No issue Brun glad i could help.

CrazedVantaBlack
Thank you for the reply! I have just downloaded and comfirmed that wildcraft trees is the culprit for this issue. The mod replaces all of the fire pit "cooking" for almost all of the log types, which in return overrides what I've made. I believe I already know how to fix this problem and I should have an update out sometime tonight.

Update: I've contacted the creator of Wildcraft Trees to see if they can help me implement compatibility. Sorry for any inconvenience in the meantime.

I can Brun confirm that the update has not fixed the issue. redwood corners are the only thing that registers when you try to make wood ash. i too am using Wildcraft Trees and shrubs and Wildcraft revival. so it might very well be a conflict.

Schplim
I've just put out an update (V1.1.4) which should fix this issue. Let me know if your problem still exists.

The mod seems really great but sadly I'm having the same issue as Artor where I can't make wood ash out of anything else than corner redwood logs. My guess is that it's a mod compability problem. (either Trees and Shrubs or Wild Farming revival as those are probably the only 2 ones I currently have that add new logs) But for some reason the mods themselves seem to break the recipe in a way that you cannot use the vanilla logs either.

Parf
An interesting idea for sure lol. To be honest I barely know how the repairing mechanic works for broken clutter but I can look into it and see what I can do.

love this as a supplement for leather-making! do you think it'd be appropriate to add a cleaning functionality for broken clutter using soap? i know glue repairs it, but this could provide an alternate way of acquiring/fixing clutter with soap on hand.

wael6

As practical, realistic, and awesome as that would be I'm not sure of a way to pull it off. It would have to be done in code and could get quite complex; far more than I am capable of doing at this time. I'll keep it in mind for a future update nonetheless. Thanks for the suggestion!

could be cool if wood used as fuel could become ash (maybe an item dropping when it finishes to burn or dropping corresponding on the amount you burned when you break the firepit/clean it with a new tool/sticks ?

Michael00181
I love that idea! I will definitely add it in the next update!

Delighted to hear that Brun, I admit I don't know a thing about coding so the simplest solution for now would lkely be using some ammount of soap with a bandage to make an item like "Bandage and soap portion." Maybe make them heal 5 HP vs the 7HP od the alcahol soaked bandages but without the drying out effect? It'd still make them better than the regular bandages 3HP. 

Michael00181
I have thought about adding more direct uses for the player. Both of your ideas do seem like they would fit well in this mod but I'll have to see if I can figure out how to implement it. I am still in the learning process of mod development, especially when it comes to coding, but I'll see what I can do!

would you ever consider some other benefits to soap? such as a temporary buff from cleaning yourself with soap that reduces animal detection range or perhaps a buff to healing effectiveness for some time after cleaning yourself with scented soaps? Perhaps making a cleaned bandage that isn't as good as the alcahol saoked one but is still good as you've portioned some soap with it to clean wounds. 

Artor
I'm not sure what you mean. From what I can see everything looks normal. If it's liquid lye you're trying to make you have to click on the white liquid first in order to see the barrel recipe.

Edit: I just realized what you meant and I believe I have fixed the problem with log variants not cooking into wood ash. These changes take place in version 1.1.2

1.20.12

https://imgur.com/a/8GDAYnQ

Just ain't working.

Aeonsteel

I'm glad you like the mod! I'll be sure to add trading in the next small update along with the next two flowers/soaps. 😊

This mod seems really cool! Can't wait for traders to buy them, I always like immersive production of items to trade for rusty gears. This will help scratch that itch, since Book Trader is currently broken.

Artor
What version are you playing on? I just tested on both 1.20.12 and 1.21.0-pre.1 with no issues.

 So for some reason I can only seem to make wood ash from redwood trees.

I've ran into some minor issues and had a lot of stuff to deal with irl so the next update will be later on this week but definitely out by the weekend. I've already implemented RowanSkie's suggestion for potash as well as a new soap bar and liquid system based off of SeniLiX's ideas for the mod! Next up on the list is buying/selling soap bars and bottled liquid soap to traders.

RowanSkie
I can work on that this afternoon and hopfully have an update tonight. There are some other things I'd like to add/change as well so if not tonight then definitely tomorrow. Thanks for the suggestion!

This can potentially replace this other mod if only it were able to make potash. 

SeniLiX
Very interesting ideas! I think soapy water would be a great way to make the cleaning process more realistic. I suppose I'll have to think up another use for bars of soap then since I could just create the liquid soap in a barrel in the first place. Maybe the bars could be colored/scented with various flowers and be sold to traders or collected as displayable items.

A couple of suggestions:

Instead of simply combining the mordanted cloth with a piece of soap in a crafting grid, how about introducing soap water?

Step 1: X number of litres of water in a barrel. Dump a piece of soap in it and it becomes soap water.

Step 2: Have the cloth soak in the barrel for X amount of time.

Second suggestion:

Use Soap water to let the player clean a dirty pot by soaking it for X amount of time.

Hydromancerx
At a glance it would appear that floralrat's "Oils! From seed to Substance" mod takes a more complex approach at turning grains and vegetables into oils with many uses. His mod also has a lot more uses and recipes for soap and oil. My mod takes a more basic approach to soap and lye while maintaining similar functionality. At the moment "Soap and Lye" is just a small mod that stems from a much larger code mod I'm developing called "Vintage Prehistory". While in development I thought it might be a good idea to release this mod as I had not seen a similar mod and I thought people might enjoy these features on thier own.

How's this mod compare to the soap from the Oils mod?

Astella
I have fixed to download for real this time 😅. Thank you for pointing it out!

Hi! I was trying to download this mod but its not downloading as a winzip!

Moon_Dew
Thanks for the heads up! I've fixed the download now so everything should be working. Let me know if you discover any other issues!

You're probably gonna want to reupload your mod, it's not downloading as a zip file.