Idk but the mason seems too overpowerd

the down side is barely noticeable compared to the upsides is bringing

im playing in a server and unironically everyone is picking mason like its a better version of commoner

Endurance

Thank you so much for your kind words <3  I will maintan the mod as long I can.. :)

This mod really makes me think hard about which class I wanna choose... usually I feel like I have a class that is 'right' for me but the classes here are all so compelling that I never know which one to pick. To be clear: This is amazing and how classes in games should be!

Squeamish on the Ranger doesn't make sense to me, they probably wouldn't have become a ranger as a job if they were squeamish in the first place, having to deal with road kill, killing injured animals as a mercy, dealing with other peoples' stupidness ect. 

As a job that would need knowledge of animals and such the Ranger's negative to animal loot find is bad, if anything it should be a bonus find to animal drops for them because of knowing how to properly skin and clean an animal.

DejFidOFF Oh, that's very good to know! I thought the metal pans were only more decorative versions of the wooden pans. I'll be sure to use this knowledge in my upcoming playthrough with this class :)

Xtremely

Thank you. I will have that one on smith on my mind. However Smith cna make very useful metal pans with have a huge loot table.

Tacet

no comment...I just use my brain and knowledge of my mod and the game.....

I agree with TheOlRazzlDazzl regarding the Smith. It feels like he doesn't have many benefits, especially when compared to the mason. The mason has traits that are several times better, and the negatives on it are almost negligible. The smith however, has really bad negatives in comparison, and the third trait is well... not very useful.

I feel like making it so that items forged by the Smith have more total durability would give it more of a specialty, as other classes often have more traits related to their line of work. Otherwise, it could be possible to take inspiration (or borrow some mechanics, with permission ofc) from certain smithing mods in order to add certain class-specific recipes like the "Bellows" and "Blacksmith Gloves" from BlackSmith Enhancements, or you could give the blacksmith cheaper recipes when it comes to bulk crafting.

Anyways, I absolutely love this mod. It definitely deserves its title as one of the best class mods for this game. Either way, I wish you the best of luck with your future modding endeavors!

DejFidOFF Oh cool, I did not realize you could see what version people downloaded/are running! That's a helpful mod DB feature.

Tacet

You did not help either.. Of course, it's a claypot-*-fired because you have up to date version of the mod.. Not him. He is running mod version for VS 1.20.xx on VS 1.21.xx .....

Mitrae The third component is a fired ceramic cooking pot, any color should do. The one requirement is that the crafter needs to be a Chef class. Has your chef tried yet?

(I was checking out this mod for my own server pack and peeked at the code to answer your question because the response you recieved gave me secondhand embarassment. 🤪)

Mitrae

Aaaach again, again, again.. Read, read and read.

I will not respond to and resolve any bugs and suggestions in comments or private messages,
that's what the issue tracker is for. But first check the Mod Troubleshooting tab.

After that please, please  use proper version of the mod with proper version of the game...

Good evening! 

Thank you so much for such a fantastic mod. We're loving it. But none of my little gamer group playing on our server can figure out the recipe for the copper cooking pot. I read the comments and it appears that someone asked the same question a ways down but your answer still left us confused. You mentioned that the recipe is a hammer, copper plate, "claypot burned"- We have no clue what this is? I've tried a raw cooking pot, a ceramic cooking pot, and mulitple color variations, plus a ceramic planter and the rest of the server has reported a zillion other things but nobody has figured out how to make it. Nobody wanted to ask because we're all positive that it's probably something totally simple that we're just overlooking, but I drew the short straw so here I am asking. 

Can someone please tell us the recipe to create the copper cooking pot? 

Signed ~ A server full of Noobs ;) 

The pirate gold coin item from merchant class is not present. It is something intended or a bug?

Lumber jacks are supposed to have access to an item called "elegant doors"

These items do not exist.

Is there something im missing here?

It really feels like the Smith class doesn't have enough sauce to make it fun to play. I wound up switching from Smith to Mason in a playthrough I did with my friends a few months ago because Mason just feels like the same thing but way better-- you get access to much more useful crafting options. This might just be because I play with Combat Overhaul, but the tool kits for reparing shields and armor feel useless-- none of our armor got low enough that we felt we needed to use one. Miner already has the metal pans but I guess it's cool for Smith to have it too if you don't have a friend to make them for you, and personally I've never actually used a bomb in this game but that could be another Me Problem lmao. Defender is a great fit but again, Mason has that already with way more benefits and a ton of health. It really just feels like Smith needs something more, maybe more stuff related to actual metalworking and the creation of tools and armor rather than just reparing/maintaining them. Are there any plans to implement something like that in the future?

To be clear this isn't me requesting or demanding anything I'm just wondering if you'd consider reworking the class if you felt like it lol. Otherwise I might just learn to mod and touch it up in my own time :P

Decco

It´s done, thank you for translation

Hello! Yes, adding the pt-br.json will help us a lot, so that both new and veteran players can read the mod more easily. Thank you very much for updating and implementing the translation.

Decco

Hello o/ Nice to hear that! So if there will be pt-br.json & pt-pt.json in lang it will works for you?

Hello! How are you? I hope you're doing well. I'm from Brazil and I have a server. We really like your mod, so I decided to create a Brazilian Portuguese translation. I replaced the English files with the Portuguese translation because I couldn't add an additional "pt" file to the mod. Would you be so kind as to officially add the translation? Thank you very much in advance.

https://www.mediafire.com/file/6di2wwfvwp8hl1h/allclasses2.0.7.zip/file

Hey so some people on our server and me cant pick a class cuz the selection window turns completly black except the character in it.

You can hear the confirm button when you hover over it and it will work but it seems like everything else is broken.
We are unsure what exactly causes this and why to only some and not all people.

Does anyone else have this issue?

Anyone have any issues with the tinker using the tuning spear?

Not one hacked locust in 20 tries.

I took All Classes off, got it in three

Anyone else?

The only pots I can mount on an elk are the ones from this mod. The vanilla pots don't work anymore. 

TeenyTinyWyvern

You can make thread in the issue trackert where we can talk about that.

Will there be an update to the Mason class now that Hardened Clay Blocks are just NOT a thing anymore?

I tested using a Longbow and a Stirrup Crossbow from CO against a friend in steel plate shooting the torso. Me, Ranger, did 6.3 dmg with iron bolt. Tailor did 6.3 also. We both did 6.48 with Longbow and a Broadhead arrow from More arrows. Also, the 25% faster draw doesnt apply since it takes both tailor and I the same time to draw a crossbow, and im assuming whatever accuracy bonus they have (The class specifically mentions most accurate class but has no accuracy bonus) doesnt apply either because it is impossible to keep a longbow drawn and hit a target further than pike range.

I'm using the lastest version of All classes with combat overhaul, but as a ranger class I don't think I'm getting the +100% ranged damage boost, not sure though since I cant test on actual player target to know the exact damage. If someone can test it further please do, I'm only playing on singleplayer.
EDIT: it seems it's not CO problem, I've tested without CO and Ranger still do not deal x2 ranged damage. Maybe I misunderstood the perk?
UPDATE 2: I forgot to toggle CO lib when testing, it seems the very lib itself will cause the bug.

If you're open to suggestions mine is change the name of Mystic to Librarian. The name would fit their description in addition it also reads very reminiscent of "The Librarians", a film/tv series about a group that gathers, secures and protects magic/occult knowledge/items. A rename would fit the role while also possibly introducing people to a new franchise.

Eclipsse

Firstaval, Idk what´s animal fat, I know just a fat.. There is an isue tracker. Since the pots are just vanilla ones  I don´t see  a problem.

DejFidOFF Ok, yea, I looked at the files, won't be too hard to achieve, just easier with configs. I would say though that imo all the classes need more debuffs to enocurage specialisation and cooperation in multiplayer please. 

CaptainJake

This is a content mod, and always will be. So no configs, sorry. You can make your own patch or if using in single edit classes.

Please add a config file, some of these are OP imo and I want to add more debuffs - for example Homesteader should have more debuffs from using armour imo.

Degen_Andi

There is an issue tab up there.. CO seriously modifying the game.. so.. And see.. disclaimer in description of AC..

I am not forcing anybody to use this.it's really not my fault. I will not modify my mod to be compatible with every other ... here..

If somebody asks nicely.. Maybe I can do something..But always don't forget. Every modder do mods in their free time and for free.. We own you nothing..

Just a heads up, Even now in 2.0.5 the Great Axe of Lumberjack's doesn't work with Combat Overhaul (When CO's installed you can't mine with it in Survival).
With and without CO the axe also appears in the hand with the axehead facing the wrong way so the item's in-hand transform is off.

I imagine that the Compatibility with CO people are talking about means that the classes already include the traits they have in CO. For example: 'Bows proficiency (Combat Overhaul) (+50% draw speed).

MrJewsbury

done..

MrJewsbury

hmm.. ok, that´s actually good point. I will do that.

DejFidOFF Can you make it so that rangers can also make recurve bows? the description says they can make bows but they can't make recurve. 

DejFidOFF Thank you! thats pretty simple actually

DejFidOFF oh, ok, sorry, didn't read the description completely

R0D96

You can make "patching" mod and update to the database. Or if it´s for single player, just unpack, edit traits, zip again and add to mod folder

does anyone know how I can modify the traits and actually save them

ParaToxic

Sanetless

What you mean CO compatibility. Have reports that this mod works alongside of Co.

Any plans to add CO compatibility?

NotTheSolaire Yeah It's safe to use it with CO, tho none of the traits in CO will be on any of these new classes.

NotTheSolaire

idk never experienced CO

is it safe to run Combat overhaul and this mod together on a server?

Wolpfy

Guess no in close future.

Hey, just woundering if you'll ever gonna make a version of the mod that is compatable with some of the Combat overhual mods traits? :)

Chlo_acqua MischievousCloud

solved in release 2.0.1

MischievousCloud Chlo_acqua

Which language?

All descriptions are also messed up for me as well. 

Hello! having a issue with the mod where all the descriptions for the class traits are messed up. Not displaying what they do correctly and not showing what the main productive unique item stat does

Parf

Hello o/ Im pretty sure, after update, this mod can be save to add to existing world. And yes, players which wants to change class to some from this mod needs to allowcharselonce to apply. The ones which are good with vanilla class doesn´t needs to allowcharselonce to apply.

quick question! would this mod be safe to add to an existing world in 1.21 once it updates? would players need the ol' allowcharselonce to apply modified vanilla class traits? thanks for all the work you're doing.

TheDucK80

You welcome. It doing fine. Seems like update for 1.21 will be released on monday 1st of september.
Some bugs will be solved. Metal pots will have new codes, will working properly like vanilla ones, some minor ones will be corrected. 
Rest of translations will be added.. Will be necesery to remap files. And as always make a backup. :)

DejFidOFF
Sweet! W modder. Thanks king

TheDucK80

I will working on it

Will this work in version 1.21?

DejFidOFF Thanks

Entaris

hammer, copper plate, claypot burned

Can't find the recipe for COPPER pot. 

I've got all the others.

Rhyagelle

idk

Is this compatible with "The Working Classes"? 

MrSuslik

Tohle si něpřečtu, nemluvím jazykem tvého kmene. I kdybych rozuměl, tak od toho tu je issue tracker.

DejFidOFF

«Не работает черта рейнджера, отвечающая за примитивного лука и грубых стрел. При применении поместите рецепт в сетку изготовления ничего не выводится.

Также все рецепты других модов, связанных с чертой «Мастер лука», сломаны. В частности, речь идет о моде для арбалетов — из-за нефункциональной черты «Мастер лука» невозможно изготовить составные конечности арбалета.

Have I explained the issue clearly enough?

MrSuslik

Every issue/bug will be resolved after someone proper reported the issue and describe that. I don't have a crystal ball to predict bugs.

When will the broken trait responsible for crafting Bow and arrows (Sentry / Renger) be fixed?"

Boneberg

yes, I can

Hello, friend. A friend and I made a translation into our native language (Brazilian Portuguese). I would like to know if you are interested in including it officially in your mod. I edited the scripts and he made the translation.

Started a new run and noticed some of the panning tables are still not right (copper has Iron and chrome in its list for sand) and (tin bronze still has chrome in its list for sand). Both are not in the iron pans list

At the first the command is /player [playername] allowcharselonce and both working for me. even .charsel

And what my mod have to do with that?

In fact, I'm the administrator, and I can't re-select the classes.

Aimli_

on SMP you need  to ask admin. In single player go creative (/gm2) and do .charsel command

How to reselect classes? I can't reselect classes after typing /player [playername] allow charselonce, it says “ingameerror-can't change classes”.

DerangedDragon

Use Extrainfo

Do you think you could end up posing a google doc or excel with the chances for the items with each different quality of pan?

danhere same. I pretend I'm washing out the pot between uses ^_^

danhere Same issue with the golden cooking pots.

Hello, there seem to be an error with the class missing config files.

ERROR: The class homesteaderclass does not exist in the configurations, probably a custom class without configs

I'm running into an issue with copper cooking pots where once it's been emptied, putting it back on the fire doesn't allow it to be refilled. You have to take it off the fire, put it down, and use a bowl to take out "nothing" from inside it. Then it can be reused. Not sure if anyone else has had this issue?

RazVonCoon

Yeah, I have the same question about why medic has civil rather than squeamish. The medic class allows me to make flower and dry grass poultice, but I'm also punished because the class reduces my ability to get the ingredients for the poultice...

@DejfidOFF but not for me.

Im just curious but why is a combat expert (The ranger in this case) squeamish? IS it just to prevent the class from overshadowing the hunter class?

Austin_Legend

It´s working on 4 of my servers and at other 171 servers worldwide.

Does not actually work on my server. Has seemed to work in singleplayer though, but can get it to work multiplayer.

ZBlank

Hello, thank you. It´s cool idea, but, I am not a programmer, I make just content mods so this is out of my range. I can add maybe something to chef class but not sure what.

hey, cool creator, damn good mod, I play as a miner, I love the process, and I also have a friend and comrade who plays as a cook (we also have a couple more added mods with culinary alteria and XSkills). а frying pan is good , but there are not enough food bonuses in this class, so to speak, otherwise this class WILL BE HUMILIATED by the FARMER with his bags of WHEAT, RAW ONIONS and stew, a great example is Walheim with his temporary food bonuses.

RayoRey

Try to remove another mod.

Good evening, I removed the mod, and it still won't let me make firewood normally. I use it on the server and it gives us that problem. I would appreciate your help.

DejFidOFF

Yes I saw a big thank you ^^

AcidNight

I add tinker trait to Tinker class in last update

DejFidOFF

Hello, indeed my translator put class for the handyman trait which is linked to the clockmaker

AcidNight

so you are wrong. you don´t need a class but trait..

DejFidOFF

Hello, yes I thought so too but apparently he didn't adapt it to this class, I'll have to see if I know how to add it

AcidNight

there is a Tinkerer class in this mod

Hello, no tinkerer planned? I have a mod that requires this class but I can't find it.

Shrapnel

There was a mistake. You can´t get iron from sand, not meteoric. You can get those things only with bronze and iron pan and from bony soil. Chromite you can get also from bony soil.
Get Extra info and you will see looting table from that pans in handbook and much more...

I think the loot table for the bronze and iron pans have been switched, I was getting Hematite, Chromite, and Meteoric Iron on a tin bronze pan (so much in fact that I made the iron pan with the Hematite I got panning), but with the Iron pan I have not seen one of them in over 32 blocks of panning. I am getting more items with the Iron pan but getting lower quility ones seems odd. (Note am getting Fire clay on the Iron Pan I was not getting on the tin-bronze pan).

GrimmSpector

no

Is there a way to make this compatible with Combat Overhaul?

@Wr4Th_0f_D0g Actually I think I might be wrong on it. I tried running without the mod, and still have the same thing happen. But I found I could chop firewood by right clicking with an axe so. I probably have another mod that did it. 

Neverendingname I've personally never noticed this but if that's really the case then remove the line "requiresTrait": "carpenter", from the recipe giving you trouble in assets\allclasses\recipes\grid\lumberjack.json

So I'm noticing a different issue with firewood. Quite simply, I can't make any at all, citing a need for the Lumberjack class. And I'm not sure what config needs to change so I can locally fix it. Any help would be nice. 

btw the stats for charcoal, tree drops, and crop drops do nothing because they aren't part of the base game and you didn't add anything to give them functionality. just thought I'd let you know.

Hello. I have translated your mod into Russian.

I leave a link: Russian translate

Apologies for asking, but what did the most recent update do? (1.2.3)

I'm translating the mod to pt-br, so I'd like to suggest a change to one thing.
On other mods related to cooking, bismuth bronze isn't used normally because it's supposed to be a bit toxic. You could make it a mid-tier potion/glue making pot like the black bronze one. (Surprisingly, the black bronze is NOT toxic, but it does look lika a black cauldron anyway, so...)

vanillastein

Just don't do it, it's not designed for that. It need to make a special models for that to do. At this moment have not time to do that.

Neti

ok, thank you

GaymerMike

It´s caused by incompatibility with some mod or you have removed come class mod and you still have that class

Hi. I wrote a translation of classes description in your mod into Polish. It would be great if you would add it.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1omNr156apb0IZcugCiZAu4AaM2_Pmoeg/view?usp=sharing

My suggestion: you could add the ability for alchemists to breed plants into potions from the alchemy mod.
Thanks.

VanillaBryce

No, I can´t. And it´s not dependency, but compatibility.

I love this mod, but I think it has unlisted dependencies. Can you remove the references to hydrate or dierate from this mod so it can be standalone?

DejFidOFF my bad, with xskills, some skills get a + or - % in exp gain for skills, but with these classes, it dont.

rjc523

which bonus? for what? from what? You guys talk to me with some non earth code which I can´t decode..

DejFidOFF does it just not give bonus with xskills?

@GaymerMike

it tells me nothing.. Its working form me

hello, i have a friend on my server when he types .charsel his game crashes. the rest are able to chance class except him, he uninstalled the game and reinstalled but still same issue

SkollDrachen

It works alongside xskills

does this work with xskills?

when cooked and emptied and try to take them out all at once then i crash

GaymerMike

Can´t replicate

Im crashing when having more than one iron pot on campfire empty and trying to pick them up to place down and right click with bowl to reset them so i can keep cooking

Saytromi

For this feature you need to have also installed wildfarming mod

GaymerMike

Take of pot from firepit, put it down, click on it with empty bowl.

Привет. На версии 1.20rc_8 я не могу обналичить руду с помощью metalpan-tinbronze и медного предмета из seal gravel (muddygravel). В GuideBook этот рецепт правильный
UPD: need mod WildFarming for fix this - answer DejFidOFF(Author)
TY

Hey, im having an issue with the bismuth cooking pot that its not showing the cooking slots, i cooked once in it but now i put it in the campfire it heats up as if food is in it but there are no slots to add the food in.

hello! I like how the ranger in Ar-class is set up more then in this because of the "squeamish: debuff and I am looking at somehow editing it out I found the "classes.json" and tried to edit it there however that didnt seem to work is there any way to edit these at all?

TheRealFlynn

Ohh thank you and thank you :)

there's a typo in your page where it says staff instead of stuff. Cool mod :)

Aricus

Its just a question, no I will not downgrade that  for 1.19, sorry

Might be a weird ask, any way to make this work with 1.19.x?

DeafJaeger

You need Miner class and craft that - fixed in 1.0.6

How to get mining laterns?

Zanklev

Please don´t spam the chat - there is the issue tracker. It seems game realated bug.  Fix in 1.0.5

TheGrunge

Yes I miss that, thank you.

mystic has no downside stacking that weak of a hunger with pilferer, if you missed that

TotRosenRot

you can do what you need to do for single player..

bringitonwimps

idk how well this works with xskill, not tested that far. This have not modifyers for xskills.
.allowcharselonce and .charsel are commands to let players select claas again.. so works with all class mods...

Hi, Can i delete all negative traits from this? Me and my friend are not fan of debufs for characters, it make it hard to choce with one we want to play. And negative traits are better on servers with more people anyway. Like for your server.

do you know how well this works with xskills?.. I have the older class mod that adds like 4 or 5 dif classes but this is more comprehensive and i like what you have done.  The other class moid im refering to has modifyers for xskills, as in the miner earns farming skills slower and the farmer earns mining skills slower but has a boost in the farming skills and vicer vs for the miner in farming(fyi i mayt be naming the actual skills boost and hinderence wrong but you get the idea im sure)

Not a big deal if it doesnt im trying to figure out now how to load this and shift from that mod to this one maybe, or maybe have both.  Any info/help on this would be appreciated, thanks.  also does the .allowcharselonce and .charsel work with this mod?  idk if that base game function or because of the other mod.

Thanks again!