THIS MOD IS STILL IN DEVELOPMENT. CONTENT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

So, I finally figured out that due to the definition changes in Combat Overhual, SDR doesn't work with it's changed weapons and tools to break them down for brokem tool heads.  Would it be possible to add compatibility with CO for just such a thing?

~Jess

is there an option to turn off panning for packed dirt and low to high fertility soil?

I dont know if this is a bug or intended, but when I break down metal parts with a chisel for the cupronickel bits, I also get Iron. Is this intended, or a bug?

just a heads up in 1.22.7 when i type in recycling into handbook to llok at infor game looks up and crashes i had to uninstall for now till it is fixed just wanted you to know. no critical crash error just locks the client indefiently checked logs no crash error reported so I repeated and it happened happend agian so definitely an issue.

Also breaks the original recipies for breaking down items such as anvils.

love the art sooo much

here's a few other mods i would consider adding compat for:

• Boric Alchemy
• SmithingPlus

Found another place needing a compatibility patch: Expanded Matter adds powdered bauxite, and the version from there doesn't work with the tarnish treatment recipe here. The version from this mod still exists in the handbook but there's no way to craft it.

Getting these warnings when loading a world. It loads just fine, but would like to know what's the issue and if I can fix it on my side somehow. 

I get a lot of error spam about planks when I load this mod alongside In Dappled Groves, I think because IDG disables a lot of plank recipes. Any chance a patch could fix that?

EDIT: Yeah, probably best to make a compatibility patch for IDG that removes plank blocks from the list of items that this mod can disassemble, because IDG has its own way of doing that using in-world crafting instead of the grid.

me love your drawings

okay so first off, I absolutely adore this mod and am so so grateful both for certain functionalities I've been severely lamenting that I was lacking, *and* that it's a genuinely involved and fun chain rather than a boring quick-done thing, I love that kind of thing and this scratches that itch so much. ^_^ but alas! I have already found a bug! </3 I was putting some flint arrowheads into the crafting menu to get chunks, right? handbook says it should take ten arrowheads to one chunk result. I put 39 arrowheads in, it immediately ate them all into..... one chunk. just one. wahhhhhh XD so yeah figured should report asap. but thank you SO SO SO much for this mod omg. XD I'm definitely the same as you in not wanting to waste anything at all ever as much as possible! =P

getting this ereror in log no ide why
12.7.2026 14:18:17 [Error] Patch 17 (target: game:recipes/grid/glasspane.json) in somedisassemblyrequired:patches/sdr-scrapwood-enabler.json failed because supplied path /ingredients/W/allowedVariants/- is invalid: The json path /ingredients/W/allowedVariants/- was not found. No such element 'ingredients' at the root path

another handbook crash with mud

Running on 64 bit Windows 10.0.26200.0 with 31830 MB RAM
Game Version: v1.22.3 (Stable)
07/02/26 14:56:41 pm: Critical error occurred
Loaded Mods: antlertools@1.0.0, artskind121faces@1.0.0, betterarrows@1.0.1, BetterGrass@0.0.3, birdseye@0.1.4, bovinae@0.3.5, bradyrockyextraction@1.1.0, bulkknap@1.1.0, caninae@1.1.6, capreolinae@2.0.13, cbr@2.0.1, ceramicbucketbarrel@1.0.1, charlottesclothes@1.4.1, chiseltools@1.17.3, clickuptorches@1.1.1, coralcarbonate@1.0.1, creaturefootsteps@1.3.0, darkvision@1.3.5, deciduoustrees@1.6.0, diversediets@1.0.4, elephantidae@1.0.17, extensivebagrecycling@1.0.1, fastmushroomharvesting@0.1.0, fieldwright@0.1.5, flintchisel@1.0.5, flintsaw@1.0.1, floralzonescaperegion@1.0.28, floralzonescaribbeanregion@1.0.23, floralzonescentralaustralianregion@1.0.20, floralzonescosmopolitanregion@1.0.11, floralzoneseastasiaticregion@1.0.19, floralzonesmediterraneanregion@1.0.19, floralzonesneozeylandicregion@1.0.19, fowlmod@1.0.1, fullsailboatrefund@1.0.0, geoaddons@1.4.8, hydrateordiedrate@2.4.14, immersivefoliage@0.1.1, industrialdeco@1.0.8, interestingoregen@2.3.8, just3leaves@0.5.0, just3roots@0.6.0, kilnshelves@1.1.8, kyattonostickybranches@1.1.3, lettherebelight@0.0.9, lichen@1.6.4, lightlevelone@3.0.1, machairodontinae@1.1.10, manidae@1.0.19, manualdishes@0.1.2, meapineapplestone@1.0.2, mycodiversity@1.0.7, nocavemusic@1.0.0, norustcreatures@0.0.4, nudemod@1.0.5, oresdroprocks@1.3.0, overhaullib@2.0.10, p1nksshelvingtweaks@1.0.8, pantherinae@1.2.14, plumpkins@1.1.3, rhinocerotidae@1.0.23, scrolled@1.1.9, seasonalflowers@1.1.0, shelfobsessed@2.1.5, shelvabletools@1.1.1, silentpause@1.0.2, simplewatertweaks@0.11.0, sirenia@1.0.29, somedisassemblyrequired@1.10.2, spinningwheel@1.2.12, sticksarefirewood@1.0.0, stickworks@1.0.0, stoneagehomosapiens@1.1.0, stonequarryrepckfipil@3.6.3, tanninfromanylog@1.0.1, temporalsreformed@0.1.9, usebambooforcharcoal@0.1.1, usefultraders@2.5.2, valkyrjahair@3.0.0, viverridae@1.0.8, game@1.22.3, vsimgui@1.2.7, wetcrops@1.1.3, wforests@1.0.0, wgroundlayers@1.0.3, wilderlandscavessystem@2.0.6, wilderlandsgeology@1.0.2, abyssaldepths@1.0.18, accessibilitytweaks@5.0.0, algernonsterrainsampler@1.3.0, altmapiconrenderercontinued@1.6.0, ancientlib@1.0.0, ancienttoolsresinharvest@1.0.0, apelanterns@1.4.1, archering@1.0.7, attributerenderinglibrary@3.1.5, barkcanoe@1223.0.2, bearsshiftyearth@1.2.0, betterhandbook@1.0.7, betterruins@0.6.3, bettertraders@0.2.0, bitzartuitweaks@0.6.4, blocksoverlay@4.11.5, bloodtrail@1.2.4, blushlibrary@1.1.2, bradycrudebuilding@1.5.4, bugsisbait@2.0.0, butchering@1.13.5, carryon@1.14.2, chunklod@1.1.0, claywheel@2.0.1, closedcaptions@1.0.7, configlib@1.12.0, configureeverything@3.0.0, coriaendershaders@1.2.2-pre.3, critcherscalculator@1.2.3, critchersgrapplehook@1.1.0, dressedtokillredux@1.0.1, drythunderstorms@1.0.0, durablebetterprospecting@22.0.0-rc.1, evenjugincrements121@1.1.0, extrafurniture@1.1.2, extrainfo@2.2.1, fairfish@2.0.0, firepitsshowfuel@2.0.0-dev.1, fishingconfig@1.6.0, fixenfontmod@0.1.0, fixperishrate@1.0.1, foodpreferences@1.6.0, foragersgamble@1.3.0, genelib@3.1.1, herbarium@1.4.3, hidegear@1.3.1, hideplayernametag@1.0.0, japanesearchitecture@0.9.7, jaunt@3.0.0-rc.3, justsnow@1.0.2, knitting@2.0.3, ksrealisticfarming@1.0.7, localrespawn@2.0.1, locusthavest@1.0.5, mngeology@2.0.10, mobsradar@3.0.0, moreanimals@1.7.0, morepiles@3.0.1, mwi@1.9.0, naac@1.0.5, ndltreegrowth@2.4.0, nemi@1.1.0, nobackwardssprinting@1.0.1, nohandsrevived@0.2.0, notenoughinvertebrate@1.0.0, nzpatch@1.2.0, pandahearth@0.1.0, physicslib@1.3.0, pomnotes@0.8.0, prettylittlethings@2.4.4, projectileflee@1.0.4, putitinthebag@1.0.4, realcrops@1.1.1, realsmoke@1.3.1, realtimefirepit@1.1.0, rebuildablebloomery@1.0.6, reelmower@1.5.1, restfulsit@1.2.0, ricepaddies@1.0.3, roamingbees@2.0.0, rollupbed@1.0.4, ropetiable121@1.4.1, saltandsands@1.3.0, seraphtechlib@1.3.3, shadehouse@1.2.3, shipwright@1.4.0, simplestarvation@1.1.1, sirenia1027hidepeltcrashfix@1.0.3, slowtox@5.0.0, smithingplus@1.9.0-rc.1, snowcaps@0.0.1, soldierspybrassworks@1.3.6, splithidesandpelts@1.1.0, squeezeberries@1.0.1, stackscoolslower@1.1.1, stepupcontinued@0.0.2, stonebakeoven@1.3.5, stonerailings@1.4.0, strelgeooverhaul@1.0.3, strelnaturetweaks@1.0.4, stringsense@2.4.0, tanningredux@1.0.2, temperatureheighttweak@0.4.0, tentbagreworked122plus@1.0.1, tinkertailorbackpacks@1.1.5, tinkertailorclockworks@1.5.2, tinkertailorpatchworks@1.6.6, titanarum@1.0.1, toomanytabs@1.0.0, valrossensmapfilters@1.2.0, trojan96verticality@0.3.2, vigor@122.7.3, visiblebags@1.0.2, ikayblythebetterbiosphere@1.0.0, creative@1.22.3, vsecomachina@0.6.1, vsroofing@1.6.2, survival@1.22.3, warmweathereffects@1.2.1, wildcultivation@1.2.1, wilderlandstheweightbelow@1.0.3, wildgrasscontinued@1.3.11, windchimes@1.5.2, backtothehole@1.0.1, ancienttoolsmortar@1.0.0, autoconfiglib@2.0.10, bagconfig@0.1.4, blushandbins@1.3.3, bradycrudebuildingwwfix@1.0.0, equus@1.4.0, fzvanillacompat@1.0.2, improvedknives@1.2.0, obsidiancraft@1.6.1, shearlib@1.3.0, tinkertailorscrapworks@1.4.7, wildcraftfruit@1.4.72, wildcraftgrain@1.1.0, wildcrafttree@1.3.4, windowstoragelib@1.2.6, windowstorage@1.8.5, wool@1.9.3
Involved Harmony IDs: garward.betterhandbook.handbookcache, blushlibrary.code.core, extrainfo, attributerenderinglibrary, garward.betterhandbook.recipeexplorer, com.chronolegionnaire.foragersgamble, pomnotes, toomanytabs
System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object.
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.CollectibleBehaviorHandbookTextAndExtraInfo.GetHandbookInfo_Patch10(CollectibleBehaviorHandbookTextAndExtraInfo this, ItemSlot inSlot, ICoreClientAPI capi, ItemStack[] allStacks, ActionConsumable`1 openDetailPageFor)
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.GuiHandbookItemStackPage.GetPageText(ICoreClientAPI capi, ItemStack[] allStacks, ActionConsumable`1 openDetailPageFor) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Handbook\Gui\GuiHandbookItemStackPage.cs:line 119
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.GuiHandbookItemStackPage.ComposePage(GuiComposer detailViewGui, ElementBounds textBounds, ItemStack[] allstacks, ActionConsumable`1 openDetailPageFor) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Handbook\Gui\GuiHandbookItemStackPage.cs:line 113
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.ModSystemSurvivalHandbook.onComposePage(GuiHandbookPage page, GuiComposer detailViewGui, ElementBounds textBounds, ActionConsumable`1 openDetailPageFor) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Handbook\SurvivalHandbook.cs:line 135
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.GuiDialogHandbook.initDetailGui_Patch3(GuiDialogHandbook this)
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.GuiDialogHandbook.OpenDetailPageFor_Patch2(GuiDialogHandbook this, String pageCode)
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.CollectibleBehaviorHandbookTextAndExtraInfo.<>c__DisplayClass19_0.<addProcessesIntoInfo>b__19(ItemStack cs) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Handbook\CollectibleBehaviorHandbookTextAndExtraInfo.cs:line 889
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.ItemstackTextComponent.OnMouseDown(MouseEvent args) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Elements\Impl\Interactive\Text\Richtext\ItemstackTextComponent.cs:line 103
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiElementRichtext.OnMouseDownOnElement(ICoreClientAPI api, MouseEvent args) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Elements\Impl\Interactive\Text\GuiElementRichtext.cs:line 519
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiComposer.OnMouseDown(MouseEvent mouseArgs) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\GuiComposer.cs:line 470
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiDialog.OnMouseDown_Patch1(GuiDialog this, MouseEvent args)
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.GuiManager.OnMouseDown(MouseEvent args) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Systems\Gui\GuiManager.cs:line 401
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.UpdateMouseButtonState(EnumMouseButton button, Boolean down) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 2004
   at Vintagestory.Client.SystemHotkeys.OnPrimaryMouseButton(KeyCombination mb) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Systems\Player\Hotkeys.cs:line 52
   at Vintagestory.Client.HotkeyManager.TriggerHotKey(KeyEvent keyEventargs, IWorldAccessor world, IPlayer player, Boolean allowCharacterControls, Boolean keyUp) in VintagestoryLib\Client\HotkeyManager.cs:line 394
   at Vintagestory.Client.HotkeyManager.OnMouseButton(ClientMain game, EnumMouseButton button, Int32 modifiers, Boolean buttonDown) in VintagestoryLib\Client\HotkeyManager.cs:line 574
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.OnMouseDownRaw(MouseEvent args) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 1974
   at Vintagestory.Client.GuiScreenRunningGame.OnMouseDown(MouseEvent args) in VintagestoryLib\Client\MainMenu\Screens\GuiScreenRunningGame.cs:line 343
   at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.OnMouseDown(MouseEvent e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 936
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientPlatformWindows.Mouse_ButtonDown(MouseButtonEventArgs e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\Input.cs:line 207
   at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.NativeWindow.OnMouseDown(MouseButtonEventArgs e)
   at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.NativeWindow.MouseButtonCallback(Window* window, MouseButton button, InputAction action, KeyModifiers mods)
--- End of stack trace from previous location ---
   at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.NativeWindow.RethrowCallbackExceptionsIfNeeded()
   at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.GameWindow.Run()
   at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.Start(ClientProgramArgs args, String[] rawArgs) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 354
   at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.<>c__DisplayClass10_0.<.ctor>b__1() in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 131
   at Vintagestory.ClientNative.CrashReporter.Start(ThreadStart start) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\ClientNative\CrashReporter.cs:line 95

The artwork for this is fantastic. ❤️ Will be adding this to my list of quailty of life mods, love the diegetic way to recover resources.

There is a few balance related things I've noticed with the mod in the (almost) two hundred hours ive been using it;

> This mod makes it far too easy to obtain Iron; as anything thats smelted down from blocks turns into iron bars; completely negating the iron bloom step needed for ironworking.
   I would personally suggest having iron objects turn into iron bloom instead; at probably half the rate they are converting to at the moment.
   Iron oxidizes when melted down IRL, so you naturally lose a bit when chucking it all into a bloomery and melt it down.

> The recipie for Plank blocks -> boards from this mod overrites the vanilla one, and gives about half the planks back compared to the vanilla one.
   Basically, turning boards into plank blocks and back again with this mod enabled basically halves the boards. The vanilla recipie it overwrites is a 1:1 return, and more realistic (and useful) imo.

> And, as Juniper already pointed out earlier, the orientation thing in the crafting grid is a pain to figure out at times.
   I occationally find myself having to open the handbook to figure out exactly what tool need to go where for me to be able to break down items. Especially some clothing items.
   ( I have noticed you've been chipping away at those over the past months. o7 )

Other than those these minor issues; I've been loving how this mod functions. I genuinely appreciate the work you've been putting into the mod over the past year.

sorry to bother, but I just encountered a crashing bug when I'm trying to open Fruitpress page in handbook. By disabling one mod after another I stumbled to conclusion that your mod unfortunatelly causes this problem. Mayhaps it is compat issue but I couldn't track it as far.

Game Version: v1.22.3 (Stable)
23/06/2026 15:57:49: Critical error occurred
Loaded Mods: kilnshelves@1.1.7, ndlgraves@1.2.1, somedisassemblyrequired@1.10.1, game@1.22.3, footprints@1.2.4, morehudbars@1.2.0, ndlwoodentorchholder@3.0.2, toolsmith@1.2.17, creative@1.22.3, survival@1.22.3, bounties@1.0.7, cobvoices@1.0.1
System.Exception: Can't create itemstack without item!
   at Vintagestory.API.Common.ItemStack..ctor(Item item, Int32 stacksize) in VintagestoryApi\Common\Collectible\ItemStack.cs:line 227
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.BlockLiquidContainerBase.OnHandbookRecipeRender(ICoreClientAPI capi, IRecipeBase recipe, ItemSlot dummyslot, Double x, Double y, Double z, Double size) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Liquid\BlockLiquidContainerBase.cs:line 83
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.SlideshowGridRecipeTextComponent.RenderInteractiveElements(Single deltaTime, Double renderX, Double renderY, Double renderZ) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Elements\Impl\Interactive\Text\Richtext\SlideshowGridRecipeTextComponent.cs:line 236
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiElementRichtext.RenderInteractiveElements(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Elements\Impl\Interactive\Text\GuiElementRichtext.cs:line 476
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiComposer.Render(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\GuiComposer.cs:line 737
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiDialog.OnRenderGUI(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Dialog\GuiDialog.cs:line 396
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.GuiDialogHandbook.OnRenderGUI(Single deltaTime) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Handbook\Gui\GuiDialogHandbook.cs:line 562
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.GuiManager.OnRenderFrameGUI(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Systems\Gui\GuiManager.cs:line 309
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.DummyRenderer.OnRenderFrame(Single deltaTime, EnumRenderStage stage) in VintagestoryApi\Client\API\IClientEventAPI.cs:line 88
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientEventManager.TriggerRenderStage(EnumRenderStage stage, Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Util\ClientEventManager.cs:line 257
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.TriggerRenderStage(EnumRenderStage stage, Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 858
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.RenderToDefaultFramebuffer(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 1048
   at Vintagestory.Client.GuiScreenRunningGame.RenderToDefaultFramebuffer(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\MainMenu\Screens\GuiScreenRunningGame.cs:line 251
   at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.Render(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 783
   at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.OnNewFrame(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 686
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientPlatformWindows.window_RenderFrame(FrameEventArgs e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\GameWindow.cs:line 112
   at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.GameWindow.Run()
   at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.Start(ClientProgramArgs args, String[] rawArgs) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 354
   at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.<>c__DisplayClass10_0.<.ctor>b__1() in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 131
   at Vintagestory.ClientNative.CrashReporter.Start(ThreadStart start) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\ClientNative\CrashReporter.cs:line 95

Hey. Awesome mod, cleaned so much junk from my chests. But...it causes a crash when I try to open handbook recipe for Angled Gears:

Running on 64 bit Windows 10.0.19045.0 with 32609 MB RAM
Game Version: v1.22.3 (Stable)
22.06.2026 14:20:20: Critical error occurred
Loaded Mods: birdseye@0.1.4, chiseltools@1.17.2, landformoverhaul@1.0.4, craftablecartographyfork@0.1.11, immersivefoliage@0.1.1, rpcommand@2.0.1, somedisassemblyrequired@1.10.1, stonequarryrepckfipil@3.6.3, sustainableforestry@1.1.0, temporalsymphony@2.3.2, temporal_gears_stack@1.0.0, trashbinned@0.4.2, visibleore@1.0.1, game@1.22.3, vsimgui@1.2.7, wforests@1.0.0, zoombuttonreborn@2.0.2, accessibilitytweaks@5.0.0, apelanterns@1.4.1, autopanning@2.0.0, betterjonasdevicesfixedagain@2.1.6, betterruins@0.6.2, carryon@1.14.2, configlib@1.12.0, danatweaks@4.1.0, deathcorpses@2.8.1, extrainfo@2.2.1, extraoverlaysm4@1.7.5, farseer@1.4.0, fillmybloomery@1.0.3, foodshelves@3.0.4, helvehammerextcontinued@1.9.1, hideplayerinfo@1.3.1, improvedhandbookrecipesfork@1222.0.2, purposefulstorage@2.0.1, rivers@5.0.0, sheltered@1.0.1, shipwright@1.3.3, spawnhighlightreborn@1.2.0, creative@1.22.3, vsroofing@1.5.7, survival@1.22.3, realisticresincrafting@1.1.0, xinvtweaksfork@1.9.1
Involved Harmony IDs: improvedhandbookrecipes
System.Exception: Can't create itemstack without item!
   at Vintagestory.API.Common.ItemStack..ctor(Item item, Int32 stacksize) in VintagestoryApi\Common\Collectible\ItemStack.cs:line 227
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.BlockLiquidContainerBase.OnHandbookRecipeRender(ICoreClientAPI capi, IRecipeBase recipe, ItemSlot dummyslot, Double x, Double y, Double z, Double size) in VSSurvivalMod\Systems\Liquid\BlockLiquidContainerBase.cs:line 83
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.SlideshowGridRecipeTextComponent.RenderInteractiveElements_Patch6(SlideshowGridRecipeTextComponent this, Single deltaTime, Double renderX, Double renderY, Double renderZ)
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiElementRichtext.RenderInteractiveElements(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Elements\Impl\Interactive\Text\GuiElementRichtext.cs:line 476
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiComposer.Render(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\GuiComposer.cs:line 737
   at Vintagestory.API.Client.GuiDialog.OnRenderGUI(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryApi\Client\UI\Dialog\GuiDialog.cs:line 396
   at Vintagestory.GameContent.GuiDialogHandbook.OnRenderGUI_Patch3(GuiDialogHandbook this, Single deltaTime)
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.GuiManager.OnRenderFrameGUI(Single deltaTime) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Systems\Gui\GuiManager.cs:line 309
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.RenderToDefaultFramebuffer(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 1048
   at Vintagestory.Client.GuiScreenRunningGame.RenderToDefaultFramebuffer(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\MainMenu\Screens\GuiScreenRunningGame.cs:line 251
   at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.Render(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 783
   at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.OnNewFrame(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 686
   at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientPlatformWindows.window_RenderFrame(FrameEventArgs e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\GameWindow.cs:line 112
   at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.GameWindow.Run()
   at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.Start(ClientProgramArgs args, String[] rawArgs) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 354
   at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.<>c__DisplayClass10_0.<.ctor>b__1() in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 131
   at Vintagestory.ClientNative.CrashReporter.Start(ThreadStart start) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\ClientNative\CrashReporter.cs:line 95

[BUG]

1 Raw red clay bowl -> 1 Clay
2 Raw red clay bowl -> 1 Clay

seems like something went wrong in calculations

after updateing to a newer version of this mod my 1.21 game throws a creative inventory error when trying to load a save. i fixed it by going back a few mod versions. it wants to update though. Vintagestory.Common.InventoryPlayerCreative.GatherTabStacks(CollectibleObject[] collectibles) in VintagestoryLib\Common\GameContent\Inventory\InventoryPlayerCreative.cs:line 182

Hey, I was wondering if you could add in support for the Immersive Wood Sawing mod? (https://mods.vintagestory.at/immersivewoodsawing), for some reason when used together theres an api error that causes a hangup during worldgen and then stops the sawing mod from working entirely, I feel these two mods mesh well together and would love to be able to use them both. Thanks and hope your days going well.

yummy mod aslo while im here can i bring attention to the COOL ART? AUGH

Just here to let ya know i love the extra illustrations <3 

InternetDragon FloodLight Perseus127 Wytedragon TheSpecimenF87

Just here to let you all know that I'm still making progress with SDR and the next version will release within the next two weeks. I'd intended for it to be a larger update, but the sudden release of 1.22 has me on compatability duty. Once it plays nice with the new release I'll send it out.

Here's the current changelog if you're interested:

InternetDragon and Perseus127 still trying to deduce what the hell is causing that, hopefully it'll figure it out soon.

You're right FloodLight, the ashlar blocks to stones recipe is from SDR. I may look into rebalancing it if it becomes a problem.

Wytedragon and TheSpecimenF87, damn that is a problem. I'll check out those mods after the next update.

Doesn't work in 1.22

If you mine a full rock, process it into ashlar blocks and then use the ashlar blocks to stone recipe, you get 8 consistent stones instead of normal 2-3. Would probably be a fine abuse because of it's nicheness if the Stone Quarry mod wasn't so widely used, making the production of ashlar blocks very easy to scale. You could say that the base rock should give more than the measely 2 pebles, but ehh... (note: it's the recycle mod that introduces this recipe, right? Cause I don't remember vanilla or the stone quarry mod alone having it)

After updating to the stable release of 1.22, this mod was causing my game to crash whenever I opened the handbook. It worked fine in previous game versions, and I look forward to the update that patches this bug. Thanks for your hard work jun1per !

@TheSpecimenF87 I found that bug through a similar method. It uses the unchisel mod and better traders mod. In better traders, traders can spawn with carts made of chiseled metal blocks, and you can remove the land claim the traders have. This allows you to unchisel the metal bars to get whole blocks. This takes a thin metal bar into a whole block. You can then smelt them down into tons of iron. This means with a copper chisel you can get all the iron you want without mining it. I removed the unchisel mod because of this, though it is a nice mod when doing a lot of chiseling while building  

Hello I would like to report a GAMEBREAKING bug

It appears that with this mod ore blocks can be smelted down into TWELVE WHOLE INGOTS, in Vanilla this is fine, but with extremely popular mods such as Better Ruins and Vintage Engineering, using the Mechanist's Mechanism blueprint from VIntage Engineering allows you to turn two plates into a block, and in Vintage Engineering plates can be crafted in the smusher or whatever it's called at a rate of ONE INGOT PER PLATE. Even worse with the vintage engineering blast furnace you can reach over 2300 celsius allowing you to instantly smelt almost anything no bloomery required.

this allows you to turn 2 ingots into a block that smelts into twelve. Please I beg of you add detection for these mods and decrease the yield of ingots in turn

@jun1per! Thanks for the reply! I really love your mod. I appreciate being able to break things down that I dont need. This and the Scraps revived mod are awesome!

After looking into it further I thought that it wouldn't affect anything. I wanted to check though since I wasnt sure.

Wytedragon ShadowsEdge ChaoticNox GOLDshou botplayer123 Maoman

Apologies for not responding sooner, I've been very busy as of late and haven't had much time to work on SDR. At the moment I can't give any solid dates for the next update, either the end of March at the earliest or the end of April.

Right now I plan to add full compatatbility for the following mods:

A Culinary Artillery
Alchemy
CO - Armory
Adventurer's Walking Stick
Better Ruins
Butchery
Trashbinned
Toolsmith
QP Chisel Tools

Here's the current changelog so far if you're curious where the update is at:

Also Wytedragon, you're right about where those errors come from and I'm fairly certain they have no effect on your game or savefile. They'll be resolved as I add in recipes for the mods that generate them.

And botplayer123, I thought I allowed those tools to fit inside a Crucible but it seems I missed them, this is fixed in the next update.

Maoman Compost Bales need to be sealed in a Barrel with Water to rot faster, I've since clarified this in its description. Also I've fixed the problem with creating weird solo items when disassembling tools.

Thank you everyone for still supporting my mod even through its slow development. :D

Hi! So I recently updated some mods, including this one, and now I am getting errors while loading up worlds saying that various grid recipes that use scrap wood couldn't be resolved. These are all from various mods, such as A Culinary Artillery and Alchemy. I am not sure what exactly is happening or how to resolve these errors. It appears as though that these mods are seeing the scrap wood and are checking for recipes that include it. I was on at least version 1.7.7 before updating. I believe it was version 1.7.8. Does anyone have any suggestions for how to resolve these errors? I do not have any modding experience and have just recently started exploring the mod files while trying to figure this out.

Can you add A Culinary Artillery so items can be disassembled?

Will the Combat Overhaul compatibility include Armory as well? Also Maoman, in case you haven't already figured it out SDR = Some Disassembly Required (this mod).

How do you smelt down soldering iron, scissors and chisels? You can put only one item in the bloomery, no?

Compatible with the Adventurer's Walking Stick mod?

I cannot seal 8 compost bales in a barrel to accelerate the process.

Also, compatibility with Butchery would be lovely, if you don't mind.

Reclaiming a crude shield (and I assume anything else that gives you sticks back) returns you sticks that appear identical to normal sticks, but cannot share a stack with normal sticks for some reason, neither on the ground or in your inventory.
They still worked for stick-based crafting though so I was able to work them back into my supplies without having one stack of weird sticks by itself.

Also, what is "SDR" you mentioned in your recent comment?

NiclAss

I do intend to do both, I've just held off on compatability with other mods until SDR has reached a more completed state (creating recipes for most vanilla items, which should be the next update). I always intended for compatabilities to be from my end, but for now I appreceate you going out of your way to help out. :)

jun1per

I will add compatibility with this mod for betterruins regarding the Recipe Errors but if you want to change the output for certain duplication exploits with our blueprints I will leave that to you. Or what do you think.
If you want you can also do both?

Otherwise I will currently only add this

This can also be done from your side just let me know how you want to resolve this. You can also contact me on discord for faster messaging ty.

DeterminedBun

Those errors are from recipes attempting to find items that don't exist. TLDR: This has no effect on the game or your save since it's just a recipe failure. Since SDR adds a new wood and metal type, whenever a mod takes from those types to make items it also grabs the ones from SDR. That's why it's trying to find Scrap Wood and Carbonized versions of items.

This also shows up when i use Trashbinned Mod

jun1per Not sure what any of this means but it started popping up after installing this mod??

[img]https://i.imgur.com/DjlDk3u.png[/img]

https://imgur.com/DjlDk3u">View post on imgur.com

Jurisian

Oh, I hadn't realized you were talking about the shingle blocks and not the individual shingles. You need a chisel to break down the blocks into shingles, then a hammer to turn the shingles into ceramic shards.

jun1per Alright thank you for your reply, for some reason I still can't get it to work. Specifically I'm trying to smash the red clay shingle roof bottom and just the normal roof block too and it just doesn't work. I've tested also on a world that only has this mod enabled so I don't think it's a mod conflict.

jun1per

apparently it also clashes with the Better Ruins mod as well :x

DeterminedBun

I could add some basic compatabilities (fixing those recipes) for those two mods with the next update.

Jurisian

You probably didn't place the hammer above the tiles in the crafting grid, the recipe isn't shapeless so it only works that way.

BriarBlack

I didn't realize the stack size for Spear Heads was that low or that someone could have that much just lying around, but yeah I can add something to fix that. I'm thinking of adding a kind of crushed flint (not calcined) made from Flint Toolheads at a 1 to 1 ratio so you don't lose out on any materials. This crushed flint will have a larger stack size for better bulk smelting and turn into Calcined Flint Chunks same as every other flint item.

avereywk

Putting different items in the bloomery at the same time is a limitation in vanilla that I have no idea how to work around. And at the moment I'm not trying to change that as that's not what this mod is aiming to do.

Ylamona

I'd love to add configs to SDR since I know balancing and mod conflicts are big issues, but I've consistently had problems getting configs to work correctly in previous versions. If you have any thorough guides on how to set it up or people who can help please let me know.

Thranos

Figured that would come up. I'll probably add a patch that decreases the amount of materials you get back from any items you can discount with blueprints while the mod is enabled. 

Don't suppose we could get compatibility with Toolsmith and QP Chisel Tools? Apparently there's some recipes that clash between this and those two mods.

Hello! Sorry if this has been asked before but how do you recycle clay roof tiles? The description says something about smashing but a hammer doesn't work? Am I missing something obvious?

Would it be possible to add a recipe that allows Flint Arrowheads and Flint Spear Heads to be turned into literally anything without cooking them? I'm using the Mechanical Auto Panner Mod and surprise surprise, Flint Arrow Heads and Flint Spear Heads show up by the absolute truckload and having to cook every single one of those (stacking up to 4) Flint Spear Heads is beyond tedious, I've gone out of my way to create several rooms full of firepits in rows of 6 so I can optimize getting rid of the raw flint and the Spear Heads.

The obvious solution for me is to allow all flint items to be smashed by a hammer into calcinated flint chunks but that seems a little unbalanced so maybe allowing -Flint Spear Head (x4)+Hammer = Raw Flint-?

the mods super useful but i was wondering is it possible to put multiple worn tool types in the bloomery at a time?

Loving the mod so far, so thanks for that!

However I'm having trouble disassebmling vanilla arrow.

I'm reading in the changelog that I should be able to burn the arrows into arrowheads, but I can't figure out how. I've tried all the ways I can think of...

Edit: I think I figured it out. I think there is some conflict with the "Bullseye" mod as I can burn the arrows fine in firepit without that mod enabled.

It'd be nice if you could configure enabling/disabling various sections of this mod for better compatibility; Like disabling tool recycling recipes & worn tool head items in favor of another mod's tool dissasembly system (like SmithingPlus or Toolsmith)

Just as an FYI: I've run into some pretty serious infinite gain loops if also running Better Ruins, due to their Blueprint sytem creating "discounts" for some recipes:

-Roofing BP: Three clay tiles = 8 sloped roofing blocks with the BP, each can be disassembled into 1 tile with SDR, 250% return Six planks = 4 sloped wood roof, each can disassemble into three planks, 200% return Three bamboo = 8 bamboo sloped, each can disassemble into one bamboo, 250% return (thatch and copper are fine, as is sod)

-Machinist's Mechanism BP: Two metal plates = one riveted metal block, each can disassemble into three metal plates, 150% return

I've alerted the Better Ruins devs, but I thought it would be a good idea to alert the other side of this as well.

god damn they are hot

jasongbs

For the time being, Clutter blocks won't be given recipes to be recycled. Since Scraps already exists I'm not prioritizing recipes for any of them. Although that may change when the mod nears a more completed state.

Ylamona

Interesting, I guess it makes sense it would crash since the recipe is shapeless so it has no idea which knife to consume if they're both the same. I'll change the recipe so it shouldn't happen again.

FourthSecret

I've been doing some testing with the help of other modders to figure out this issue. We don't a have solution yet but we know what blocks are affected: Any Wood Slabs (Scrap Wood included) that are placed in the "up" postion. The issue is also isolated to the world's they occur in, so any newly create worlds should be fine. I hope to report back later with an actual solution soon. We're still trying to figure this thing out. 

P.S. the crate being uncraftable was an oversight on my part, this next update has the recipe.

Howdy, liking the mod so far but i got a question, on the planned features you said (NO CLUTTER) but you mean it as in:

"Items that can be considered clutter won't be reciclable (like a ruined bucket)"

Or:

"Everything will be reciclable to the point no clutter will be left"

Sorry if it's kinda of a dumb question, English ain't my first language 

I tried splitting the head from a copper knife with another copper knife, and the game crashed. Almost not sure why I'm surprised lol
Anyway, I'd recommend making knives directly smeltable like cleavers. This would fix the problem well.

Hello, I found a couple issues with the latest update. The Scrap Crate doesn't seem to have a recipe to actually craft it, it's in the handbook but my players and I can't create them. Second, this one might be because I'm hosting a multiplayer server and updated this mod for it, there's an issue that cropped up that's very inconsistent. Wood slabs (the half-slabs) seem to become error blocks whenever they get snow on them. This doesn't happen all the time, some are fine and others have the error.

DeeTales

This shouldn't be a problem at all. One of my patches to add a unique variant of the Glass Panes simply failed to run so all that's missing is that one item. I'll add a patch soon to get that error off your startup log though!

DecaByte

I just did some testing on this, frankly, bizzare bug between SDR and SmithPlus and am sad to report that for the time being I have no idea what causes this. I have contacted the developer of SmithingPlus and am hoping to get some insight from their end. If you do still have some of those bugged tool heads there is a fix. I'm assuming you added in SDR after SmithPlus so if you disable SDR any previously bugged tool heads should revert to their original state. After you're done you may reenable SDR if you'd like. I hope to come back with a more concrete solution later.

Seeing this in the server startup log. Not sure if it's an actual problem, but it's showing as an error and not a warning. 

jun1per

Looks like there some issues with the Smithing Plus mod. All my broken iron toolheads changed their discription metal to other metals (after adding this mod) but still acted as Iron as I was able to repair it with Iron bits & the return repaired item was the new bugged name metal, not the Iron item it was originally. Also errors about reciepes. Can't remember what they all about, but was a few after adding this mod. Other then that, looks like a mod I would want to use. Hopefully you can sort out the issues with Smithing Plus. Maybe a config to switch off your toolheads to allow Smithing Plus to do it's thing.
Thank You for your very needed mod!

Brady_The

I appreaciate you adding that compatiblity on my behalf, it wasn't necessary but much welcomed! 

Also interesting that there'd be a crash relating to Vinegar, but in hindsight it makes sense as to why. I've since made a new, seperate liquid to take its place and it works fine on my end. 

As for Material Needs, I threw together a quick and dirty patch to prevent those recipe errors from showing up. Both of these will come with the next version of the mod.

You can scratch carolines request. I added compatibility on my end. 👍

While doing so I discovered that clicking on Vinegar in the handbook crashes the game, because your vinegar recipes all share the same name/code. Solution: Make the code unique.

In combination with Material Needs the sdr-door deconstruct recipe prints some error messages, due to how MN implements some wood types. It's nothing major but I personally dislike any kind of warning or error message in my mod. The simplest solution would be to add "darkaged" to "skipVariants".

Thank you :D You're the best!

GreenDragonette

Sure! I figured I'd missed some blocks and items so I'll add those in the next version.

littlejaguar183

No that's not a bug, the Worn Tool Heads aren't meant to be repaired just melted or broken down into nuggets. I believe Smithing Plus does have that functionality if that's what your looking for.

caroline

Yeah I'll definely put down Vrady's for future compatatbility, although it may be a while as I want to finish covering the vanilla blocks and items first.

I found iron door with bars in the prison ruins, and I'm pretty sure it's not recyclable, at least its handbook and my imagination are mum on this; melting a chute in a bloomery worked, so I tried it, but no dice :( Do you think it would be possible to add the iron doors (and maybe iron fence, too?) to bloomable items?

could you add compatability with Vrady's Crude Building Elements? 

bug?

when i try to fix my worn tool heads i het them up and try to put it on the anvil and i cant do it.

I tryed reloging and multible different heads  I was using copper anvil to fix copper tools 

Why is the example character, so CUTE?! :v

Ah hell I find this 5 days after making a mod to uncobble my cobblestone

Feature suggestion: Reverting formed raw clay items back to clay. In case you, say, make a stack's worth of red clay tiles when you wanted blue clay tiles... Asking for a friend. (No, I didn't just do that, why would you think that?)

(I'm just going to twaddle around a little with to make a recipe for it myself, but it seems like a suitable addition here.)

@Michael00181 It is from disassembling jewelry like the Nadiyan Bronze Lapis Bracelet

So whats the deal with the cut gems that traders want to buy? it says they're from this mod.

Thanks for looking into that, I'll have to do some more testing to pin this down.

Thranos

Just did some testing on my end and I don't think SDR the culprit. However I was able to place the Broken Tool Heads in bloomeries so there may be something up on my end. All my mod does involving bloomeries is change the "smelting temperature range" that an item needs to be in to be placed into a bloomery. (So items with super low or high melting temp like lead or titanium can be placed inside) As for the amount of metal returned when melting it down I think that's vanilla.

If you or anyone on your server is familair with modding you should be able to make a patch that lowers the amount of metal returned when smelting Broken Tool Heads. (For reference Smithing Plus uses metal Work Items for their Broken Tool Heads, so change the value for that item)

Trying to track down an odd issue players on my server have run into- appears to possibly but not for sure be from here.
Broken tool heads from Smithing Plus (which aren't on their own able to be put into bloomeries) seem to be bloomable when that mod is run along with this one.
This is a bit of a problem because the intent of broken tool heads is partial recovery of metal, and this sidesteps the entire process.

this is completely unrelated to everything but i like the character you use in images

this is a good fresh of breath air from all the ai mods, thanks!

Love the art and the idea

DracaBro

Only smaller metal items can go in the crucible, (nails, arrowheads, toolheads) larger items need to be melted down in a bloomery.

Question on how to melt down metal blocks, how does one melt them down?

i tried throwing blocks into a crucible to melt them down, but it never worked.

Hinochi

There shouldn't be any outstanding issues with either mod, however, there may be some unintended interactions between SDR and Toolsmith. Nothing gamebreaking just imbalanced.

Does this play well with mods like Toolsmith and Wear & Tear?

Oh wonderful. This mod is easily a complete necessity for me. It was working fine for the most part but I'm terribly glad to see it's still being maintained. Thank you dearly. 

yay!

An update to get SDR to 1.21 is in the works. For now it's just going to be compatable with an update containing actual content coming out hopefully within the next week. Thanks everyone for still sticking around through my absence! :)

Trying to look at pottery shards (or at least the dark brown ones) currently seems to cause a CTD on 1.21.x
 

SevenIndex Hello again! Just wanted to check if this mod is working with 1.21 and such, and if not, any idea when it may be updated? Love this mod and its utility.

Drawing your own pictures for mod description - beyond based

Thank you! I love this mod. Now I can recycle all my junk.

Unfortunately, it seems like a few things are broken in 1.21. Ingots going in the crucible being one of them

I love this mod, it is one of my favorite mods. Are there any plans to update it for 1.21?

Hey two things, wonderful images and wonderful mod in general. Thanks for making it and making the images fun as well.

Great mod, also agree, great thumbnails!  The one recipe I wish it had was some way of melting down bronze armlets. I found so many of these during panning and they have no use in the game.

i really love how you actually drew stuff for the thumbnails instead of the ai-generated slop that a lot of mods use, very nice :3

Hi!. I can't figure out how to disassemble iron doors.

 Lyca_Entropy you can do that with a chisel in the crafting grid already

in vanilla

Could it be possible to make it so ingots can be broken back into nuggets, even if some of it gets "lost"?

This is since I'm having such a hard time in 1 world finding copper to make bronze alloys (and most of the copper I prev mined was turned into ingots before I stopped finding copper) being able to turn them into nuggets will allow to smelt a couple ingots more.

can you disasemmble clay roof tiles?

Thank you, made a bunch of windows from the wrong wood by accident and was disheartened so much effort was basically wasted, but now I got some materials back! For future reference, is there any other way to disassemble them than burning in a firepit? I tried saw, hammer and axe in a crafting grid and nothing came up, but in handbook supposedly you can get boards from them too? If there's a choice between lead and boards I'd choose lead every time, I'm just curious (and very grateful!).

I was worried when a bunch of errors reared during logging in my world, but I scrolled through older asks and fingers crossed all is well so far. Your mod got grumpy about axe recipe (I have a bunch of mods, including Toolsmith, Thrifty Smithing and Smithing Plus) and some blocks(?) from Better Ruins. But works as advertised and doesn't look like it's gonna crash or corrupt the file :)

Have a great day!

For some reason I cannot for the life of me figure out the fire clay + grog + grog + water thing. I've tried every possible permutation of item quantities in a pot atop a fire and none of them are working.

edit: nevermind I'm sleep deprived and getting my multiplication wrong lol

Oh also real quick since I noticed it while playing. I've noticed that Vanilla variants versions of several items can't be broken down. I assume it's potentially because each one would need a recipe made for them? If so, that's understandable :P

SevenIndex

Awesome! thank you for letting me know it works. As for the exploit, Yeeeaaaah that's fair. I also use Smithing Plus alongside Toolsmith so my tools last a good long while. Thank you for again for getting back to me! Those axes and spare hammer head are getting melted down >:)

Wingfriend

I've played with both mods before, they work fine with each other, no errors or broken recipes. But for the time being they're super exploitable together. 

I'll probably make a patch to balance this in the future but for now enjoy the free tools. :)

Real quick, wanted to check. I've been using the mod Toolsmith a bunch since it makes my tools feel so much more interactive and fun. Wanted to ask and see if anyone has tried this with the Toolsmith mod. If it works, three random copper axes I found from pots are getting melted :P

Enigmayster

Thanks for following up on that other guy's error, I'll add in a patch for Rustbound Magic in the next update. Also, your method is just as good as the one I usually use for that kinda thing.

Denton_

I'm planning to do a revamp of how SDR approaches recycling metal items to find a good middle ground between nuggets and smelting, which would include Worn Tool Heads. (and almost every other metal doodad) 

(P.S. Worn Tool Heads, along with many other small metal items, can be smelted in a Crucible.)

(P.S.S. The limitation of the Bloomery only accepting the same item is a feature of Vanilla, and I don't know how to change it.)

Could worn tool heads be broken into nuggets, which would make it much easier to melt inside a bloomery. As of right now, you can't mix a knife head with a hammer head, even though they're made from the same material.

summonedobject errors are tied to rustbound magic mod.

I've fixed them for my game by adding skipvariant for pickaxe:

"skipVariants": [ "summonedobject-pickaxe1-unstable", "summonedobject-pickaxe2-unstable" ],

and for saw:

"skipVariants": [ "summonedobject-saw1-unstable", "summonedobject-saw2-unstable" ],

in the assets\somedisassemblyrequired\recipes\grid\deconstruct\tool\sdr-tool-recycle-metal.json file

dunno if that's the correct way of solving incompatibilities but it works so...

Bomberanian

Of course! I'll totally add that compatibility in the next update.

Would you consider making the carbonized metal arrows compatible with combat overhaul? Don't know how hard that is. But as it stands you can't fire the arrows at all.

Vaili

I had no problems testing the two mods together so there may be a problem with the addition of another mod on top of those two. If you can please put in your modlist and whatever errors are generated in the server log or crash log. Also please use the "Add spoiler" feature incase either is especially long.

Does the game break down when using the "Re-Smeltables Light" mod along with your mod?

Scorives

These errors come from one of my recipes being unable to find the Worn Tool Head variants for these modded tools. This shouldn't have any effect on your game or corrupt anything. 

Also I appreciate putting your log in but I have no idea what mod these tools come from. Would you mind pasting your modlist too so I can make a patch in the future?

22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-pickaxe-summonedobject-pickaxe1-unstable in Grid recipe
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Error] Grid Recipe 'somedisassemblyrequired:recipes/grid/deconstruct/tool/sdr-tool-recycle-metal.json': Output Item code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-pickaxe-summonedobject-pickaxe1-unstable cannot be resolved
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-pickaxe-summonedobject-pickaxe2-unstable in Grid recipe
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Error] Grid Recipe 'somedisassemblyrequired:recipes/grid/deconstruct/tool/sdr-tool-recycle-metal.json': Output Item code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-pickaxe-summonedobject-pickaxe2-unstable cannot be resolved
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-saw-summonedobject-saw1-unstable in Grid recipe
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Error] Grid Recipe 'somedisassemblyrequired:recipes/grid/deconstruct/tool/sdr-tool-recycle-metal.json': Output Item code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-saw-summonedobject-saw1-unstable cannot be resolved
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-saw-summonedobject-saw2-unstable in Grid recipe
22.6.2025 03:33:32 [Error] Grid Recipe 'somedisassemblyrequired:recipes/grid/deconstruct/tool/sdr-tool-recycle-metal.json': Output Item code somedisassemblyrequired:oldtoolhead-saw-summonedobject-saw2-unstable cannot be resolved

Sorry folks, but I can't get configs to work for SDR.

I was able to confirm that the individual settings function properly using another mod's domain that utilizes Configlib as a base for testing. But for some reason using SDR's domain in configlib-patches.json breaks the config entirely, locking each setting to their default and producing the error below in the log.

(Some other things of note: The config file in the ModConfig folder generates with only the file pathway to itself. SDR is a Code mod.)

If any of you are familair with Configlib and/or this error please tell me what I'm doing wrong.

Just wanna say the art on this is fabulous. Absolutely drew me in, and saving the planet(and my inventory sanity) is cool.

config lib can indeed be used to add a config file without c#. There's a decent amount of documentation starting here
https://github.com/maltiez2/vsmod_configlib/wiki

there's config lib here but unsure if it requires c# or not

FOR ANYONE WANTING A CONFIG FOR SDR / OR UNHAPPY WITH THE REMOVAL OF METAL BIT RECIPES, PLEASE READ

I, currently, do not know how to add a config file for SDR. So as a temporary change until I can figure it out, I've re-enabled all disabled recipes involving using a Chisel to reclaim Metal Bits or Ingots from items in version 1.6.7. As for some of the other toggleable features and recipes you all have suggested they will remain unchanged til I can get a config up and running. 

If any of you wanna help and point me in the direction of config file coding, please do!

BriarBlack

Yeah like I said to NolandVoyd earlier I plan on adding config settings for some of the more devisive changes next. Also I don't understand the example you were giving. Maybe I didn't make it clear enough in the changelog and guide but Ingots, Regular Tool Heads and Worn Tool Heads (plus other small metal items like Lamealle and Scales) can be used in the Crucible. I wanted the Bloomery to be reserved for larger items and so you wouldn't need a mountain of fire clay bricks to melt a bunch of copper spear heads.

Can we plz get some config toggles for balancing decisions like whether blocks can go into crucibles and whether ingots can be converted back into nuggets? I'm not trying to be a jerk about it but some of these balancing decisions feel kind of silly. Why should I first forge the ingot into a tool head, stick that tool head on a stick, and only THEN can I smelt that down into liquid bismuth bronze? That feels super weird to me.

SevenIndex

Yeah, the other thing I noticed is that the recipe for decrafting a tool makes things like chopping firewood quite precarious. One extra click and you decraft your tool. Requiring an extra ingredient would probably help with that.

Looks like the crash was some interaction with SmithingPlus. Hmm... Probably not worth worring about since its a specific interaction between mods
 
5/24/2025 10:43:58 PM: Critical error occurred in the following mod: smithingplus@1.6.0-rc.2
Loaded Mods: aculinaryartillery@1.2.5, jonasworkshop@1.1.1, millwright@1.2.0, overhaullib@0.2.8, primitivesurvival@3.7.7, prospecttogether@2.0.3, somedisassemblyrequired@1.6.6, terraprety@6.0.2, game@1.20.10, vsimgui@1.1.8, animalcages@3.2.2, egocaribautomapmarkers@4.0.2, betterfirepit@1.1.5, betterruins@0.4.12, blacksmithenhancements@1.1.4, butchering@1.8.2, carryon@1.8.0, combatoverhaul@0.3.9, commonlib@2.6.1, configlib@1.5.3, expandedfoods@1.7.4, foodshelves@2.1.2, freedomunits@1.1.4, fromgoldencombs@1.8.12, maltiezcrossbows@1.2.0, maltiezfirearms@0.14.2, playerlist@2.1.5, rackableplates@1.0.0, rustboundmagic@2.5.4, smithingplus@1.6.0-rc.2, statushudcont@3.2.6, stonebakeoven@1.1.6, toolsmith@1.1.9, creative@1.20.10, vsinstrumentsbase@2.0.3, survival@1.20.10, armory@0.2.4, playercorpse@1.11.1, xinvtweaks@1.8.0
Involved Harmony IDs: smithingplus, XInvTweakPatch
System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object.
at SmithingPlus.CastingTweaks.CollectibleBehaviorCastToolHead.TryPlaceOn(ItemStack stack, BlockEntityAnvil beAnvil) in /Users/jacopouggeri/workspace/VintageModding/SmithingPlus/SmithingPlus/CastingTweaks/CollectibleBehaviorCastToolHead.cs:line 45
at Vintagestory.GameContent.BlockEntityAnvil.TryPut_Patch0(BlockEntityAnvil this, IWorldAccessor world, IPlayer byPlayer, BlockSelection blockSel)
at Vintagestory.GameContent.BlockEntityAnvil.OnPlayerInteract_Patch1(BlockEntityAnvil this, IWorldAccessor world, IPlayer byPlayer, BlockSelection blockSel)
at Vintagestory.GameContent.BlockAnvil.OnBlockInteractStart(IWorldAccessor world, IPlayer byPlayer, BlockSelection blockSel) in VSSurvivalMod\Block\BlockAnvil.cs:line 169
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.SystemMouseInWorldInteractions.TryBeginUseBlock(Block selectedBlock, BlockSelection blockSelection) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Systems\Player\MouseInWorldInteractions.cs:line 875
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.SystemMouseInWorldInteractions.HandleMouseInteractionsBlockSelected_Patch1(SystemMouseInWorldInteractions this, Single dt)
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.SystemMouseInWorldInteractions.OnFinalizeFrame(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Systems\Player\MouseInWorldInteractions.cs:line 85
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientEventManager.TriggerRenderStage(EnumRenderStage stage, Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\Util\ClientEventManager.cs:line 188
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientMain.RenderToDefaultFramebuffer(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientMain.cs:line 992
at Vintagestory.Client.GuiScreenRunningGame.RenderToDefaultFramebuffer(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\MainMenu\Screens\GuiScreenRunningGame.cs:line 242
at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.Render(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 695
at Vintagestory.Client.ScreenManager.OnNewFrame(Single dt) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ScreenManager.cs:line 670
at Vintagestory.Client.NoObf.ClientPlatformWindows.window_RenderFrame(FrameEventArgs e) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\GameWindow.cs:line 88
at OpenTK.Windowing.Desktop.GameWindow.Run()
at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.Start(ClientProgramArgs args, String[] rawArgs) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 334
at Vintagestory.Client.ClientProgram.<>c__DisplayClass10_0.<.ctor>b__1() in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientProgram.cs:line 130
at Vintagestory.ClientNative.CrashReporter.Start(ThreadStart start) in VintagestoryLib\Client\ClientPlatform\ClientNative\CrashReporter.cs:line 93

NolandVoyd

I 100% agree that the amount of anvils and other large metal blocks you can fit in a bloomery at once is rediculous. It was something I wanted to change, but since those values are determined within a C# file and not a Json one it's a little outside of my limited expertiese. I'll see what I can do though.

As for tool decrafting I'll definetly see if I can't add a config for that as well as some other minor changes people may want to turn off. It may take a while though as I've never implemented configuarable features of my mod.

Also I can't seem to recreate that crash involving Worn Tool Heads and Anvils. I assume it's some weird interaction with another mod, do mind posting the crash log and your mod list?

Also, clicking an anvil with a worn tool head crashes the game.
Can we get a config option to disable decrafting tools? It is redundant and somewhat conflicts with mods like Toolsmith.

Seems a little odd that you can smelt 6 anvils at once in the bloomery, and that they only cost 1 charcoal to smelt. Might want to bump the costs up and limit it to 1 anvil.

EbKeth

Disabling the recipes that turn various metal objects into metal bits using a chisel was an intentional choice. It's in the 1.5.5 changelog. Personally I just think those recipes make no sense whatsoever, so I got rid of them in favor of resmelting the items into ingots or bits. 

I can understand why this would be considered a bug and if you'd prefer for this change not to be a thing, I may release a seperate patch with the next update that lets you re-enable those recipes.

SevenIndex

Updating from version 1.4.5 to 1.5.5, we are now unable to turn ingots into metal bits via a chisel.

KumaKoruna

I have, but never got around to posting anything there. Honestly I just haven't been making anything to post to my socials due to both developing this mod and some big life changes coming up. I'll probably branch out to Bluesky at some point, but for now my stuff is exclusive to Tumblr.

@SevenIndex that is why i exactly mentioned it. i found your tumblr and meant IF i had an account there, i would followed you already. ever considered bluesky or the sorts?

BriarBlack

Thanks, I'm aware that alot of metal blocks and items that say they can be smelted cannot be put in bloomery. By default items must have a smelting temperature between 1000 and 1500 degrees to be used in a bloomery. Since steel melts at 1502 it's incompatable. I'm trying to change that range with the next update but since it involves C# code it's a bit out of my expertiese. For now I've allowed those excempt items to be placed in a crucible to be melted.

Hey Hey, Just popping in to let you know of a potential oversight, Steel blocks are meant to be able to smelted back down to ingots, however they cannot be inserted into a bloomery. Just a heads up!

Surprised I got a response, but I wondered if tuning cylinders are scrappable or planned to be?
They could become metal parts or metal scrap in a pulverizer maybe?
Or shove em in a fire for a slag that lets you make cupronickel from it, since that's what all the tech is?
Idk, I'm sure you can think of something better or funnier.

Mobius jamescook KumaKoruna

Thank you for the kinda words about my funny arangement of lines and colors, I definitly didn't go into this thinking those would get as much attention as the mod itself. Also, KumaKoruna, it's funny you mention that...

CyanSoup

Good. >:)

Your art rules, I love staring at it. Great work and great idea for a mod too

i like the art you got there

since youre gonna read and will listen to what i have to say. hi, i like your art. please do more of that. its perfect for those Vintage Story shenanigans. would love to follow you if i had a tumblr account.

The shaft into a single firewood is hilarious.
As my group's engineer the insane waste does actual damage to me.

SevenIndex Thank you!

Ive also stumbled over this mod, it references yours in the description, and they do make a good point.

https://mods.vintagestory.at/grog

Javidac

I added a quick update to version 1.5.5 adding a patch for the Short Shelves. Since both recipes had the exact same layout one overrided the other, why it was mine I don't know.

oh how I love deco items that have a recycle route, oh how I hate it if they have non~

I think you ought to be able to take your clothes and cut them into cloth squares with a knife or shears (how many bundles of cloth squares you get depends on what the garment is and how tattered it is). And then so many bundles of squares, plus some linen thread and some feathers, makes you a (patchwork) quilted down jacket to keep you nice and toasty in the winter.

If a patchwork coat was good enough for Dolly Parton . . .

Foodshelves had a massive update, and with some dissassembly required enabled its not possible to make the new short shelves in that mod. This mod somehow takes priority when crafting them.

Rekeme

Thanks for letting me know. Apparently I replaced all the individual damage values with the Carbonized Metal Arrow's damage. (steel arrows deal the same damage as copper arrows lol) I'll ship the fix with the next update.

Hey there, bug report for you!

Using this mod causes the arrows to lose their damage coefficient in 1.4.5 1.20.9. Install the mod, launch a new world, and check the arrows in the handbook. They no longer have damage.

I noticed this after updating from mod version 1.1.0 on 1.20.4. Please let me know if I can provide additional information.

Ivanblade

Makes sense that VV and SDR would have some problems. I'll make a soft compatatbility patch with the next update so there's no issues regarding recipes, a full patch with recipe and item integration will come later since VV is freaking massive.

VesPuppy

Any item that has "Smelts into" under their Smelting Temperature can be melted in the Bloomery. Mostly it's any block or item made entirely out of metal. (Copper Roofs, Riveted Metal Blocks, etc) Items like the Scrollrack, that use Nails & Strips in their recipe, can be burned in a firepit to reclaim all the metal at the cost of destroying all the wood. (Look for "Cooks into" on items) I'll definely make the guide more intuatuive come the next update. As for the Aged Wood Fences their recipes seem to work fine, but if you're refering to how they can only be broken into sticks and not planks I do have an answer for that: I try to keep the recipes balanced around a 50% return rate on resources as well as avoiding getting more resources than was used, ideally maintaining both with only a single item required. Fences craft in batches of 8 so you get alot of items for very little resources. Since only 4 planks are used they can't be split evenly between the 8 possible items, so instead I had it yeild extra sticks as compensation.

oh yeah, also somewhat off-topic, but the mod inspired me a lil bit, and i got a saw (for wood) irl and thought i'd make attempts at recycling some old furniture i see people throw out

hewwo, it's me again - I noticed that the aged wood fences can't be broken down with the usual methods. I also wanted to ask - the added guide mentions smelting things down with the use of bloomery - which items exactly does this refer to? Is it stuff like lanterns and scroll racks, or tool heads?

Hi! I found a mod conflict with Vanilla Variants while playing i was trying to build a chest and it is building the default chest not the modded one instead. I'm not positive if the conflict it's Vanilla Variants, it's Recipe Patcher or both, but
I have been able to recreate the conflict while only using SDR and the other two mods together, hope I explained it well!

Yeah okay thats understandable. I wozld have preferred to have it all from one mod but yeah there are already some mods of that kind.

HaraiseTenshi

Melting down or breaking apart tools hasn't been high of a priority since other mods like Break Down Tools, Salvage+ and Re-Smeltables Light already exist. I may add it in at some point in the future, but there's still other features I'd like to add before stepping into tools.

Any chance on adding recycling of metal tools like melting/chiseling metal tools into bits?

I know you can just "use them up" but it kinda feels like a waste to have to use up a perfectly 'useless' copper chisel instead of zust melting it or forging it into a rod or something to give it another life in a fruitpress for example when transitioning to bronze anyway and such ^^

gg

virtualpolecat lazula Calisto Brady_The

I fixed that bug with the fruitpress recipe in 1.4.5. It had something to do with that I implemented the scrap plank as an additional variant of the existing planks instead of a seperate item tied to SDR. (I'm honestly not entirely sure what exactly was broken) I re-implemented the plank as its own thing so there also shouldn't be anymore errors from recipes from other mods that use "plank-*" in their recipes. 

I've confirmed that v1.3.1 is the version that breaks the fruitpress recipe, but I'm not familiar with modding so I can't pinpoint exactly what causes it. Hope it helps regardless.

Calisto 

Thanks for posting your log, by the look of it, some items from Culinary Artillery and the other mods that can use any plank type in their recipe are trying to use the "scrap plank" from my mod. Since it's only recipes that are having problems it shouldn't have any effect on gameplay, just that giant wall of text on start up. I'll try to add in a compatibility patch for some of these mods in the next update, but with so many it may take a while. Also, you can use the "Add spoiler" function for posting any error logs or the like.

virtualpolecat

That's weird. I'll take a look at it and ship a bug fix when it's resolved.

This mod breaks the fruit press crafting recipe, just thought i would bring that to your attention! keep up the great work!

Hi, I just downloaded the recent update. I'm getting a long error log when I load this with some of my other mods. Here is a bit of the error log. I'd post the whole thing but it's very long:

21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackacacia': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-acacia-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-baldcypress-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackbaldcypress': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-baldcypress-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-birch-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackbirch': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-birch-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-ebony-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackebony': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-ebony-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-kapok-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackkapok': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-kapok-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-larch-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottleracklarch': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-larch-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-maple-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackmaple': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-maple-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-oak-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackoak': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-oak-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-pine-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackpine': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-pine-north cannot be resolved
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Warning] Failed resolving crafting recipe ingredient with code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-purpleheart-north in Grid recipe
21.4.2025 22:45:50 [Error] Grid Recipe 'aculinaryartillery:bottlerackpurpleheart': Output Block code aculinaryartillery:bottlerack-scrapped-purpleheart-north cannot be resolved

It goes on similarly for recipes from Decorations Bazaar, Alchemy, Crude Building Materials, Butterfly Cases, Kevin's Furniture and More Floors. I tried loaded those mods without this mod and no error. I will post the whole log if you want. 

Planet Folgora in Vintage...mmm

i love the drawings!! they're such a cool way to showcase a mod

Brady_The

That makes sense. And I know I'll have to do a lot of patching in the future, but without any logs or response from Trungad I can't do anything for him.

The errors mentioned by Trungad happens due to the way your mod adds certain states into the game.

Take planks for example. You add "scrapped" into the mix. Now the game will try for every mod with recipes using "plank-*" in their ingredients (without any restrictions via "allowedVariants/skipVariants") to create a -scrapped-variation, which most likely doesn't exist and thus leads to error messages galore.

Tried it out with scraps mod https://mods.vintagestory.at/scraps that already have your planned additions. Seems like they work tohether fine in first flight. Will be with you on your journey in your versions.

VesPuppy

Yes I do plan to add those into the mod, though they may take a while since crates use a "type" system instead of "variant". Because of that I can't use the wildcard (*) character within recipes so their json will be a little long. Even so, I'll totally add those. They'll come with the next update. :)

Woof, are there plans for including the wooden crates and hunter backpacks in the mod? Especially removing parchment from crates?

Greatly appreciating this mod of course, but I also wanna say, the art of your character is soooo cute. Love the style.

Trungad

Could you share your server-debug and server-main logs? There's probably some conflict with another mod going on.

Oh god SO MANY ERRORS! 

oh now i understand why i can't craft wooden fences, ty for fixing it

okays, thank you for the fast answer ^w^

VesPuppy

At the moment I don't have a Github, but I may look into it in the future. I've never made one before so it might take a while to figure out. 

For now I'm not focusing on clutter block since Scraps already exists and this mod still has a lot of development to go through before I'd consider it done. Also totally agree with you with the glue system. I was planning on making a small mod that gave a small chance for clutter to drop when broken in addition to the current system but SDR has all my attention at the moment.

I would like to keep this mod mostly my own for the sake of balance and having full creative liberty. But if you have any suggestions for recipes, changes or whatever you can always put them in the comments here. If and when I start up a Github I'll definetly look into anything you decide to send my way.

Oh my god, I was planning to make something like this myself, makes me happy seeing I wasn't the only one bothered by lack of disassembly recipies ;w; do you maybe have a github? It would probs make submitting bug reports as well as suggestions too. I was thinking of adding possibility to recycle various clutter blocks (as well as revising what is necessary to pick them up intact, as glue-ing everything just feels wrong), so perhaps instead of making a separate mod, I could submit parts to your mod? Unless you'd prefer to keep this mostly a your project, then I will make my own version

Between this and Scraps, the "junk trunk that everyone winds up shoving in a corner somewhere" may finally become obsolete.

Kudamas

Thank you for the kind words. Hope you enjoy the mod! :)

I feel like you wrote about me in the mod description. I'm such a pack rat. I'm very excited to try this out! Love the art in your pics too!

Trungad

Fixed that bug with the fences. I accidentally made the file names the same and they overit each other.

This mod accidently removes recipies from the game. Fences are uncraftable.

Mine too 😅

Hell yeah, now my friends can stop making fun of me for wanting to keep everything and giving the excuse "it might have a use" now it DOES have a use HA. Thanks for the mod, hope all goes well, I'll be adding this to the server