Yassaff I am currently working on the rest of the roofing blocks. Expect them sometime this week

Hello! I realy love this mod and I was wonderring if there are any plans for the wooden planks roof variants?

MrSandman Thanks for telling me! I fixed it in the newest patch

Placing cables from the Electricity mod onto thatch roofs results in a crash. I have not tested it on clay shingle roofs.

Edit: Placing any block under already constructed roof pieces results in a crash.

Javidac More Piles is 100% compatible. I play with it myself and use it with this mod. You need to change the toolmode on the things you want to place to "place on ground"

oneil one roof is inherently incompatible with this mod. It would take too much effort to make it compatible

Will there eventually be compatibility with the More Piles mod? It makes it a little hard to start making roofs when the controls are the same for starting a roof frame and making a pile of sticks.

A patch like that would make your roof mods permanent residents in my mods folder. :D

Hi ! great ideas ! will it work with the one roof mod ? 

Bartandules I'll consider both when I get done with some more variants.

ParallelPenguins That's something I didn't expect. I'll get a patch out for that soon.

Buildings that generate with roofing have all the roof blocks facing one way. So if a mod adds a trader's house, or any naturally generated roof really, is gonna be a bit wonky.

I'm glad to see shingles have been added to roof types now! Are there any plans to add mod support for mods that add shingles or other types of firewood, like Clayworks or wildcraft trees?

crupette Ah excellent! Thanks for the info. Looking forward to playing with this more :).

Yootah Thank you for the detailed report! I'm working on a complete rewrite at the moment, so this should be patched in the next release.

Edit-2: there still is some sort of incompatibility even with "CtrlKey" configuration below, or without. An NRE on this mod's side in GetToolMode, /home/jon/prg/vintagestory/inworld-roofing/inworldthatching/src/CollectibleBehavior/BehaviorFrameMaterial.cs:line 234

Crash occurs when:

• Ctrl+Shift+RClick placed stick pile exceeds some number (24? 32? 40? differs each time) of items, on final placement

• And also when Shift placing sticks into pit kiln, same exception location

Edit-1: the player can fix this manually if they tweak More Piles' config as follows:

This way making a stick pile now requires pressing both Ctrl + Shift, whereas frames can be placed with just Shift click.

Compatibility with More Piles would be cool.

Currently with both active and on Shift + Right Click the making of stick pile from that mod takes priority. Perhaps explicitly disable piling for sticks that are in frame mode?

Dusktracer The sticks don't stack because I had to use some item metadata to store the placement modes. There should be an additional tooltip on the unstacked sticks telling you how to clear the attribute data. The straw dropping instead of dry grass is a bug though. I'll get a patch out for that soon

Love the concept of this mod! Found one small issue when playing around with it so far. When I break a thatched roof, I get back sticks that don't stack with other sticks and it returns straw rather than dry grass. You can get the sticks to stack again by placing them on the ground and picking them back up, but the straw transformation makes it hard to get the same color on my roof when I messed up a corner XD.

crupette i believe so? its the one you stick hay sticks and a fuel source plus clay in.

Aloy I'm not getting that crash on my side. Do you mean the pitkiln? Can you DM me on Discord the list of mods you're using?

it crashes when making firepits now, specifically when i try to place the second layer of sticks.

wildejackson Iiell wojtek16 I'll try to make that happen, doesn't look too bad...

I love this vision for the game, please keep going!

I 3rd that! I feel like this would work perfectly!

Beautiful mod!

I would like to second the suggestion of wildejackson

This may sound annoying but is there any possibility of compatability with art of growing? It adds actual thatch (As opposed to dry grass/hay) blocks as well as straw blocks. No idea how practical it would be to copy the behavour over to those blocks.

Brilliant. This is a good direction. Keep up the good work.

Dzieciol That option already exists. The old recipes are usable when you deactive the mod or don't install it.

(The current Vanilla solution and this mods solution are so fundamentally different, that an "either, or" option doesn't make sense.)

I love the concept,but there should be an option to bring back old recipe.

I've been thinking about something like this for a while! Maybe it can even be expanded to all types of roof!