my base and my farmland is all high fertility soil with potash on it, ready for a big planting of flax! D: 

Great mod, thank you

KnewOne fixed

The soil drop when nutrients at default level doesn't seem to be working. Tested with no mods and in new world. Hoe'd a farmland, broke it, it dropped as farmland and not soil. 1.20.7 / 1.2.0

DarkThoughts the mod uses itemstack attributes, the equivalent of minecraft's nbt data. It stores the attribute in the item stack, then retrieves it when you try to place it down. That's it. Vanilla uses this much more extensively than this mod for clutter blocks, as they use attributes also for rendering.

So, is this going to add a gazillion of block variants or how is this done on a technical level? Seeing how some mods like vanilla variants completely wreck the ram usage, I'm rather paranoid now.

Awesome! I'll grab this and uninstall Farmland Drops Soil (sometimes).

<3<3 Have a wonderful night friend.

Robot_Milk I was faster than your comment XP

Ah I see. Any chance of a fix? I already appreciate you updating this for 1.20 <3

Robot_Milk whoopsie the logic checks if any fertility is the same as the original, and not if they are all the same.

Ah I think I misspoke, it also drops as soil when there are less nutrients in it as well as in its default state. Only the addition of fertilizer makes it still drop.

Robot_Milk yeah, I suppose I could make that configurable, but it was requested back in the day. Allows one to recover the dirt when there is no extra nutrient info. Can be useful for terra preta for example, if you need it for crafting. This only happens if the farmland is in its default state, so it's balanced.

Deleted my old comment with a bit less info. Blocks will only drop as farmland when they have fertilizer in them, even if they're missing nutrients. Is this intended behavior?

OliverRook no change was done, but it appears to work fine for 1.20 at a cursory glance. I simply recompiled the mod as a zip and for 1.20

Wow, I literally just found this mod less than 10 minutes ago and it updated after 6 months less than 5 minutes ago XD

PukupukuDragon it works fine in 1.19.8. DLL-only mods are an official modding template, and all the modinfo information is contained in the assembly info. The game can load it fine, but apparently the vanilla api for server download doesn't recognise DLL-only mods. Edit: repackaged as zip.

This doesn't work, add a modinfo.json.

agaric I haven't tested, but I don't think 1.20 changed anything about farmland. I could be wrong tho...

i think it'd be nice to have word from the author, but your word is enough for me lol

I played around for a bit with it to test it, and it seemed to be working fine on 1.20.1

does this work with 1.20.1?

NastyFlytrap did it have any extra nutrients? If they're default it should drop normal dirt. Mod has had no changes since it worked, and should also be compatible with CAN crops. Do you have any other mod that alters farmland?

Mod doesnt seem to work. I've had it installed for months, and the medium soil i placed two weeks ago wasnt always dropping when i mined it a few seconds ago. V1.19.8 and v1.1.1

VaelophisNyx does it? Why does the official modding template allow to release as dll only then lol. modinfo is included tho, just in the assembly info instead of as a file. The game itself can read that when loading the mod, so it'd be weird if it can't in other circumstances...

shouldn't it need the zip and mod info files because servers need that to download automatically?

ok thank you

FrazierFr this mod has no assets so it's a pure executable, no need for a zip. Vintage story and mods are a dll file plus some assets.

.dll ?