Hello. can you add support https://mods.vintagestory.at/vintageengineering mod. to make steel in vint furnace like steel. iron + cocke?

Do you plan on adding the earthy orange variation to the red clay molds fired in the pit kiln? All the mold mods i could find dont have it for some reason which is kinda annoying.

can you add a lantern for it please

Getting these errros basically every second - 

[Warning] Failed resolving a blocks blockdrop or smeltedstack with code game:platemold-fire-fired in beehivekiln-burn - 

I tried deleting the clayforming folder and that didnt appear to do anything

i'm having an odd bug, when this mod is installed at least vanilla more molds stops talking to its config file. 1.0.15 for this mod and 2.1.2 for the molds mod, granted i am still on 1.22.3 so i guess i do need to finally get around to that, but would that change things?

Hi. Does anyone have experience with this mod in combination with zippys sky steel on 1.21.x?

Hah, I was quite suprised when I saw that this mod is where the bulk ingot molds came from!

I like the balance for bulk (requiring breaking for the big ones), and I like to have plate molds. But yeah, that seems like something better suited for a seperate mod! Or at least, once the config is up, it's opt-in rather than opt-out, as most people will not expect a metal mod to add in molds.

Mongster, Teotale, and GotoFinal
I will admit, I did not have the proper documentation in the mod's discription for the metal molds and that has been corrected.

As Goto has stated, the clayforming recipes can simply be removed without fear of needing to re-disperse the mod as all recipes are handled Server Side. Hopefully, this will be remidied in the near future by adding in a config/command to enable/disable the molds, that is, unless, more people simply want them removed.

As for the Quenching and Tempering Mechanics, I'm unsure of how that's a complaint. I simply made my tools compatible with the latest features of Vintage Story.

It was cool to have a tier of metal slightly above steel, but this mod adds a bunch of stuff it doesn't mention in the description. Considering that and the new quenching/tempering mechanics, I'll be uninstalling. 

I like the idea of meteorite steel, but plate molds don't fit in here. That should be a feature of a separate mod. As a server owner, I'd like to have meteorite steel, but I don't want to have unbalanced plate molds

GlytchMeister So, the issue with Combat Overhaul is the mod has changed so much that I can't keep up with compatability while also updating my mod so I've decided to forego the compatability with Combat Overhaul. It's simply too much work, especially right now.
As for QP's ChiselTools, their mod is auto-filling the Meteoric Steel Anvil (That my mod adds in) with a wildcard. Better Ruins did this too but the fix has to be on their end.

I spotted an error in my logs, here's the generic version:

[Error] Patch # (target: game:itemtypes/combatoverhaul/spear.json) in meteoricsteelcompat:patches/armory/itemtypes/weapons/spear.json failed because supplied path /attributes/XXXXXXXXX/DamageStrengthByType is invalid: The json path /attributes/XXXXXXXXXX/ThrowAttack/DamageStrengthByType was not found. Could traverse until /attributes, but then 'XXXXXXX' does not exist.

I beleive it should be /attributes/Modes/XXXXXXX

I also see there's an issue with QP's ChiselTools:

[Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code chiseltools:chiseledanvil-meteoricsteel in Grid recipe
[Error] Grid Recipe 'chiseltools:decorative anvil': Output Block code chiseltools:chiseledanvil-meteoricsteel cannot be resolved

that seems to be a grid recipe that is lookig for meteoric steel as a type of metal that an anvil can be?

it happened regardless of my other mods, but I just reinstalled and it seems to be fixed now

BuilderBoy02 I've only seen this error appear when the mod is loaded with certain other mods that change the base files as opposed to adding to base files like I do.

Sadly, as much as I'd like it to be, Combat Overhaul compatability isn't going to be innately available within Meteoric Steel.
There are too many changes that happen to the base files and far too many changes between versions

Hello, meteoric steel armor doesn't have durribility or a flat damage reduction for me. Is anyone else having this bug or is there anyway for me to fix it? 

Incredible mod, i always felt like vanilla meteoric iron was underutilized since I jump straight to steel as soon as I get iron and don't think about meteoric iron at all.

Degen_Andi

There's no need to rush. The mod is already great. I have just suggested an idea.

Kaynereer I'd love to get an update out for 1.22 as soon as possible, but I've got something else in the works that I want done first so it'll have to wait.

This is just a suggestion. Meteorite steel should be oil-quenched.

I don't know how difficult it is to implement this. I wish not. 

would you be fine with a quick merge if i fix some of the new errors for the newer versions?

Grumman Combat Overhaul has had seven updates in the last five days. I'm doing what I can.
My mod is most compatible with Combat Overhaul 1.15.5. CO is currently up to 1.16.16

I apologize for not being able to keep up with Maltiez's update schedule but there's a lot to comb through and attempt to fix.

any work bein done to update with the latest release of co?

GarnetAnimations with Reforged Tools not being, officially, compatible with 1.21.1-6 and with 1.22's release candidate coming out soon I will probably not be adding in compatibility unless they update to 1.22.

Would you be willing to add compatibility with Reforged Tools?

EnderMelody Many of the compats will conflict. My mod is not perfect and there will be people who prefer the compat mod over just my mod. In the 1.1 version, I plan to have fully functional CO Compatability. As of right now, it's just some things I was able to throw together and adjust until there were no errors remaining.

are the 1.0.8 added compats conflicting with meteoric steal compat mod? will that mod be needed anymore?

Exile0fErini Thank you for bringing this to my attention. I'll see what I can put together in the next update.

I found a slight interaction between this and gloomeclasses where both are trying to input a steelanvil as far as i can tell, I've done a dirty personal fix by deleting the steelanvil.json file from gloome but was hoping that some compatability between the two can be made in the future?
and here's a screen capture of half of the issue i found, the other half being the exact same thing but for anvilpart-top-steel, I've looked at it several times and the cs:line 1854 and 279 are the same on both error sections.

Interesting. I experienced no issues in my playtest but I'll see what I can do to fix this issue in the upcoming update Turt

As of this comment the meteoric steel armors all have a spelling error inside the json, it should be "flatDamageReduction" not "flatProtection". All the meteoric steel armors also have no durabilty, and therefore do not work when equipped. I believe it is due to the value not being set correctly in the json as well. I'm also not sure if the armor is intended to have the protection reduction modifier that normal steel plate does but it is not on the meteoric steel plate.

Degen_Andi The author of Beter Ruins already answered that he will try to fix it in next patch, Im glad that its just warning and actually causes no issues.

Degen_Andi

I have added compatibility with this mod and betterruins inside betterruins for the next upcoming update of it. Until then it can be ignored.
https://github.com/NicIAss/betterruins/commit/54908f5f49994c7690216802c10dc10219202418

Sounds like a mod conflict to me, the armor is working perfectly fine on my end DariaOxo

GLaDOS_cz As for the Better Ruins issue, they generate a recipe for any block that would use the code "game:metalblock-new-plain-*" and, because my metal falls into this wide grouping, it's picked up. I haven't figured out how to fix it, other than to include this block variant that only has a creative decoration use.

There seems to be compability issue with better ruins mod: "(Server Warning) Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code game:metalblock-new-plain-meteoricsteel in Grid recipe

(Server Error) Grid Recipe "betterruins:recipes/grid/schematic-mechanical/mechanical.json": Output Block code game:metalblock-new-plain-meteoricsteel cannot be resolved

Is anyone else on mod v1.0.7 noticing issues with meteoric steel plate armor? We've just made it, and it seems to have no durability counter, and doesn't protect against attack. 

Yeah okay i commented there as well and they said somethings changed that they will need to look over,

Wulff My mod doesn't touch anything related to Armory. The only thing related to CO that my mod DOES touch, is the falx. I specifically patch in a variant of my Meteoric Steel Falx that gets picked up by Combat Overhaul. This is being caused by another mod.

From the looks of it, the Meteoric Steel Compatibility mod.

Im getting a wall of red errors relating to the compatibility patch. the errors seem to be for every weapon

https://imgur.com/a/aRjNam4

It's throwing console errors about grid recipes with chisel tools decorative anvil and  the mechanical schematic for better ruins atm

The finished anvil parts don't have their texture when being placed in the forge (reheating for assembly).

I'm not sure what exactly happened with the recipes because I remember going through the entire mod and changing everything from add to addmerge but it'll be fixed (again) in the next update.

Can confirm, smithing recipes are broken in 1.0.5. The smithing recipes patches should probably be using addmerge instead of add

With just the latest version of this mod on a fresh world I'm unable to craft regular steel tools/strips/etc (some items are still available). (Made a separate install just to isolate the issue)

Ezralyne Latest update re-enables the the Meteoric Steel Falx with Combat Overhaul. The version before enabled putting metal bits onto existing work items though there are some individuals who are stating that it's broken on their modded save files with 80+ mods so I suggest trying it out. I haven't found any issues with adding or removing my mod mid save yet.

Degen_Andi Ah I see, thanks for the info. I'll get back to the mod author with your insights see if there's anything they can do with the extra info. Any advice for them your end? Couldn't imagine it would be as simple as adding a wildcard their end lmao

Kripteekz So, because my mod simply expands the base game's files for everything except for the Steel Anvil Base/Top smithing recipe and the Falx Shape, all of those shape and texture paths are in the base game's .json files. The main problem .json files are the Knife, Axe, Shovel, Hoe, and Spear since they also have a stone variant. The way the vanilla .json files have some of their variants listed makes it difficult to easily patch those in. Essentially, I'd have to almost replace the entire .json (or large segments of the file) to make it work more easily but that would then make it very difficult for other mods to accurately patch those files since mine would change the full layout.

Hey, I just made a patch that adds support for all the CO/Armory stuff and also adds some armor using vanilla/CO meshes: https://mods.vintagestory.at/show/mod/33210

Degen_Andi Thanks for reply :) Interestingly the ones you edited apart from the hoe seem to work at least spawning one in in creative. Trying to forge is the no go haha. Where are the shape and texture paths located? Was having a look through the files of your mod to see if I could do what you said but unable to locate. Only thing in shapes is the falx

Kripteekz So, what I've done in almost every tool instance is I've simply added my metal to the vanilla variant list of tools. This makes the base game do most of the work (Shapes, animations, gui transforms, hand transforms, etc.) There are a few instances where I had to change the base files a little more agressively than that (Falx, Axe, Shovel, Hoe, Knife) because of how the vanilla .json files were written. As long as the shape and texture paths for my metal are properly replaced they should work innately though I may have to add in a few tweaks myself before it's possible. With the new version that just dropped, who knows what I'll need to change with the mod.

Degen_Andi Hey man love the mod, plus amazing first go at modding :)

Was wondering if this can be made compatible with toolsmith? Is compatible in the way your mod can use the tool handles and bindings fine but isn't using the updated textures from reforged tools. Also Reforged Meteoric Steel doesn't seem to resolve that with toolsmith unfortunately. I reached out to the toolsmith mod author prior and they said might be difficult their end with how the part rendering is set up; if needs to be their end any advice would be appreciated too so I can get back to them on it, cheers in advance :3

Ezralyne So, the mod still functions with both of those mods, the only problems are with CO, the tools will do "neutral" damage since it isn't marked as a damage type, the Falx recipe breaks (Not sure why yet) and with smithing plus, the only incompatabilities is tool head aren't returned on tool break (Should be able to fix that easily before long) and you can't add metalbits to existing work items. I'll do my best to work on these features in the coming week.

Keeping an eye on this one, my server currently runs both Smithing Plus and CO +armory though lol, if the compatibilty issues are fixed I will be adding this

Hi, I like the idea of this mod a lot and was wondering if there's any chance of ever making it compatible the combat overhaul family of mods

Mr_J_Soda Upon further digging, there are no matching error logs when loading into a new world in a new instillation of 1.21.4 with only my mod installed. This means that some other mod is enabling the Steel Anvil Top and Steel Anvil Bottom in your load order.

Unnamed_Hero I'll be able to work on the mod in the next couple days. I've had a lot of things come up this week and I've been a little too busy to really sit down and see what needs changed lately.

Hi
I'm sorry, is it already possible to bet on 1.21.4 or have you not finished yet?

Degen_Andi Ah okay, thank you :)

Migo Yes, this server error is also thrown in 1.21.0, 1.21.1, and 1.21.2. This exception is happening because I have the metalblocks for Meteoric Steel disabled. They will be enabled later, once I finalize more textures. The reason this happens is because my mod patches base game files and adds all varaints through the base game's process. Because BetterRuins just pulls those assets, the hidden assets will cause flags but won't cause issues in-game. When a recipe cannot be resolved it simply doesn't generate THAT specific input/output.

Mr_J_Soda Since the 1.21.4 update is brand new, I'm unfamiliar with how the code changes and thus, how my mod reacts. All I can promise is to look into it but it sounds like they enabled the Steel Anvil parts according to this log.

When loading with 1.21.4 it has a json error for one of the recipes.

6.10.2025 20:55:21 [Server Error] Grid Recipe 'betterruins:recipes/grid/schematic-mechanical/mechanical.json': Output Block code game:metalblock-new-plain-meteoricsteel cannot be resolved

Looks like an issue with Better Ruins and this mod.

So I just booted up my game with this mod, and I got the following errors in the server-main/log.

This is exactly the sort of thing I've been looking for! Thank you so much :)

Meteoric Iron can be processed into Meteoric Steel via the cementation furnace. Same restrictions but 1. It requires a Steel Anvil which my mod enables the crafting recipe for the Steel Anvil Top and Steel Anvil Base ICountFrom0.

I think it's combat overhalls turn to figure out what to do with it, and possibly maintain a compatability patch.

I know that if this was designed to only be a combat overhall version, I wouldn't want it.  This is basically "vanilla".

So, how DO you steel the metroirite iron?  Same process as iron to steel?  Or some modifications?

compatible with combat overhaul?

Hello, could you make it compatible with the weapon mod ancien armory please ?

Just the other day I was talking about how this should be a thing. Very cool.

Roscati Yeah! That would be great!

Nice Mod, would love to get this over to Maltiez for CO compat

Neat idea

As a meteoric iron fan, steel would be fire. Keep up the good work, hope for a compatability patch for combat overhaul and armory!

FLINT AND meteoric STEEL!!!